• News and journalism

What is gatekeeping in journalism?

Written with AI (How we create content)Target level: Grade 10Last updated: Report an error
Quick answer

Gatekeeping in journalism is the process by which reporters, editors and, today, platform algorithms choose which of the day's many events reach the public, and in what form. The psychologist Kurt Lewin coined the term in the 1940s, and David Manning White first used it to study a newspaper editor in 1950, finding that some of his choices were personal.

The topic explained

A funnel with gates

Gatekeeping in journalism is the process of choosing which events become news and how they are told. Every day there are far more events than any news site, broadcast or feed can carry, so stories pass through a series of gates: a reporter notices one event and not another, an editor runs one report and drops the next, and on a phone an algorithm decides what appears first. Pamela Shoemaker and Tim Vos describe it as culling and crafting: cutting most items away and shaping the few that remain.

The word comes from the psychologist Kurt Lewin, who studied in the 1940s how food reaches a family's table: whoever shops and cooks stands at a gate and decides what gets through. Lewin suggested that news travels through channels in the same way. The common mistake is to treat gatekeeping as censorship. Censorship is a ban imposed from outside; gatekeeping is selection that has to happen, because a front page has a few slots and a day has thousands of events. The question is not whether there are gates but who keeps them and by what rules.

Funnel of four gates: every event of the day, what reporters noticed, what editors chose and what the algorithm ranked, ending at the reader's screen.Every event of the dayWhat reporters noticedWhat editors choseWhat the algorithm rankedYour screen
Fewer stories pass each gate. The widths are a sketch, not counts.

Mr. Gates: the first study

In 1950 David Manning White published a study of a wire editor at a morning paper in a Midwestern American city, whom he called Mr. Gates. For one week the editor kept every wire story he rejected and wrote down why. He threw out about nine in ten. Most were rejected as not worth printing or because there was no space and another story on the same event had been used, but some reasons were plainly personal, such as “don't care for suicides”. White concluded that the selection of news is highly subjective.

Later researchers read the same figures differently. When Maxwell McCombs and Donald Shaw re-examined them, they found that the share of each kind of story Mr. Gates chose followed fairly closely the share the wire services had sent him. So the editor was less free than he looked: much of his choice was made upstream, by the agencies and by habits of the trade.

Table of the kinds of reasons Mr. Gates gave for rejecting stories: not worth printing, such as dull or too vague; no space, because another story on the same event was used; personal taste, such as don't care for suicides.Kind of reasonExample from his notesNot worth printingDull, too vagueNo spaceAnother story on same eventPersonal taste“Don't care for suicides”
From David Manning White's study, 1950.

Five levels of influence

In Gatekeeping Theory (2009), Shoemaker and Vos widened the picture from one person to five levels. The individual: the reporter's interests and views. Routines: deadlines, news values, the habit of quoting officials. The organization: the owner, the policy, the budget. Social institutions outside the newsroom: advertisers, the government, sources and rival outlets. The social system: the culture and values of a whole society, which decide what seems normal or shocking.

A made-up example shows them at work. A reporter who cycles to school pitches a story on bike lanes (individual). It runs at 6 p.m., when the site always posts local news (routines), but it is cut short because the site has no traffic reporter this month (organization).

Five levels of influence on gatekeeping according to Shoemaker and Vos, from the widest to the narrowest: social system, institutions, the organization, routines and the individual.Social system: cultureInstitutions: ads, stateOrganization: owner, policyRoutines: deadlinesIndividual: reporter
Shoemaker and Vos, 2009: each level contains the one below it.

New gates: algorithms and audiences

Online, the gates have multiplied. Platforms rank each user's feed with algorithms that predict what that person will click, share or watch for longer, and readers pass stories on to their friends. Axel Bruns called this sharing gatewatching: people do not keep gates of their own but point others to what has already been published. An editor chooses for one whole audience and can be asked why; an algorithm chooses for each user separately, and the reasons are hidden in closed code.

The common mistake on the exam is to write that the internet has no gatekeepers. It has more, and they are harder to see. A strong answer defines gatekeeping, cites White (1950), names one level of influence and explains how an algorithm differs from an editor.

Table comparing an editor with a feed algorithm: the editor chooses by news values and judgment, the algorithm by predicted clicks and shares; the editor sees one whole audience, the algorithm each user apart; the editor can be asked, the algorithm hardly.EditorFeed algorithmChooses byNews valueLikely clicksSeesOne audienceEach user apartAnswers?Yes, by nameHardly: closed code
Free printable worksheet

Practice: gatekeeping in journalism

For 10th grade communications students. All the sites and cases are made up. Answer from what is printed here, then check yourself against the answers.

Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.

Free printable worksheetlessoons.com
Practice: gatekeeping in journalismName:
  1. Define gatekeeping in one sentence, and explain how it differs from censorship.

  2. Complete the missing gate in the funnel.

    The funnel of gates with the third gate blank and a question mark, between what reporters noticed and what the algorithm ranked.Every event of the dayWhat reporters noticed?What the algorithm rankedYour screen
  3. What did Mr. Gates do in White's 1950 study, and what did White conclude? Fill in the missing kind of reason in the table.

    Table of the kinds of reasons Mr. Gates gave for rejecting stories: not worth printing, such as dull or too vague; no space, because another story on the same event was used; personal taste, such as don't care for suicides.Kind of reasonExample from his notesNot worth printingDull, too vagueNo spaceAnother story on same event??
    From David Manning White's study, 1950.
  4. A re-examination found that the kinds of stories Mr. Gates chose followed the kinds the wire services sent him. What does this add to White's conclusion?

  5. Write the level of influence (Shoemaker and Vos) for each made-up case in the table.

    Table of four made-up cases, each with a question mark for its level of influence: a reporter who cycles to work, a weather story every day at six, an owner's rule against stories on rivals, and a big advertiser who may pull out.Made-up caseLevelReporter who cycles to work?Weather story every day at 6?Owner: no stories on rivals?Big advertiser may pull out?
  6. Fill in the missing row: what does an editor choose by, and what does a feed algorithm choose by?

    Table comparing an editor with a feed algorithm: the editor chooses by news values and judgment, the algorithm by predicted clicks and shares; the editor sees one whole audience, the algorithm each user apart; the editor can be asked, the algorithm hardly.EditorFeed algorithmChooses by??SeesOne audienceEach user apartAnswers?Yes, by nameHardly: closed code
  7. A student writes: “On social media there are no gatekeepers, so everyone sees everything.” Write a short answer that disagrees, using two terms from the lesson.

More topics and worksheets at lessoons.com© 2026 Lessons

Common questions

Who coined the term gatekeeper?

The psychologist Kurt Lewin, in the 1940s, while studying how food reaches a family's table. He suggested that news passes through channels and gates in the same way, and David Manning White applied the idea to a newspaper editor in 1950.

What is the difference between gatekeeping and agenda setting?

Gatekeeping is about how stories are selected inside the media. Agenda setting is about the effect on the audience: the issues the media cover most come to seem most important to the public. Gatekeeping shapes the media agenda that agenda setting then passes on.

Is gatekeeping the same as censorship?

No. Censorship is a ban on publishing imposed by an authority. Gatekeeping is the everyday selection that every outlet must make because it cannot carry everything. Gatekeeping can still be unfair, which is why researchers study whose stories pass the gates and whose do not.

What is gatewatching?

Axel Bruns's term for what users do online when they share and recommend news. They do not decide what is published, but by passing some stories on and not others they help decide what their friends and followers see.

Are algorithms gatekeepers?

Yes, in the sense of the theory. A feed algorithm decides which posts each user sees first, usually by predicting clicks, shares and viewing time. Unlike an editor, it chooses for each person separately and its rules are not public.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi

Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.

Try asking

Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.

Learn it with a teacher

Learn this topic live with Lessi

Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.