- Accounting: budgeting and management decisions
When should a business drop a product line?
A business should drop a product line only when total profit would rise without it. Compare what the product brings in with the costs that would disappear if it stopped: its variable costs and its own fixed costs. Shared costs allocated to it stay and fall on the other products, so a product that shows a loss may still be worth keeping.
The topic explained
A product that shows a loss
A made-up bakery sells three lines: bread, cakes and cookies. Its report charges each line with its variable costs, its own fixed costs, such as a cookie oven and its baker, and a share of the bakery's common costs, rent and management, ₪120,000 a year divided by sales. On that report, bread and cakes each earn ₪20,000 and cookies lose ₪8,000. The owner wants to drop cookies.
Whether to drop a product line depends on one question: what happens to the bakery's total profit? Today it is ₪32,000. To find it without cookies, ask which revenues and costs would disappear with them, and which would stay.
Segment margin: what the product really adds
Cookies bring sales of ₪100,000 and cause variable costs of ₪70,000, a contribution of ₪30,000. Their own fixed costs, ₪18,000, would end with them. What is left, ₪12,000, is the segment margin: what cookies add to the bakery after paying every cost they cause.
The ₪20,000 of common costs charged to cookies does not depend on them. The rent and the manager's salary are paid whether cookies are baked or not. That allocated share is what turns a contribution of ₪12,000 into a reported loss of ₪8,000, and it is the misreading at the heart of most bad decisions to drop a product. The key used to divide the shared costs, sales here, is itself a choice: divided by floor space, cookies might show a profit or a larger loss, while the bakery's total would not change by a shekel.
What happens after dropping
Without cookies the bakery loses ₪100,000 of sales and saves ₪70,000 of variable costs and ₪18,000 of own fixed costs. Profit falls by the segment margin, from ₪32,000 to ₪20,000. The ₪120,000 of common costs is now divided between bread and cakes alone, ₪72,000 and ₪48,000, and their reported profits fall to ₪8,000 and ₪12,000.
A careless owner may then see the cakes or the bread as the next weak line and keep cutting, each time spreading the same common costs over fewer products. The rule that stops this: a line with a positive segment margin helps pay the shared costs, and dropping it, by itself, lowers profit.
When dropping is right
Dropping becomes right when the space, staff or money freed can earn more elsewhere. Suppose the cookie corner could hold more cake production that adds ₪15,000 of segment margin. Dropping cookies and expanding cakes gives 20,000 + 15,000 = ₪35,000, more than the ₪32,000 of today. The ₪12,000 cookies add is then an opportunity cost, beaten by a better use.
Qualitative points weigh in too. Customers who come for cookies may also buy bread, so the loss can be larger than the cookies' own figures; a line that is weak today may be growing. A product with a negative segment margin, one that does not even cover its own costs, is the clearest case for dropping it.
Practice: dropping a product line
For 12th grade accounting students. A made-up sports shop has three departments. Bicycles had sales of ₪150,000, variable costs of ₪105,000 and own fixed costs of ₪35,000, and were allocated ₪30,000 of the shop's ₪160,000 common costs. The shop's total profit is ₪20,000. Check the answers at the end.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
What is the difference between a department's own fixed costs and the common costs allocated to it?
Complete the bicycle department's statement.
If the shop closes the bicycle department, what will its total profit be?
What happens to the ₪30,000 of common costs allocated to bicycles after closing?
The shop could rent the bicycle space to a café for ₪14,000 a year. Complete the comparison.
Of the bicycle department's own fixed costs, ₪20,000 is a manager's salary that would continue, since the manager would move to shoes. Without the café, by how much would closing bicycles lower profit?
Give one reason, beyond the figures, to keep the bicycle department.
Common questions
Should a business drop a product that shows a loss?
Not necessarily. If the loss comes from allocated common costs that would stay anyway, and the product covers its own costs, dropping it lowers total profit.
What is a segment margin?
A product's sales less its variable costs and its own fixed costs. It shows what the product adds toward the shared costs and profit of the business.
Why are allocated common costs ignored in the decision?
They stay whether or not the product is dropped; they are only divided differently among the remaining products. Costs that do not change are irrelevant to the decision.
When is dropping a product the right decision?
When its segment margin is negative, or when the space, staff or money it uses can earn more in another use. Qualitative effects on other products are weighed too.
What is the difference between contribution and segment margin?
Contribution is sales less variable costs. Segment margin also subtracts the fixed costs that belong only to that product, such as its own equipment and staff.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.