- Sociology: deviance and social control
What is Merton's strain theory?
Merton's strain theory (1938) explains deviance by the gap between the goals a culture holds up, above all success and wealth, and the legitimate means it gives people to reach them. Where the means are blocked, people feel strain and adapt in one of five ways: conformity, innovation, ritualism, retreatism or rebellion. Only conformity is not deviant.
The topic explained
Goals, means and the strain between them
The American sociologist Robert K. Merton set out his theory in an article called Social Structure and Anomie (1938). Every culture, he wrote, tells its members what is worth striving for, its cultural goals, and which ways of getting there are acceptable, its institutional means. In the United States he saw a culture that pressed everyone toward the same goal, money and success, while the legitimate means to it, a good education and a well paid job, were open to some far more than to others.
That gap creates strain, and Merton took Durkheim's word anomie for the result: a state in which the norms about means lose their hold, because the goal matters more than the rules. The misreading to avoid: Merton does not say that poor people are deviant. He says that a social structure which promises the same goal to everyone and hands out the means unequally puts pressure on the people with the fewest means.
The five adaptations
People respond to the strain in five ways, depending on whether they accept or reject the goals and the means. Conformity accepts both: Yael studies hard and works her way up. It is by far the most common adaptation, Merton noted, or society could not hold together. Innovation accepts the goal and rejects the means: someone who wants to be rich and cheats on taxes or commits fraud. Ritualism gives up the goal and keeps the means: an official who has stopped hoping for promotion and follows every rule to the letter. Retreatism rejects both and withdraws from society. Rebellion rejects both and puts new goals and means in their place, as in a movement that aims to replace the system.
Reading a case with the theory
On an exam the method has three steps. First, name the goal the person accepts or rejects. Second, name the means: are they legitimate, and are they open to this person? Third, place the case. A student who copies a classmate's project to get a high grade accepts the goal, a good grade, and rejects the legitimate means, his own work: that is innovation. A clerk who no longer cares about results but insists on every form being filled in triplicate is a ritualist: deviant, Merton said, even though she breaks no rule.
That last point is easy to miss. Ritualism is deviance from the cultural goal, not from the rules, which shows that Merton's idea of deviance is wider than crime.
What the theory explains, and what it misses
Strain theory explains why deviance is patterned: why it rises when opportunities shrink, and why much crime aims at money. Its critics point to what it misses. Albert Cohen, in Delinquent Boys (1955), argued that much youth delinquency, such as vandalism, brings no money at all and is done in groups, as a search for status. Richard Cloward and Lloyd Ohlin (1960) added that illegitimate means are unequally available too. Robert Agnew's general strain theory (1992) widened strain beyond money. And many people under heavy strain never deviate, which the theory alone cannot explain.
Practice: Merton's strain theory
For 11th grade students of sociology. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
Fill in the missing link in Merton's chain.
Complete the table: what does each adaptation do with the goals and the means?
Which adaptation is each case? (a) Gal wants a high salary and studies for a profession that pays well. (b) A salesman who wants to meet his target lies to customers about a product. (c) A teacher who stopped believing her students can improve still marks every exercise exactly on time. (d) A group founds a community that rejects money as a goal and lives by sharing.
Write the two missing adaptations in the grid.
Why does Merton count ritualism as deviance even though the ritualist breaks no rule?
Complete the table: what did Albert Cohen add to strain theory?
Write a paragraph evaluating strain theory: one thing it explains well and one thing it misses, with an example of each.
Common questions
What is anomie in Merton's theory?
For Merton, anomie is the breakdown of the norms about means that follows when a culture stresses a goal more than the rules for reaching it. He took the word from Durkheim, for whom it meant a state in which norms no longer regulate people.
Which of Merton's adaptations is the most common?
Conformity. Merton wrote that most people accept both the goals and the means, otherwise society could not hold together. The other four adaptations are forms of deviance.
What is the difference between innovation and rebellion?
Innovation keeps the cultural goal, such as wealth, and uses illegitimate means to reach it. Rebellion rejects both the goal and the means and tries to put new goals and new means in their place.
Does strain theory explain white collar crime?
In part. Innovation covers fraud by people who already have legitimate means, if the goal of ever more success drives them. Critics say the theory was built for blocked opportunity and fits crimes of the well off less naturally.
How is Merton's theory different from labeling theory?
Merton asks why people deviate, and finds the cause in the social structure. Labeling theory asks how others react to deviance, and how a label can push a person into further deviance.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.