• Taxes, subsidies and market failure

What is tax incidence?

Written with AI (How we create content)Target level: Grade 11Last updated: Report an error
Quick answer

Tax incidence is who really bears the burden of a tax, buyers or sellers, whatever the law says about who pays it to the state. A tax on a good raises the price buyers pay and lowers the price sellers keep; the side with the less elastic curve, the one less able to walk away, bears the larger share.

The topic explained

Who pays and who bears

The law names who hands a tax to the state: a VAT is paid by the seller, as when Israel's rate rose from 17% to 18% in January 2025. That is the statutory incidence. Tax incidence in the economic sense asks who really bears it: how far the price buyers pay rises, and how far the price sellers keep falls.

Take market A: Qd=100−5PQ_d = 100 - 5P and Qs=5P−20Q_s = 5P - 20 meet at ₪12 and 40 units. A tax of ₪4 per unit, collected from sellers, means they need ₪4 more for each quantity: supply becomes Qs=5(P−4)−20=5P−40Q_s = 5(P - 4) - 20 = 5P - 40. Now 100−5P=5P−40100 - 5P = 5P - 40 gives P=14P = 14 for buyers and ₪10 left for sellers, with 30 units sold. Buyers bear ₪2 and sellers ₪2.

Market A with demand Qd = 100 − 5P and supply Qs = 5P − 20, meeting at 40 units and ₪12. A ₪4 tax shifts supply up to S + tax: buyers pay ₪14, sellers keep ₪10, 30 units are sold. The revenue rectangle and the deadweight loss triangle are shaded.QuantityPrice (₪)102030405060708024681012141618200revenueDWLDSS + tax
Equal slopes: buyers and sellers each bear ₪2 of the ₪4 tax. Revenue ₪120; deadweight loss (DWL) ₪20.

Elasticity decides the shares

In market B demand is steeper, Qd=64−2PQ_d = 64 - 2P, and supply is Qs=6P−32Q_s = 6P - 32; it too starts at ₪12 and 40 units. With the same ₪4 tax, 64−2P=6(P−4)−3264 - 2P = 6(P - 4) - 32 gives P=15P = 15: buyers bear ₪3 and sellers only ₪1. The rule: the side that responds less to price, the more inelastic side, bears more of the tax, because it cannot easily buy or sell less.

That is why taxes on fuel and cigarettes, whose demand is inelastic, fall mostly on consumers, while a tax on a good with many close substitutes falls more on producers.

A table comparing two markets with the same ₪4 tax and the same starting point, ₪12: in market A buyers pay ₪14 and sellers keep ₪10, half each; in market B, with steeper demand, buyers pay ₪15 and sellers keep ₪11, three quarters on buyers.Market AMarket BDemandQd = 100 − 5PQd = 64 − 2PPrice buyers pay₪12 → ₪14₪12 → ₪15Price sellers keep₪12 → ₪10₪12 → ₪11Buyers' sharehalfthree quarters

Who remits does not matter

Suppose the same ₪4 were collected from buyers instead. Demand would fall by ₪4 at every quantity, and the market would settle where buyers pay ₪14 in all, ₪10 of it to sellers: the same 30 units and the same shares. The law can choose who writes the check, not who bears the burden.

The state collects 4⋅30=1204 \cdot 30 = 120 shekels, the rectangle on the graph. But 10 units that buyers valued above their cost are no longer traded: the triangle 12⋅4⋅10=20\frac{1}{2} \cdot 4 \cdot 10 = 20 is the deadweight loss of the tax.

A flow: the tax is collected from sellers; the supply curve moves up by the tax; the price rises by less than the tax, so both buyers and sellers pay part of it.Tax on sellersSupply moves upBoth sides pay

Common mistakes

Assuming the price rises by the full tax: it does so only if demand is perfectly inelastic or supply perfectly elastic. Shifting the demand curve when the tax is collected from sellers: it is the supply curve that moves up by the tax. And forgetting that the quantity falls, so the revenue is the tax times the new quantity, not the old one.

Free printable worksheet

Practice: tax incidence

For 11th grade economics students. Use the equations, graph and tables on the sheet, show each calculation, then check against the answers.

Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.

Free printable worksheetlessoons.com
Practice: tax incidenceName:
  1. Explain the difference between the statutory incidence and the economic incidence of a tax.

  2. In market B, Qd=64−2PQ_d = 64 - 2P and Qs=6P−32Q_s = 6P - 32, and a tax of ₪4 is collected from sellers. Find the price buyers pay, the price sellers keep and the quantity.

    Market B with demand Qd = 64 − 2P, supply Qs = 6P − 32 and supply plus a ₪4 tax; dots mark the old equilibrium at 40 units and ₪12 and the two prices at 34 units.QuantityPrice (₪)102030405060481216202428320DSS + tax
  3. Fill in the table for market B. Which side bears more of the tax, and why?

    A table for market B with a ₪4 tax: the buyers' share, the sellers' share and the tax revenue, each marked with a question mark.Market B with a ₪4 taxValueBuyers' share of the tax?Sellers' share of the tax?Tax revenue?
  4. In market A the tax cut the quantity from 40 to 30 units. Compute the deadweight loss and explain what it means.

  5. Demand for a good is perfectly inelastic. A tax of ₪3 is collected from sellers. By how much does the price buyers pay rise?

  6. Fill in the middle box: what happens on the graph when the tax is collected from buyers instead of sellers?

    A flow with a blank: a tax is collected from buyers; the middle box is a question mark; both sides pay, as before.Tax on buyers?Both sides pay
  7. Israel's VAT rose from 17% to 18% in January 2025. Write a short paragraph: what determines how much of such a rise is borne by consumers and how much by sellers?

More topics and worksheets at lessoons.com© 2026 Lessons

Common questions

Do consumers always pay the tax?

No. Consumers bear a larger share when their demand is inelastic, and sellers bear more when supply is inelastic or demand elastic. Usually the burden is shared.

Why does a tax create a deadweight loss?

It drives a wedge between the price buyers pay and the price sellers keep, so some trades worth more than their cost stop. The value of those lost trades is the deadweight loss.

Does it matter whether the law taxes buyers or sellers?

Not for the final burden. Taxing buyers shifts demand down, taxing sellers shifts supply up, and both lead to the same quantity and the same shares of the tax.

How do you find the shares from the equations?

Solve for the new equilibrium with the tax, then compare: the rise in the buyers' price is their share, and the fall in the sellers' price is theirs. The two shares add up to the tax.

How is tax incidence asked on the bagrut?

Students shift a curve by the tax, find the new prices and quantity, compute each side's share, the revenue and the deadweight loss, and explain the role of elasticity.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi

Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.

Try asking

Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.

Learn it with a teacher

Learn this topic live with Lessi

Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.