• Psychology: memory systems and forgetting

Why is retrieval practice better than rereading?

Written with AI (How we create content)Target level: Grade 11Last updated: Report an error
Quick answer

Retrieval practice, testing yourself by recalling material from memory, is better than rereading because each act of recall strengthens the memory and the routes to it, while rereading only feels effective. In Roediger and Karpicke's 2006 study, students who took a recall test remembered 56% of a passage a week later, against 42% for those who reread it, although rereading did better after five minutes.

The topic explained

The testing effect

Most students study by rereading their notes, and it feels productive: the material looks familiar. Retrieval practice means closing the book and trying to recall the material, by answering questions, writing down everything you remember or using flashcards. The finding that recalling information makes it more durable than studying it again is called the testing effect: a test is not only a way of measuring learning but a way of causing it.

Henry Roediger and Jeffrey Karpicke (2006) tested this with 120 students and short prose passages, one about the Sun and one about sea otters. After reading a passage for seven minutes, students either read it again or wrote down all they could recall, with no feedback. They were then tested 5 minutes, 2 days or 1 week later. Notice what the tested students did not get: no extra reading time, no answers, no corrections. Any advantage had to come from the act of recalling itself.

What the students remembered

After 5 minutes the rereaders did slightly better: 81 percent of the ideas against 75. But after 2 days the order reversed, 68 percent for the tested group against 54, and after a week it was 56 against 42. The tested students remembered as much after a week as the rereaders did after two days. In a second experiment students who read a passage once and recalled it three times remembered 61 percent a week later, against 40 percent for those who read it four times, yet the rereaders had predicted they would remember it best.

That last result explains the common mistake. Rereading creates a feeling of fluency: the text looks familiar, so it feels learned. Recall is effortful and shows the gaps, so it feels worse, even while it builds longer-lasting memory.

Paired bar chart of Roediger and Karpicke's first experiment: after 5 minutes, restudy 81 percent and tested 75; after 2 days, restudy 54 and tested 68; after 1 week, restudy 42 and tested 56.81%75%5 minutes54%68%2 days42%56%1 weekstudied againtook a test
Roediger and Karpicke (2006), Experiment 1: share of idea units recalled.

Spacing: the same time, spread out

The second most powerful technique is spaced practice: spreading the same amount of study over several sessions with gaps between them, instead of massed practice, cramming it into one. Ebbinghaus already noticed the effect in 1885, and a large review of more than 300 experiments by Cepeda and colleagues (2006) confirmed that spaced practice produces better long-term retention. Each gap allows some forgetting, and recalling the material after a little forgetting strengthens it more. Spacing and retrieval work best together: a short self-test spread over several days combines the two. Cramming the night before can still get a student through a test the next morning, as the 5-minute results suggest, but much of it is gone a week later, which matters in a subject whose bagrut exam covers a great deal of material.

Two timelines over a week before a test: in massed practice four study sessions are packed into the last day; in spaced practice the same four sessions are spread across the week.massedspacedtest
The same total time, arranged differently.

Turning it into a study plan

A review of ten common techniques by John Dunlosky and colleagues (2013) rated practice testing and spaced practice as the most useful, and rereading and highlighting as low in usefulness. A two-week plan that uses both: on day 1 read the material once and write a list of questions; on days 2, 4, 7 and 11 answer the questions from memory, check, and note what you missed; on day 13 do a mixed practice test. Each session is short, and each one is a test, not a reread. The method works for vocabulary, history dates and psychology studies alike.

A table of four study methods rated by Dunlosky and colleagues in 2013: practice testing, high usefulness; spaced practice, high; rereading, low; highlighting, low.Study methodUsefulnesspractice testinghighspaced practicehighrereadinglowhighlightinglow
Dunlosky and colleagues (2013), a review of ten learning techniques.
Free printable worksheet

Practice: retrieval practice

For 11th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.

Free printable worksheetlessoons.com
Practice: retrieval practiceName:
  1. Fill in the tested group's results after 2 days and after 1 week. When did rereading do better?

    The paired bar chart with the tested group's results after 2 days and after 1 week replaced by question marks; restudy 81, 54 and 42 percent, tested 75 percent at 5 minutes.81%75%5 minutes54%?2 days42%?1 weekstudied againtook a test
  2. What is the testing effect?

  3. Fill in the missing result. Which group predicted it would remember best, and was it right?

    A table of Roediger and Karpicke's second experiment: study four times, 83 percent after 5 minutes and 40 after a week; study three times and test once, 78 and 56; study once and test three times, 71 and question mark.ConditionAfter 5 minAfter 1 weekstudy 4 times83%40%study 3, test 178%56%study 1, test 371%?
  4. Why does rereading feel more effective than it is?

  5. Fill in the name of the second schedule. Which one leads to better long-term memory?

    The two timelines with the label of the second one, four sessions spread across the week, replaced by a question mark.massed?test
  6. Build a two-week plan to learn the main studies of a psychology unit, using retrieval practice and spacing.

  7. Evaluate the claim that the testing effect will work for every student and every subject.

More topics and worksheets at lessoons.com© 2026 Lessons

Common questions

Is retrieval practice the same as taking exams?

Not exactly. Any effort to recall from memory counts: flashcards, explaining a topic aloud, writing everything you remember, or answering practice questions. Low-stakes self-tests work well and need no grade.

Should I check the answers after testing myself?

Yes. Checking and correcting mistakes adds to the benefit, because otherwise a wrong answer can be remembered. Roediger and Karpicke's students had no feedback and still benefited, but feedback helps more.

How long should the gaps be in spaced practice?

It depends on how long you need to remember. A useful rule is to review a day or two after first learning and then at growing intervals, such as after several days and after a week or two.

Is highlighting useless?

It is not harmful, but on its own it does little for memory, which is why Dunlosky and colleagues rated it low. It can help to pick out what to turn into questions for retrieval practice.

Does retrieval practice help with anxiety before exams?

Practicing recall in conditions like the exam can make the real test feel more familiar. If anxiety before exams is strong or lasting, a school counselor is a good person to talk to.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi

Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.

Try asking

Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.

Learn it with a teacher

Learn this topic live with Lessi

Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.