- Taxes, subsidies and market failure
What is a subsidy in economics?
A subsidy is a payment by the government for each unit of a good produced or bought. It works like a tax in reverse: buyers pay a lower price, sellers receive a higher one, and more is traded. The benefit is shared, the less elastic side gaining more, and the state pays for every unit sold, usually more than the gain it creates.
The topic explained
A tax in reverse
A subsidy in economics is a sum the government pays for each unit of a good, to the seller or to the buyer. Paid to sellers, it lets them accept a lower price from buyers for each quantity: the supply curve moves down by the subsidy.
Take market A: and meet at ₪7 and 50 units. A subsidy of ₪2 a unit makes supply . Now gives for buyers; sellers receive shekels; 60 units are sold.
Who gains, and what it costs
Buyers pay ₪1 less and sellers receive ₪1 more: with equal slopes they share the subsidy equally. As with a tax, the less elastic side gains more. The state pays shekels, the rectangle on the graph.
The gains are smaller than the cost. Buyers gain in consumer surplus and sellers 55 in producer surplus, 110 in all. The other 10 pays for the extra 10 units, which cost more to produce than buyers value them: a deadweight loss of .
Why governments subsidize anyway
The calculation above assumes the market was efficient to begin with. Often it is not. When a good brings benefits to people other than the buyer, such as vaccinations, public transport that cuts traffic and pollution, or research that other firms learn from, the market produces too little, and a subsidy can bring it closer to the efficient quantity. Governments, Israel's among them, also subsidize to make basic goods affordable or to support a young industry.
Critics answer that subsidies are costly, paid for by taxes that have their own deadweight loss, that they are hard to remove once given, and that they may help sellers more than the people they were meant for.
Common mistakes
Assuming buyers get the whole subsidy: the price falls by less than the subsidy unless supply is perfectly elastic. Shifting supply up instead of down. And computing the cost on the old quantity: the state pays for every unit sold after the subsidy, 60 here, not 50.
Practice: subsidies
For 11th grade economics students. Use the equations, graph and tables on the sheet, show each calculation, then check against the answers.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
Define a subsidy per unit, and say which curve it moves and in which direction when it is paid to sellers.
In market B, and , and sellers receive a subsidy of ₪5 a unit. Find the price buyers pay, the price sellers receive and the quantity.
Fill in the table for market B. Who gains more from the subsidy, and why?
Compute the deadweight loss of the subsidy in market B.
In market A, the subsidy cost ₪120 and the gains to buyers and sellers were ₪110. Where did the other ₪10 go?
Fill in the middle box of the flow, and explain when such a subsidy may be worth its cost.
Write a short paragraph: should the government subsidize public transport fares? Give one argument for and one against.
Common questions
Is a subsidy the opposite of a tax?
In its effect on the graph, yes: a tax moves supply up and raises the price buyers pay; a subsidy moves it down and lowers that price. Both drive a wedge between buyers' and sellers' prices, and both create a deadweight loss in an efficient market.
Do consumers get the whole subsidy?
Rarely. The subsidy is shared between buyers and sellers, and the side whose curve is less elastic gains more. Buyers get it all only if supply is perfectly elastic.
When is a subsidy efficient?
When the good brings benefits to people other than the buyer, a positive externality, so the market produces too little. A subsidy equal to that external benefit can bring the market to the efficient quantity.
How is the cost of a subsidy calculated?
The subsidy per unit times the quantity sold after the subsidy. On the graph it is the rectangle between the two prices, up to the new quantity.
How are subsidies asked on the bagrut?
Students shift supply by the subsidy, find the new prices and quantity, compute each side's gain, the cost to the state and the deadweight loss, and discuss when a subsidy is justified.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.