- Jewish Thought: Modern Thinkers
What makes the Jews a nation in modern Jewish thought?
Modern Jewish thinkers gave different answers to what makes the Jews a nation. For Ahad Ha'am it is a shared spirit and culture; for A. D. Gordon, life and labor on the land; for Rav Kook, the holy within the nation's life; for Rabbi Soloveitchik, a shared fate and a shared destiny; and for Leibowitz, as for Saadia long before, the Torah and its commandments.
The topic explained
An old answer and a new question
In the tenth century the answer was simple. Saadia Gaon wrote: “כי אומתנו איננה אומה כי אם בתורותיה” (for our nation is a nation only by its laws, its Torot, Emunot ve-Deot 3:7). The Jews were one people because they shared the Torah and kept its commandments.
In the nineteenth century many Jews in Europe stopped keeping the commandments, and many still felt Jewish. What, then, makes the Jews a nation? Modern Jewish thought answers in at least five ways. The common mistake is to think all of them mean the same thing by nation: for some it is a culture, for others a covenant.
Spirit, labor and the person
Ahad Ha'am (1856–1927), in our words, held that the Jews are a nation by a shared national spirit, expressed in language, literature and values, which a spiritual center in the Land of Israel would renew for Jews everywhere. Religion, for him, was one creation of that spirit, not its source, and the revival of Hebrew was the spirit at work. A religious reader sees the difficulty at once: if the national spirit created religion, religion is a human creation.
A. D. Gordon (1856–1922) found the nation's renewal in life and physical labor on its own land. Yet he set a limit: “את האדם אסור להקריב אפילו על מזבח האומה” (a person may not be sacrificed even on the altar of the nation, On Self-Education and the Work of Revival). The nation serves the person, not the other way round.
The holy within the nation
Rav Kook (1865–1935) refused to separate the nation from faith. In Orot he writes: “הנטיה הלאומית המעשית של כנסת ישראל היא לבושה החיצון של הנטיה הרוחנית שלה” (the practical national tendency of Knesset Israel is the outer garment of its spiritual tendency, Orot Yisrael, Le'umiyut Yisrael 1). Even secular nationalism, in his view, carries a holy core it may not know. This is how he could embrace the secular pioneers: their love of the people and the land was, for him, holy work even when they denied it. Secular readers object that he reads into them a faith they reject.
He also sets Jewish nationhood apart: “הלאומיות הישראלית היא מיוסדת ע"פ תביעה מוסרית גדולה ועמוקה” (Israel's nationhood is founded on a great and deep moral demand, 3). For Ahad Ha'am the spirit made religion; for Rav Kook the divine gives the nation its spirit.
Fate and destiny, or Torah alone
Rabbi Soloveitchik, in Kol Dodi Dofek (1956), described two covenants in our words: a covenant of fate, made in Egypt, the shared suffering that binds every Jew, religious or not; and a covenant of destiny, made at Sinai, a shared purpose a person chooses to take on. The first makes the Jews a people; the second makes them a holy nation.
Leibowitz returned to Saadia: historically, the Jewish people was the people that kept the Torah and its commandments, and a Jewish nationhood without them is, in his view, something new. Critics answer each side: a bond made only of shared suffering is thin, and a definition by Torah alone leaves out many Jews who see themselves as part of the people. A strong answer sets two of these positions against each other on one question.
Practice: what makes the Jews a nation
For 11th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
Saadia Gaon writes: “כי אומתנו איננה אומה כי אם בתורותיה” (our nation is a nation only by its Torot, its laws, Emunot ve-Deot 3:7). Explain the sentence in your own words.
Fill in the two empty boxes in the table of thinkers.
Why did the question of what makes the Jews a nation become sharp in the nineteenth century?
A. D. Gordon writes: “את האדם אסור להקריב אפילו על מזבח האומה” (a person may not be sacrificed even on the altar of the nation). What limit does he set on nationalism?
Name the two thinkers replaced by question marks on the line from faith to culture.
Rav Kook writes: “הנטיה הלאומית המעשית של כנסת ישראל היא לבושה החיצון של הנטיה הרוחנית שלה” (the practical national tendency of Knesset Israel is the outer garment of its spiritual tendency). How does his view differ from Ahad Ha'am's?
Fill in the empty box under the covenant of destiny.
Write a paragraph: choose two thinkers from this sheet who disagree on what makes the Jews a nation, present each in his own terms, and argue for one.
Common questions
Is Judaism a religion or a nationality?
Modern Jewish thinkers disagree. Saadia and Leibowitz tie the nation to the Torah; Ahad Ha'am and Gordon see a nation of culture and life; Rav Kook joins the two; Soloveitchik speaks of a shared fate and a chosen destiny.
What are the covenant of fate and the covenant of destiny?
In Kol Dodi Dofek (1956) Rabbi Soloveitchik distinguishes the covenant of fate, made in Egypt, the shared suffering of all Jews, from the covenant of destiny, made at Sinai, a shared purpose and way of life a person chooses.
Why are some thinkers quoted and others not?
Writers who died at least seventy years ago, such as Saadia, Gordon and Rav Kook, can be quoted. Soloveitchik and Leibowitz are still under copyright, so their views are given in our own words.
What did A. D. Gordon mean by the altar of the nation?
He warned against nationalism that demands the sacrifice of individuals. For Gordon the national revival is meant to renew the whole person, so a person may never be sacrificed for the nation.
How do I answer an exam question on the nation in modern Jewish thought?
Define the question, present two thinkers who answer it differently in their own terms, quote or paraphrase each accurately, show the point where they part, and give your reasoned view with an answer to an objection.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.