- Jewish Thought: Providence, Prophecy and the Commandments
What is the reason for sacrifices according to Maimonides and the Ramban?
Maimonides and the Ramban give opposite reasons for sacrifices. Maimonides (Guide 3:32) holds that the Torah kept the worship of its time, sacrifice, and turned it to God, to wean people from idolatry step by step. The Ramban (on Leviticus 1:9) rejects this: Noah and Abel offered before any idolatry, and the offering shows a person that he deserved what is done to the animal.
The topic explained
Maimonides: no sudden leap
Maimonides starts from human nature: “שאי אפשר לצאת מן ההפך אל ההפך פתאום” (it is impossible to pass from one extreme to the other at once, Guide 3:32). When the Torah was given, all peoples worshipped with animal sacrifice. To forbid it outright, he says, would have been as if a prophet came today and said God commands you not to pray. The question of Maimonides and the Ramban on sacrifices begins with this claim.
So “ומפני זה השאיר ית׳ מיני העבודות ההם והעתיקם מהיותם לנבראים ולענינים דמיוניים שאין אמיתות להם – לשמו ית׳” (God left those kinds of worship and moved them from created things and imaginary powers that have no reality, to His own name). The Torah did the same with the road out of Egypt: “וְלֹא־נָחָם אֱלֹהִים דֶּרֶךְ אֶרֶץ פְּלִשְׁתִּים כִּי קָרוֹב הוּא” (God did not lead them by the way of the land of the Philistines, though it was near, Exodus 13:17), but by a detour, until they could face war.
The first intention
For Maimonides, then, sacrifice is a means, and the goal lies beyond it: “והיא – השגתו ית׳ והנחת ׳עבודה זרה׳” (and that is apprehending God and leaving idolatry). A common mistake is to conclude that Maimonides thought the sacrifices unimportant or abolished.
In his law code he rules the opposite: in the days of the Messiah “וחוזרין כל המשפטים בימיו כשהיו מקדם. מקריבין קרבנות” (all the laws return as they were before; sacrifices are offered, Hilkhot Melakhim 11:1). Explaining a commandment's origin does not, for him, cancel it.
The Ramban: an offering of the self
The Ramban quotes Maimonides and answers sharply: “והנה הם דברי הבאי, ירפאו שבר גדול וקשיא רבה על נקלה” (these are empty words; they heal a great wound and a hard difficulty lightly, on Leviticus 1:9). The Torah calls the offerings a pleasing odor to God; and “והנה נח בצאתו מן התבה עם שלשת בניו, אין בעולם כשדי או מצרי, הקריב קרבן” (Noah, coming out of the ark with his three sons, when there was no Chaldean or Egyptian in the world, offered a sacrifice), as did Abel. What idolatry were they curing?
His own reason: “כי בעבור שמעשי בני אדם נגמרים במחשבה ובדבור ובמעשה” (since human deeds are completed in thought, in speech and in act), the sinner lays his hands on the offering, confesses, and sees the kidneys burned and the blood sprinkled, “כדי שיחשב אדם בעשותו כל אלה כי חטא לאלהיו בגופו ובנפשו וראוי לו שישפך דמו וישרף גופו, לולא חסד הבורא” (so that a person, doing all this, will think that he sinned against his God with body and soul, and it would be fitting for his own blood to be spilled and his body burned, but for the Creator's kindness).
Weighing the two
The Ramban himself calls this reason “ואלה דברים מתקבלים מושכים את הלב כדברי אגדה” (things acceptable, drawing the heart, like words of aggadah), and adds that the true reason is a hidden secret of the kabbalah. Maimonides offers a historical explanation that keeps God from needing anything; the Ramban an inner one that keeps the offering meaningful in itself.
Each has a cost. Maimonides is open to the charge that a commandment explained by its past seems less needed today; the Ramban, to the charge that his symbolic reading is hard to prove from the text. A strong answer sets out both, with a quotation from each, and the main objection to each.
Practice: Maimonides and the Ramban on sacrifices
For 11th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
Maimonides writes: “שאי אפשר לצאת מן ההפך אל ההפך פתאום” (it is impossible to pass from one extreme to the other at once). How does this principle explain the sacrifices?
Fill in the two empty boxes in the worship column.
Maimonides compares the commandment to the road out of Egypt: “וְלֹא־נָחָם אֱלֹהִים דֶּרֶךְ אֶרֶץ פְּלִשְׁתִּים כִּי קָרוֹב הוּא” (God did not lead them by the way of the land of the Philistines, though it was near). Explain the comparison.
The Ramban answers: “והנה נח בצאתו מן התבה עם שלשת בניו, אין בעולם כשדי או מצרי, הקריב קרבן” (Noah, when there was no Chaldean or Egyptian in the world, offered a sacrifice). Why is this an argument against Maimonides?
Write the part of the offering that matches thought and desire.
“כדי שיחשב אדם בעשותו כל אלה כי חטא לאלהיו בגופו ובנפשו וראוי לו שישפך דמו וישרף גופו, לולא חסד הבורא” (so that a person will think that he sinned with body and soul, and his own blood should have been spilled, but for the Creator's kindness). What should the person feel when he brings an offering, according to the Ramban?
Fill in the Ramban's two empty boxes in the comparison table.
Write a paragraph: which reason for the sacrifices convinces you more? Present both with a quotation each, the main objection to each, and your view.
Common questions
Did Maimonides think sacrifices were bad?
No. He explains why the Torah commanded them, as a step away from idolatry toward knowing God, but in Hilkhot Melakhim 11:1 he rules that sacrifices will be offered again in the days of the Messiah.
Why did the Ramban call Maimonides' reason empty words?
Because the Torah calls the offerings a pleasing odor to God, and because Noah and Abel offered sacrifices when there was no idolatry to cure. For the Ramban a commandment cannot be only a concession to error.
What is the Ramban's own reason for sacrifices?
That a sinner, laying his hands on the offering, confessing and seeing it burned, should feel that he deserved this himself and lives by God's kindness. He adds that there is also a hidden kabbalistic reason.
What does the desert detour have to do with sacrifices?
In Guide 3:32 Maimonides compares them: God led Israel by a long road because the short one through the land of the Philistines was too hard, and He commanded sacrifice because worship without it was too hard at the time.
How do I answer an exam question on the sacrifices?
Present Maimonides' view with Guide 3:32, the Ramban's reply and reason from his commentary on Leviticus 1:9, compare them on why sacrifice was commanded, and weigh one objection to each.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.