- Social studies
- Grade 11
Jewish Thought: Prophecy and Revelation – 11th Grade
According to Maimonides, the Israelites believed in Moses not because of his miracles, which could be suspected as tricks, but because of the revelation at Mount Sinai: the whole people saw and heard God speak to Moses. How the tradition understands God speaking to people: the revelation at Sinai as the ground of faith, the tests of a true prophet, why prophecy ended and the sages took its place, and what the prophets demanded of the people.
All lessons in Jewish Thought: Prophecy and Revelation (in learning order)
Common questions
Why did the Israelites believe in Moses?
According to Maimonides, the Israelites believed in Moses not because of his miracles, which could be suspected as tricks, but because of the revelation at Mount Sinai: the whole people saw and heard God speak to Moses. They became witnesses, not followers of a wonder-worker, and a faith built on what you witnessed lasts for ever.
How can you tell a true prophet from a false prophet?
The Torah gives two tests for telling a true prophet from a false prophet: whether his predictions come true (Deuteronomy 18), and whether his message keeps faith with God, since even a sign cannot prove a prophet who calls to idolatry (Deuteronomy 13). Maimonides adds that only a promise of good is a clear test, because a threat may be canceled by repentance.
Why did prophecy end?
According to the sages, prophecy ended with the last prophets, Haggai, Zechariah and Malachi, early in the Second Temple period, and after the Temple's destruction the authority to teach God's will passed to the sages. From then on the Torah was decided by study, argument and the majority, not by visions, as the story of the oven of Achnai shows.
Did the prophets reject the sacrifices?
Most traditional readers say the prophets did not reject the sacrifices but rejected offerings brought by people who did injustice: Isaiah, Amos, Hosea and Micah set justice and kindness before worship. Some modern scholars read them as opposing sacrifice altogether. The verses themselves condemn worship cut off from justice, and the same prophets still picture a Temple.
What does Jewish Thought: Prophecy and Revelation for 11th Grade cover?
How the tradition understands God speaking to people: the revelation at Sinai as the ground of faith, the tests of a true prophet, why prophecy ended and the sages took its place, and what the prophets demanded of the people. The unit includes 6 ordered lessons covering Sinai and the faith in Moses, True and false prophets, The end of prophecy and the authority of the sages, The prophets and the sacrifices.