- Jewish Thought: Prayer and Shabbat in Depth
Why pray if God already knows what we need?
Rabbi Yosef Albo answers why pray if God already knows what we need: prayer does not change God's mind, it changes the one who prays. God's decrees fit a person's state, and a person who prays becomes, in a sense, someone else, ready to receive good that was not decreed for who he was before. God's will was conditional from the start.
The topic explained
The doubt about prayer
The question is old, and Rabbi Yosef Albo, a fifteenth-century Spanish thinker, states it sharply in Sefer HaIkkarim, the Book of Principles: “ואם נגזר אין צריך תפלה, ואם לא נגזר איך תועיל התפלה לשנות רצון השם” (if it was decreed, there is no need for prayer; and if it was not decreed, how can prayer help to change God's will?, 4:18). After all, “שלא ישתנה השם מן הרצון אל לא רצון” (God does not change from willing to not willing).
Albo finds the doubt already in the Bible, in the mouth of the wicked whom Job describes: “מַה־שַּׁדַּי כִּי־נַעַבְדֶנּוּ וּמַה־נּוֹעִיל כִּי נִפְגַּע־בּוֹ” (what is the Almighty that we should serve Him, and what will we gain if we pray to Him?, Job 21:15). The doubt seems to leave two bad choices: either prayer is useless, or God is like a person who can be talked into changing His mind. Albo rejects both.
A decree fits a state
Albo's key idea is that God's gifts depend on the person who receives them: “שהשפעות העליונות יושפעו על המקבל בהיותו במדרגה ידועה והכנה ידועה לקבלם” (the higher influences flow to the receiver when he is at a certain level and a certain preparation to receive them). A decree is not given to a name but to a person in a certain state.
His parable is a farmer. Suppose good crops were decreed for him this year, yet “והוא לא יחרוש ולא יזרע בשנה ההיא” (he does not plow or sow that year). Then, Albo says, even if God sends mighty rains over the earth, his crops will not succeed. The rain was real; the farmer was not ready to receive it. So with prayer: the good is there, and the question is whether the person has made himself a vessel that can receive it.
Prayer changes the one who prays
So “וכשתשתנה המדרגה ההיא או ההכנה ההיא תשתנה הגזרה בהכרח” (when that level or that preparation changes, the decree necessarily changes). Prayer, like repentance and good deeds, is such a change. Of repentance Albo writes: “הנה הוא כאלו נהפך לאיש אחר שלא נגזרה עליו אותה גזרה” (he is as if he became another person, on whom that decree was not decreed). His example is King Ahab: after he humbled himself, God said “יַעַן כִּי־נִכְנַע מִפָּנַי לֹא־אָבִי הָרָעָה בְּיָמָיו” (because he has humbled himself before Me, I will not bring the evil in his days, 1 Kings 21:29).
Has God then changed His mind? No: “שכך היה רצון השם מתחלה” (for this was God's will from the start): that the decree should stand while he is at that level and preparation, and that if the preparation changes, the decree changes. The condition was part of the decree all along.
What the answer asks of us
The misreading students fall into is to think Albo turns prayer into a technique for getting what we want. In his answer the one who prays must become different: humbler, more aware that good comes from God, more ready to receive it. The Torah praises a people with a God who is near “כַּה׳ אֱלֹהֵינוּ בְּכָל־קָרְאֵנוּ אֵלָיו” (as the Lord our God is, whenever we call to Him, Deuteronomy 4:7). Albo is also honest about a limit: how God's knowledge stays unchanged is as hidden as in the question of free choice, but “וכן נאמין היות התפלה מועלת לבטל הגזרה אחר שהעיד על זה החוש” (so we believe that prayer helps to annul a decree, since experience testifies to it). A strong bagrut answer states the doubt, explains Albo's answer with the farmer, and asks what it demands of a person who prays.
Practice: why pray if God knows
For 10th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
Albo writes: “ואם נגזר אין צריך תפלה, ואם לא נגזר איך תועיל התפלה לשנות רצון השם” (if it was decreed, there is no need for prayer; if not, how can prayer change God's will?). Explain the doubt in your own words.
Complete the diagram of the doubt.
Albo says “שהשפעות העליונות יושפעו על המקבל בהיותו במדרגה ידועה והכנה ידועה לקבלם” (the higher influences flow to the receiver at a certain level and preparation). What does this mean for a decree?
Complete the parable: what happens to the farmer who does not plow, even if rain was decreed?
Fill in the missing step of Albo's answer.
How does Albo answer the objection that prayer changes God's will? Use the words “שכך היה רצון השם מתחלה” (for this was God's will from the start).
Write a paragraph: does prayer change God or the person who prays? Present Albo's view and your own.
Common questions
Does prayer change God's mind in Judaism?
According to Rabbi Yosef Albo, no: God's will was conditional from the start, and prayer changes the state of the person who prays, so that a different decree fits him.
Who was Rabbi Yosef Albo?
A Jewish thinker in fifteenth-century Spain, the author of Sefer HaIkkarim, the Book of Principles, which discusses the foundations of faith, including prayer.
What is Albo's parable of the farmer?
Even if good crops were decreed for a farmer and God sends rain, if he does not plow and sow he will have no harvest. Prayer is the plowing: it prepares a person to receive.
If God knows everything, why ask Him for anything?
Albo's answer is that asking is part of becoming ready to receive: the one who prays recognizes that good comes from God, and that change in him is what the decree depends on.
Can repentance change a decree?
Albo says yes: one who repents is as if he became another person, on whom the old decree was not decreed. The same logic explains prayer and good deeds.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.