• Psychology: positive psychology and well-being

What is the difference between a fixed and a growth mindset?

Written with AI (How we create content)Target level: Grade 12Last updated: Report an error
Quick answer

A fixed mindset is the belief that ability is a set amount you cannot change; a growth mindset is the belief that ability can be developed through effort, good strategies and help. Carol Dweck's research links the two to how students react to failure, but large later studies find the effects on grades are small.

The topic explained

Two beliefs about ability

The American psychologist Carol Dweck, of Stanford University, studies what people believe about their own abilities. In a fixed mindset, ability is a set amount: you are either a math person or not, and nothing changes that. In a growth mindset, ability can be developed through effort, good strategies and help from others. Researchers call these beliefs implicit theories, and Dweck made them widely known in her book Mindset (2006). Most people hold a mix, and the same person may hold a growth mindset about sport and a fixed one about math.

The difference matters most after failure. With a fixed mindset, a low mark seems to reveal a lack of ability, so effort looks pointless, or even shameful. With a growth mindset, it signals that a new strategy or more practice is needed. The common misreading is that growth mindset means effort alone is enough, or that praising effort for its own sake helps. Dweck stresses the process: effort together with better strategies and asking for help.

Table comparing a fixed and a growth mindset: ability is a fixed amount versus ability can be developed; the goal is to look smart versus to learn; failure means I am not able versus I need a new strategy; effort is a sign of low ability versus the way to improve.Fixed mindsetGrowth mindsetability is a set amountability can be developedgoal: look smartgoal: learnfailure: I can't do itfailure: try a new wayeffort means I'm weakeffort is how I improve
Two beliefs about ability, as Dweck describes them; most people hold a mix.

What praise does: Mueller and Dweck

Mueller and Dweck (1998) ran six studies with fifth graders. Children solved a set of problems and were praised in one of two ways: for being smart, or for working hard. Then they met problems on which they failed. Children praised for intelligence were more interested afterward in tasks that would make them look good than in tasks they could learn from. After the failure they persisted less, enjoyed the problems less, blamed their low ability more and then performed worse. They also described intelligence as more fixed than children praised for effort did.

The study did not show that praise is bad. It showed that praising a fixed trait can teach a child that every result is a verdict on that trait.

Table of Mueller and Dweck's 1998 results for fifth graders: after praise for intelligence, children preferred tasks that made them look good, persisted less after failure, enjoyed the task less, performed worse and saw intelligence as fixed; after praise for effort, they preferred tasks they could learn from, persisted more, enjoyed more, performed better and saw intelligence as improvable.Praised for intelligencePraised for effortchose to look goodchose to learngave up soonerkept tryingdid worse after failuredid better after failuresaw ability as fixedsaw ability as growing
Mueller and Dweck (1998): six studies with fifth graders, results after a set of problems they failed.

How big is the effect?

As growth mindset programs spread to schools around the world, researchers asked how much they really help. Sisk, Macnamara and colleagues (2018) ran two meta-analyses, studies that pool the results of many others. The first, covering 365,915 students, asked whether mindset is linked to academic achievement. The second, covering 57,155 students, asked whether mindset interventions raise achievement. Both overall effects were weak. There was a hint that students at academic risk or from low-income families might gain more.

Weak does not mean zero, and it does not mean the idea is false. It means that across hundreds of thousands of students, knowing someone's mindset tells you little about their grades, and a typical intervention moves grades only slightly. A careful exam answer reports both the original findings and these later, larger tests.

Table of Sisk and colleagues' two meta-analyses of 2018: the link between mindset and grades, 273 effects and 365,915 students, overall weak; the effect of mindset interventions, 43 effects and 57,155 students, overall weak, with possible benefit for students at risk or from low-income homes.QuestionStudentsOverall resultmindset and grades365,915weak linkdo interventions work?57,155weak effectwho may gain most?same dataat-risk, low income
Sisk and colleagues (2018): two meta-analyses of the mindset research.

A national experiment, and a balanced verdict

Yeager, Dweck and many colleagues (2019) then ran a large experiment in a nationally representative sample of US secondary schools. A short online lesson, under an hour, taught that intellectual abilities can be developed. Grades improved among lower-achieving students, more students enrolled in advanced math, and the effect held mainly where classmates' norms supported the message. The analyses were registered in advance and the data were collected independently, which makes the result more trustworthy.

The balanced verdict: mindset is a real but modest influence, strongest for students who are struggling and in schools whose culture backs it up. A poster on the wall saying effort is everything is not the same as teaching and practicing better strategies.

The national experiment from top to bottom: a short online lesson under one hour, given to a nationally representative sample of US secondary students; grades rose among lower-achieving students; more students took advanced math; the effect held where peer norms supported the message.Online lesson, under 1 hourNational sample, US schoolsLower achievers' grades roseMore took advanced mathBest where peers agreed
Yeager, Dweck and colleagues (2019): a pre-registered national experiment.
Free printable worksheet

Practice: fixed and growth mindset

For 12th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers. The sentences are imaginary and are not a test of anyone's mindset.

Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.

Free printable worksheetlessoons.com
Practice: fixed and growth mindsetName:
  1. Mark each sentence as fixed or growth mindset.

    Table of three imaginary student sentences, each to be marked fixed or growth with a question mark: I'm just not a math person; I haven't figured out this method yet; If I need help, it means I'm not smart.Student saysMindsetI'm just not a math person?I don't get this method yet?needing help means I'm dumb?
  2. Fill in the two missing results of Mueller and Dweck's study.

    Table of Mueller and Dweck's results again with two cells replaced by question marks: what children praised for intelligence did after failure, and how children praised for effort saw ability.Praised for intelligencePraised for effortchose to look goodchose to learn?kept tryingsaw ability as fixed?
  3. Fill in the result of the intervention meta-analysis, and name one group that may benefit more.

    The table of the two meta-analyses again with the overall result of the intervention analysis replaced by a question mark.QuestionStudentsOverall resultmindset and grades365,915weak linkdo interventions work?57,155?
  4. A parent says to a child who got 95: "You're so smart!" Rewrite the praise in the spirit of Mueller and Dweck's findings.

  5. Why does the national experiment of 2019 deserve more trust than a single small study?

  6. A school decides to hang growth mindset posters in every class and expects grades to rise. Using the page, evaluate the plan.

  7. Explain the common misreading that growth mindset means effort alone is enough.

More topics and worksheets at lessoons.com© 2026 Lessons

Common questions

Who came up with the idea of a growth mindset?

The American psychologist Carol Dweck of Stanford University developed the research on implicit theories of ability and made the terms fixed and growth mindset widely known in her book Mindset, published in 2006.

Does a growth mindset really improve grades?

A little, for some students. Two meta-analyses in 2018 found weak overall effects, and a national experiment in 2019 found that a short lesson raised grades mainly among lower-achieving students, especially where classmates supported the message.

Is it bad to tell a child they are smart?

Mueller and Dweck's 1998 studies found that praise for intelligence led children to give up sooner after failure than praise for effort. Praise that describes what the child did, such as effort and strategy, is the better habit.

What is an example of a growth mindset statement?

I can't do this yet, so I'll try another method and ask for help. It treats the difficulty as temporary and points to a strategy, while a fixed statement such as I'm just bad at this treats it as permanent.

What are the criticisms of mindset theory?

Large meta-analyses found the link between mindset and achievement and the effect of interventions to be weak overall. Critics also warn that popular versions oversimplify it into praising effort or hanging posters, which the research does not support.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi

Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.

Try asking

Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.

Learn it with a teacher

Learn this topic live with Lessi

Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.