- Jewish Thought: Modern Thinkers
What was Rav Kook's philosophy?
Rav Kook's philosophy (1865–1935) sees all of reality as one whole, in which the holy and the secular are not enemies: above both stands the holy of holies, which carries them together. So he read the return to Zion, even its secular pioneers, as part of a whole people's renewal and repentance, and hoped that the old would be renewed and the new made holy.
The topic explained
The holy, the secular and the holy of holies
Rabbi Avraham Yitzhak HaCohen Kook was born in 1865 in what is now Latvia. In 1904 he was called to be rabbi of Jaffa, and in 1921 he became the first Ashkenazi chief rabbi of the Land of Israel. At the heart of Rav Kook's philosophy is unity: everything flows from one source, so the holy and the secular are not two alien worlds. Every study and every spiritual ascent, he wrote, “צריכים להיות בנוים על היסוד של ההרגשה הטבעית” (must be built on the foundation of natural feeling, Orot HaKodesh 1:48), and above both stands “קודש הקדשים, שהוא נושא בתוכו את הנושא של הקודש ואת הנושא של החול” (the holy of holies, which carries within it both the holy and the secular).
The idea he is best known for is that the old should be renewed and the new made holy. A common mistake is to think he made the secular equal to the holy or gave up the commandments. He kept them, and wanted to raise the secular toward the holy, not erase the difference.
The land and the pioneers
In Orot (1920) he wrote “ארץ ישראל איננה דבר חיצוני, קנין חיצוני לאמה” (the Land of Israel is not an external thing, an external possession of the nation, Orot, Land of Israel 1). So he saw the work of settlement as a religious act, even when secular Jews did it. Many rabbis condemned the pioneers; Rav Kook praised “אותו החיל החלוץ ההולך ובונה את ארץ האבות” (that pioneering band that goes on building the land of the fathers, Orot HaTechiya 5), which keeps the commandments tied to the land through its work.
This is how he describes the way of the righteous: they “אינם קובלים על הכפירה, אלא מוסיפים אמונה” (do not complain about heresy, but add faith, Shemonah Kevatzim 2:99). Instead of fighting unbelief from outside, add light from within.
Souls of chaos and a nation's repentance
In the chapter The Souls of the World of Chaos in Orot, he sets “ההדרכה הרגילה של תום ויושר, בשמירת המדות הטובות וכל דת ודין” (the usual guidance of integrity and decency, keeping good traits and every law), the way of the world of order, against those who break all limits. “נשמות דתוהו גבוהות הן מנשמות דתיקון” (the souls of chaos are higher than the souls of order): they seek a vast light, so they shatter every frame. Even so, “תמצית האומץ שיש ברצונם היא הנקודה של קודש” (the essence of the courage in their will is the point of holiness). The revolt of the rebels of his generation was, for him, a life force to repair, not to drive out.
Hence a nation's repentance: “כמקרה הנשמה בגוף האיש היחידי, ככה הוא מקרה הרוח, המחולל תנועה בקרב עם שלם” (as with the soul in the body of a single person, so with the spirit that moves a whole people, in his article To Repentance). Repentance is also the return of the whole movement “with all its branches” to its source: a whole people returning to its holy origin.
Objections from both sides
When Orot appeared, Rabbis Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld and Yitzhak Yerucham Diskin, leaders of the Haredi Edah HaCharedit, published a call against it over its views of secular Jews, Zionism, the holy and the secular, and some Haredi circles forbade reading it. From the other side, many secular Jews do not want their deeds read as a religious mission that is not theirs: the journalist Sefi Rachlevsky argued in The Messiah's Donkey (1998) that Rav Kook's disciples treat the secular as a mere tool.
His yeshiva, Mercaz HaRav, founded in Jerusalem in 1924, carried his teaching on. A strong answer states his position in his own words, then each objection fairly.
Practice: Rav Kook's philosophy
For 12th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the quotations printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
What office did Rav Kook hold from 1921, and when was his book Orot published?
Rav Kook is known for the idea that the old should be renewed and the new made holy. Explain both halves of the idea in your own words.
Of the highest level Rav Kook writes “שהוא נושא בתוכו את הנושא של הקודש ואת הנושא של החול” (which carries within it both the holy and the secular; Orot HaKodesh 1:48). What belongs in the top box of the diagram, and what does it teach?
“ארץ ישראל איננה דבר חיצוני, קנין חיצוני לאמה” (the Land of Israel is not an external thing, an external possession of the nation; Orot, Land of Israel 1). What view does Rav Kook reject, and what is his own?
Fill in the world of chaos column of the table.
The righteous “אינם קובלים על הכפירה, אלא מוסיפים אמונה” (do not complain about heresy, but add faith; Shemonah Kevatzim 2:99). How does this explain Rav Kook's attitude to the secular pioneers?
In his article To Repentance Rav Kook writes “כמקרה הנשמה בגוף האיש היחידי, ככה הוא מקרה הרוח, המחולל תנועה בקרב עם שלם” (as with the soul in the body of a single person, so with the spirit that moves a whole people). What is new in the idea of a nation's repentance?
Write a paragraph: present Rav Kook's reading of the secular pioneers, one religious and one secular objection to it, and say which objection you find stronger and why.
Common questions
What does Rav Kook's idea of renewing the old and making the new holy mean?
It is the idea Rav Kook is best known for: tradition must be renewed and speak to life today, and the new things of the age, such as science and national revival, must be made holy and connected to the holy.
Why did Rav Kook support the secular pioneers?
He saw building the land as a religious act that keeps the commandments tied to it, and found a point of holiness in the courage of their revolt. For him national revival was part of a process of redemption and repentance, even when those doing it were not religious.
Who opposed the book Orot?
Rabbis Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld and Yitzhak Yerucham Diskin, leaders of the Haredi Edah HaCharedit, published a call against it over its views of secular Jews, Zionism, the holy and the secular, and some Haredi circles forbade reading it.
How is Rav Kook different from Leibowitz?
Rav Kook saw national revival and the building of the land as a process with religious meaning. Leibowitz, who lived after him, held that the state has no religious value in itself and called for separating religion from the state.
What is Mercaz HaRav?
A yeshiva Rav Kook founded in Jerusalem in 1924. After his death in 1935 his students went on teaching his thought there, and it became an important center of religious Zionism.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.