- Sociology: social change, modernization and globalization
What is the difference between Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft?
The difference between Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft is Ferdinand Tönnies' distinction (1887) between two kinds of social bond. Gemeinschaft, community, rests on kinship, place and shared belief, and its ties are valued for themselves. Gesellschaft, society, rests on contract and exchange, and its ties are means to personal ends. Every real group mixes both; Tönnies held that modern life moves toward Gesellschaft.
The topic explained
Two kinds of social bond
The German sociologist Ferdinand Tönnies set out the difference between Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft in a book of that name in 1887. Gemeinschaft, usually translated as community, is a bond people value for its own sake. It grows from kinship, from living in one place, and from shared belief and friendship, and it is held together by what Tönnies called natural will: acting from habit, feeling and duty. Gesellschaft, society or association, is a bond people form as a means to their own ends: a contract, a sale, a job, membership of a company. It rests on rational will, the deliberate choice of the best means to a goal. Tönnies opened the book by describing community as real and organic life, and society as an imaginary and mechanical structure.
A neighborhood grocer who has known your family for twenty years and lets you pay next week is a Gemeinschaft tie. Ordering the same groceries from an app, from a company that knows you only as an account, is a Gesellschaft tie.
Ideal types on a line, not two boxes
Tönnies treated the two as pure types. In theory they can be kept apart; in real life every group mixes them, so it is better to place a group on a line between the two poles than to put it in a box. A family firm is built on kinship and on profit at once. Tönnies also described a historical movement: with industry, capitalism and the growth of cities, Gesellschaft became dominant, and many readers hear regret in his account of what was lost.
The misreading to avoid is to treat Gemeinschaft as good and Gesellschaft as bad, or as the village and the city. A close community can also be stifling: it watches its members, punishes difference and leaves little room for choice. A contract between strangers can be fair, free and open to anyone. Tönnies described two ways of living together; he did not ask students to pick a winner.
The kibbutz, the moshav and the city
Israel offers clear cases. Degania, founded in 1910, is counted as the first kibbutz: property was shared, members worked and ate together, and decisions were taken by the members' assembly. In Tönnies' terms it stood close to Gemeinschaft, yet it was founded by a deliberate choice, a community of shared belief rather than of birth. Nahalal, founded in 1921, was the first moshav ovdim: each family farmed its own plot, while buying and marketing were cooperative, a mix of the two types. From the late 1990s many kibbutzim moved to the renewed model, with wages that differ by job; by the end of 2009, 72 percent of kibbutzim had made the change, according to the University of Haifa's Institute for Research of the Kibbutz. That is a move along the line toward Gesellschaft.
Cities are not pure Gesellschaft either. Residents of a Tel Aviv building may barely know each other, yet a neighborhood synagogue, a sports club or a building's chat group can rebuild pockets of community.
Tönnies and Durkheim
Émile Durkheim reviewed the book in 1889 and drew his own pair from it in The Division of Labor in Society (1893). He matched Gemeinschaft with mechanical solidarity, the bond of people who are alike, and Gesellschaft with organic solidarity, the bond of people who depend on each other's different work. But he rejected Tönnies' view of modern society as artificial: for Durkheim, interdependence was a real and natural form of cohesion. Note the trap in the words: Tönnies called community organic and society mechanical, the reverse of the way Durkheim used the terms. Both men described the same change, from small traditional communities to large industrial societies; they disagreed about what the change does to the bonds between people, and a strong bagrut answer sets the two views side by side.
Practice: Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft
For 12th grade students of sociology. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
Fill in the Gesellschaft column for the will and for what keeps order.
Closer to Gemeinschaft, to Gesellschaft, or a mix? (a) A village where everyone knows each other and disputes are settled by the elders. (b) A bank's customer call center. (c) A family restaurant where three cousins work. (d) An online marketplace for second-hand goods.
Fill in the missing box on the line, and explain why it stands there.
Fill in the year Nahalal, the first moshav, was founded.
Complete the table: how did Durkheim see the ties of modern society?
Degania was founded by a deliberate decision of its members, yet it is placed near the Gemeinschaft pole. Explain how both can be true.
Is your class's chat group closer to Gemeinschaft or to Gesellschaft? Write a paragraph that uses at least three features from the comparison table.
Common questions
Who coined the terms Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft?
The German sociologist Ferdinand Tönnies, in his book Gemeinschaft und Gesellschaft, published in 1887. He was one of the founders of the German Sociological Association and its president from 1909 to 1933.
What do Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft mean in English?
Gemeinschaft is usually translated as community, and Gesellschaft as society or association. Many English textbooks keep the German words, because neither translation carries the full meaning.
What is an example of Gemeinschaft?
A family, a village where people have known each other for generations, a circle of close friends or a community of believers. In each the ties are valued for themselves, not as a means to something else.
Is Gemeinschaft the same as mechanical solidarity?
Durkheim matched the two, but they are not the same. Mechanical solidarity is the bond of people who are alike; Gemeinschaft is a bond valued for itself. And Tönnies called community organic, the opposite of Durkheim's usage.
Is modern Israel a Gemeinschaft or a Gesellschaft?
Like every modern society it mixes both. Its economy, state and cities run largely on contract and exchange, while family, community and shared belief remain strong in many groups, from kibbutzim and moshavim to religious communities.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.