- Sociology: deviance and social control
What is labeling theory in sociology?
Labeling theory says that deviance depends on how others react to an act, not only on the act itself. Howard Becker (1963) argued that groups create deviance by making rules and applying them to particular people. Edwin Lemert (1951) showed how a public label can turn a single act, primary deviance, into an identity that leads to more, secondary deviance.
The topic explained
The idea: deviance is in the reaction
Most theories of deviance ask why a person broke a rule. Labeling theory, part of the interactionist school of sociology, asks a different question: why are some acts and some people called deviant, and what does the name do to them? The American sociologist Howard Becker gave the classic answer in Outsiders (1963). Groups create deviance, he argued, by making the rules whose breaking counts as deviance and by applying those rules to particular people, who then become outsiders. Deviance, in his account, is not a quality of the act but of the reaction to it: the deviant is the person to whom the label has successfully been applied.
The misreading to avoid: labeling theory does not claim that labeled people did nothing. It claims that the same act can lead to very different futures, depending on who notices it and how they respond.
Lemert: primary and secondary deviance
Edwin Lemert, in Social Pathology (1951), separated two stages. Primary deviance is an act of rule breaking that has no lasting effect on how a person sees himself: almost everyone has done something of the kind. Secondary deviance follows a public reaction. Imagine Ido, a 15-year-old who takes a phone charger from a shop on a dare. If no one notices, it stays primary deviance. If he is caught, named in front of his class and kept away by other parents, he may come to see himself as the label says, drift toward friends who accept him, and break more rules. The label has become part of his identity.
Sociologists describe the last step as a self-fulfilling prophecy: a label, believed by others and then by the person, helps bring about the behavior it predicted.
Becker: who makes the rules, and who is caught
Becker drew attention to the people who make rules. He called them moral entrepreneurs: the rule creators who campaign for a new law, and the rule enforcers, such as police officers, who apply it. His case was the Marihuana Tax Act of 1937 in the United States, which followed a campaign by the Federal Bureau of Narcotics. He also showed that being labeled and breaking a rule are two different things, and sorted behavior into four types: the conforming, who obey and are seen to obey; the pure deviant, who breaks a rule and is seen to; the falsely accused, labeled for something they did not do; and the secret deviant, who breaks a rule and is never noticed. Official statistics count only the people who were noticed.
What the critics say
Critics raise three objections. The theory explains secondary deviance but not the first act: why did Ido take the charger at all? It can be too fixed, since many labeled people reject the label and change course. And it says little about victims: a burglary harms someone whatever label is attached. A strong answer gives the theory its credit as well. It explains why the same act leads to different outcomes, and it is one reason many justice systems try to keep young first offenders away from court records.
Practice: labeling theory
For 11th grade students of sociology. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
Fill in the missing step in the path from primary to secondary deviance.
Primary or secondary deviance? (a) Maya once skips a lesson and no one finds out. (b) Ron, called the class troublemaker by all his teachers, starts to act the part, telling friends it is who he is. (c) Avi copies one answer in a quiz in 9th grade and never does it again.
Complete the table: what happens to the self-image in each kind of deviance?
Write the two missing types in Becker's grid.
What did Becker mean by moral entrepreneurs? Give the two kinds and an example of each.
Complete the table: which criticism asks why Ido took the charger in the first place?
A school decides that a student caught breaking a rule for the first time will meet the counselor instead of being suspended. Write a paragraph explaining the decision with labeling theory, and add one criticism.
Common questions
Who founded labeling theory?
Frank Tannenbaum's Crime and the Community (1938) is often named as its beginning. Edwin Lemert (1951) added primary and secondary deviance, and Howard Becker's Outsiders (1963) made the theory famous.
What is the difference between primary and secondary deviance?
Primary deviance is rule breaking that does not change how a person sees himself. Secondary deviance follows a public label: the person accepts the deviant identity and the deviance continues because of it.
What is a self-fulfilling prophecy in labeling theory?
A prediction that comes true because people act on it. When others treat someone as a deviant, and the person comes to believe it, the label helps produce the behavior it predicted.
Does labeling theory say criminals are innocent?
No. It says that the reaction to an act shapes what happens next, and that being labeled is not the same as breaking a rule: some rule breakers are never labeled and some people are labeled falsely.
Which school of sociology does labeling theory belong to?
Symbolic interactionism, which studies how people give meaning to each other's actions in interaction. It differs from functionalism, which asks what deviance does for society, and from Merton's strain theory.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.