- Jewish Thought: The Classical Thinkers
What did the Ramban say about hidden miracles?
For the Ramban, hidden miracles are miracles that change nothing visible in nature: rain that falls in its season for those who serve God, success for those who keep the commandments. The open miracles of the Exodus exist to lead people to acknowledge the hidden ones, which he calls the foundation of the whole Torah (commentary on Exodus 13:16).
The topic explained
Two kinds of miracle
The Ramban (Rabbi Moses ben Nachman, 1194–c. 1270), a rabbi, physician and kabbalist from Girona in Catalonia, sets two kinds of miracle apart. A revealed miracle changes nature before everyone's eyes: the ten plagues, the splitting of the sea, the manna. In his words these are “שהם מופתים משנים הטבע בפירסום” (wonders that change nature in public, on Genesis 17:1). A hidden miracle changes nothing visible: “כי אין מן הטבע שיבואו הגשמים בעתם בעבדנו האלהים” (it is not from nature that the rains come in their time when we serve God, same place).
So hidden miracles are not rare. They are the blessings and curses of the Torah (Leviticus 26, Deuteronomy 28), promised to the whole people and to the single person. A common mistake is to think a hidden miracle is a small miracle nobody noticed. For the Ramban it is the ordinary course of life itself, run by God's decree.
Why the great miracles were needed
On Exodus 13:16 the Ramban explains that people's beliefs went astray long ago. Some “כופרים בעיקר ואומרים כי העולם קדמון” (deny the root and say the world is eternal), some deny that God knows the details, and some accept that God knows but deny providence. One public miracle answers them all: “כי המופת הנפלא מורה שיש לעולם אלוה מחדשו ויודע ומשגיח ויכול” (the wondrous sign shows that the world has a God who made it new, who knows, watches over and is able). If a prophet foretold it, it proves prophecy too.
But “ובעבור כי הקב״ה לא יעשה אות ומופת בכל דור” (the Holy One does not perform a sign and wonder in every generation). So the Torah commands remembrance: tefillin, the mezuzah, Passover, the sukkah, and recalling the Exodus morning and evening. “כי הקונה מזוזה בזוז אחד וקבעה בפתחו ונתכוון בענינה” (one who buys a mezuzah for a coin, fixes it on his doorway and has its meaning in mind), he writes, has already acknowledged creation, God's knowledge and providence.
Everything is a miracle
The key sentence: “ומן הנסים הגדולים המפורסמים אדם מודה בנסים הנסתרים שהם יסוד התורה כלה” (from the great, famous miracles a person comes to acknowledge the hidden miracles, which are the foundation of the whole Torah). No one has a share in the Torah of Moses, he adds, until they believe that all that happens to the many and to the individual is miracle, with no nature in it.
This does not mean the world looks wondrous. Hidden miracles happen while “שעולם כמנהגו נוהג עמהם” (the world runs its usual course with them, on Leviticus 26:11), and they become visible only when they recur over a whole land and people. In the same passage he writes “כי התורה לא תסמוך דיניה על הנסים” (the Torah does not base its laws on miracles). Scholars still debate how far he meant that there is no nature at all; some argue he did accept a natural order.
The Ramban and Maimonides
Maimonides (1138–1204) explained miracles differently. In his commentary on the Mishnah (Avot 5:6) he wrote that God “בתחלת עשיית הדברים שם בטבע שיעשה בהם כל מה שיעשה” (at the very beginning placed in nature all it would do), even the splitting of the sea. Of the days of the Messiah he wrote “עולם כמנהגו נוהג” (the world runs its usual course, Laws of Kings 12:1), and in the Guide (3:18): “ההשגחה נמשכת אחר השכל” (providence follows the intellect).
Both believe in creation and providence; they differ on how God acts. For Maimonides God works through a nature he made, for the Ramban God's decree stands behind nature at every moment. A religious reader may find in the Ramban a way to see God in daily life; a secular reader may see a way of interpreting events that observation can neither prove nor refute, which is what hidden means.
Practice: the Ramban on hidden miracles
For 11th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the quotations printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
Who was the Ramban, and what was his work?
Fill in the hidden miracle column of the table.
The Ramban writes: “כי אין מן הטבע שיבואו הגשמים בעתם בעבדנו האלהים” (it is not from nature that the rains come in their time when we serve God, on Genesis 17:1). Why is rain in its season a miracle for the Ramban?
On Exodus 13:16 he writes: “כי המופת הנפלא מורה שיש לעולם אלוה מחדשו ויודע ומשגיח ויכול” (the wondrous sign shows that the world has a God who made it new, who knows, watches over and is able). Which three mistaken views does a miracle refute?
He adds: “ובעבור כי הקב״ה לא יעשה אות ומופת בכל דור” (the Holy One does not perform a sign and wonder in every generation). What comes at step 2, between the miracles in Egypt and acknowledging the hidden miracles?
He also writes: “אם יעשה המצות יצליחנו שכרו ואם יעבור עליהם יכריתנו ענשו” (if he keeps the commandments his reward will make him prosper, and if he transgresses them his punishment will cut him off, on Exodus 13:16). How does this describe a hidden miracle in one person's life?
Maimonides writes that God “בתחלת עשיית הדברים שם בטבע שיעשה בהם כל מה שיעשה” (at the very beginning placed in nature all it would do, on Avot 5:6). How does his approach differ from the Ramban's?
Write a paragraph: can daily life be seen as hidden miracles? Give the Ramban's view with a quotation from this sheet, another view, and your own reasoned conclusion.
Common questions
What is the difference between a revealed miracle and a hidden miracle?
A revealed miracle changes nature before everyone, like the splitting of the sea. A hidden miracle changes nothing visible, like rain in its season for those who serve God. For the Ramban both are acts of God, and the hidden one is the foundation of the Torah.
Did the Ramban believe in nature at all?
He writes that with hidden miracles the world runs its usual course, and that the Torah does not base its laws on miracles. Scholars debate how far he meant there is no nature, and some hold that he accepted a natural order with God's decree behind it.
Was the Ramban against medicine?
On Leviticus 26:11 he describes an ideal time when the whole people is righteous and needs no doctors, but in the same passage he writes that the Torah gave the doctor permission to heal and that its laws do not rely on miracles. It is a theological view, not a practical instruction.
What does the mezuzah have to do with miracles?
For the Ramban God does not perform open miracles in every generation, so the Torah commands acts that recall the Exodus. A person who fixes a mezuzah with its meaning in mind has already acknowledged creation, God's knowledge and providence.
How does the Ramban disagree with Maimonides about miracles?
Maimonides wrote that miracles were set into nature during the six days of creation and that the world runs its usual course. The Ramban saw everything that happens, even what seems natural, as a hidden miracle decreed by God. Both believe in providence and differ on how it works.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.