- Jewish Thought: Zionist Thinkers
What did Herzl mean that Zionism is a return to Judaism?
In his opening speech at the First Zionist Congress in 1897, Herzl said that Zionism is a return to Judaism even before it is a return to the land of the Jews. He meant that assimilated Jews were coming home to their people and its identity, and that this inner return had to come first. Religious and cultural Zionists later read the sentence their own way.
The topic explained
A speech in Basel
On 29 August 1897 the First Zionist Congress opened in the Stadtcasino of Basel. It met for three days, with 208 participants from 17 countries, and its proceedings were in German. It founded the Zionist Organization and adopted the Basel Program: Zionism seeks a home for the Jewish people in Palestine, the Land of Israel, secured by public law.
Theodor Herzl (1860-1904) convened it. He had grown up in a German-speaking, assimilated Jewish family, worked as a journalist, and in 1896 published The Jewish State. In his diary a few days after the congress he wrote, in words we summarize, that at Basel he had founded the Jewish State. His opening speech, though, began with something else: not with the state, but with the question of who the Jews in the hall were and what they were looking for.
Home before the land
Herzl told the delegates that they had, so to speak, come home, and that Zionism is a return to Judaism even before it is a return to the land of the Jews. In the Hebrew translation of the speech the key words are “שיבה אל היהדות” (a return to Judaism). The returning sons, he said, find much in the house that needs repair, above all brothers living in deep poverty.
The sentence turns the usual order around. One might think that Zionism is first a political plan and only later, perhaps, a cultural matter. Herzl says the reverse: before the journey to the land comes a journey back to the people, by Jews who had drifted away from it. Antisemitism, he said, had revived a sense of belonging that had been falling apart. He spoke of modern, educated Jews who had left the ghetto and were hurt to the heart by the new hatred; the speech spoke to them: your way back to the people begins here.
What the return meant
Herzl gave two signs of this return. Zionism had joined the most modern and the most conservative elements of Judaism without either side giving up its dignity, and this, he said, showed that the Jews are a people. The congress would also seek spiritual means to revive Jewish national consciousness, without giving up any of the culture Jews had acquired. He also thanked the founders of the farming settlements in the Land of Israel and in Argentina, but called their work only the first word of the movement, not its last.
The common misreading is that Herzl was calling Jews back to religious observance. He was not: his Judaism here is peoplehood and identity. That is also why he echoed Pinsker: a people can help itself only by itself, and its future must rest on a legal right, not on toleration granted as a favor.
Readers of one sentence
Because the sentence is open, each stream of Zionism could claim it. Religious Zionists read a return to Judaism as a return to Torah and faith, and hoped the national movement would lead there. Cultural Zionists, in the spirit of Ahad Ha'am, read it as a return to Jewish culture, language and learning. Herzl himself meant above all a return to the Jewish people. A strong bagrut answer quotes the words, places them in the speech and the congress, and compares at least two readings fairly. Herzl died in 1904, at forty-four; in 1949 his remains were brought to Jerusalem and reburied on Mount Herzl.
Practice: Herzl and the return to Judaism
For 12th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
Complete the table: what did the First Zionist Congress found?
What did Herzl say comes before the return to the land of the Jews?
Fill in the missing step in the order of Herzl's speech.
According to Herzl, what did the union of modern and conservative Jews at the congress prove?
Complete the table: how did religious Zionists read a return to Judaism?
Why is it a misreading to say that Herzl was calling Jews back to religious observance?
Write a paragraph: what did Herzl mean that Zionism is a return to Judaism before the return to the land? Compare two readings of the sentence.
Common questions
When was the First Zionist Congress?
In Basel, Switzerland, on 29-31 August 1897. It was convened by Theodor Herzl, attended by 208 people from 17 countries, and founded the Zionist Organization.
What is the Basel Program?
The platform adopted at the First Zionist Congress in 1897: Zionism seeks to establish a home for the Jewish people in Palestine, the Land of Israel, secured by public law.
Was Herzl religious?
No. He grew up in a German-speaking, assimilated Jewish family. When he spoke of a return to Judaism, he meant a return to the Jewish people and its identity.
What did Herzl write after the Basel congress?
In his diary on 3 September 1897 he wrote, in short, that at Basel he had founded the Jewish State, and that within fifty years everyone would see it.
How is Herzl's Zionism different from Pinsker's?
Both called on the Jews to help themselves; Herzl added a world congress, a political organization and diplomacy aimed at a home secured by public law.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.