- Psychology: thinking, decisions and intelligence
What are the theories of intelligence?
The main theories of intelligence disagree on whether it is one ability or many. Spearman (1904) proposed a general factor, g; Thurstone (1938) seven primary abilities; Cattell (1943) fluid and crystallized intelligence; Gardner (1983) multiple intelligences; and Sternberg (1985) analytical, creative and practical intelligence. Test data most strongly support a general factor with broader abilities beneath it.
The topic explained
One ability or many?
Theories of intelligence try to answer a simple-sounding question: is intelligence one general ability, or several separate ones? The first scientific answer came from the English psychologist Charles Spearman. In 1904 he looked at children's marks in school subjects and in tests such as telling musical pitches apart, and found that every pair was positively correlated: a child who did well in one tended to do well in the others. This pattern is called the positive manifold.
Spearman explained it with a single general factor, which he called g, shared by all mental tasks, plus a specific ability for each task. A common misreading is that g means a person is equally good at everything. It does not: the correlations are positive but far from perfect, so people still have clear strengths and weaknesses. Psychologists such as Godfrey Thomson replied early on that the same correlations could also come from many smaller abilities that overlap between tests, so the pattern alone does not prove that g is one thing in the brain.
Several abilities, arranged in levels
In 1938 Louis Thurstone tested people on many tasks and described seven primary mental abilities: verbal comprehension, word fluency, number facility, spatial visualization, associative memory, perceptual speed and reasoning. But the seven abilities themselves turned out to be correlated, and a reanalysis showed that g could explain his data as well. Raymond Cattell, from 1943, split general ability into two. Fluid intelligence is reasoning about new problems with little help from what you have learned, as in matrix puzzles. Crystallized intelligence is the knowledge and skills you have built up, such as vocabulary. Fluid ability peaks in early adulthood, around 27, and then slowly declines, while crystallized knowledge can keep growing.
Most researchers today combine these ideas in a hierarchy: g at the top, broad abilities in the middle and specific skills at the bottom.
Gardner's multiple intelligences
Howard Gardner, in his 1983 book Frames of Mind, argued that there are separate multiple intelligences: linguistic, logical-mathematical, spatial, musical, bodily-kinesthetic, interpersonal and intrapersonal, with a naturalistic intelligence added in the 1990s. He drew on evidence such as brain damage that harms one ability and spares others, and on people with one exceptional talent. For Gardner an intelligence is a potential to solve problems or make things that a culture values, so a dancer's or a composer's skill counts as much as a mathematician's. The theory became very popular in schools.
The research criticism is strong. When the abilities Gardner names are measured with tests, most of them correlate with one another and with g, which is the opposite of what fully separate intelligences would predict, and there are few studies that test the theory directly. It is also often confused with learning styles, the idea that each pupil learns best through one channel, which Gardner himself rejects.
Sternberg's three kinds, and how to compare theories
Robert Sternberg's triarchic theory (1985) describes three kinds of intelligence: analytical (solving and judging problems, what tests measure), creative (dealing with new situations) and practical (adapting to and shaping everyday surroundings). Linda Gottfredson (2003) criticized its evidence and pointed out that ordinary IQ tests already predict real-world outcomes. A good exam answer compares theories on two questions: how many abilities they propose, and what evidence supports them.
The hierarchical view is built into today's tests. The Wechsler adult scale, in its 2008 edition, reports four index scores, verbal comprehension, perceptual reasoning, working memory and processing speed, and combines them into one full-scale IQ, its estimate of general ability.
Practice: theories of intelligence
For 12th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
Look at Spearman's correlations. What do they all have in common, and what did Spearman conclude from it?
Spearman (1904), as tabled by Jensen (1998): every pair of school measures correlated positively. Fill in what each researcher proposed.
Name the two broad abilities in the diagram, and say which one tends to decline from early adulthood.
Classify each person by Sternberg's three kinds of intelligence.
A friend says: "Spearman's g means that a clever person is good at everything." Correct this.
Give one piece of evidence Gardner used for separate intelligences, and one research finding against the theory.
A school sorts pupils into "musical learners" and "spatial learners" and teaches each group differently, citing Gardner. Evaluate this practice.
Common questions
What is the g factor?
The g factor is the general ability Spearman proposed in 1904 to explain why performance on all kinds of mental tests is positively correlated. It is a statistical summary of what the tests share, and most modern models place it at the top of a hierarchy of abilities.
Is Gardner's theory of multiple intelligences accepted?
It is popular in education but not widely accepted by researchers on intelligence. Tests of the abilities it names mostly correlate with one another and with g, and there are few direct studies supporting it. Many teachers still value it as a reminder that pupils differ.
What is the difference between fluid and crystallized intelligence?
Fluid intelligence is solving new problems with little help from what you have learned, such as a matrix puzzle. Crystallized intelligence is the knowledge and skills you have built up, such as vocabulary. Fluid ability peaks in early adulthood; crystallized knowledge can keep growing.
Which theory of intelligence is correct?
No single theory is simply correct. Test data strongly support a general factor with broader and narrower abilities beneath it, a hierarchy that combines Spearman, Thurstone and Cattell. Gardner and Sternberg widen the question of what counts as intelligence, but their evidence is weaker.
Is emotional intelligence one of the theories of intelligence?
It is a separate idea, the ability to perceive and manage emotions, and it is not one of the classic theories covered here. Gardner's interpersonal and intrapersonal intelligences are related to it. Researchers still debate how distinct it is from personality.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.