- Sociology: Israeli society
What is the ethnic gap among Jews in Israel?
The ethnic gap in Israel is the average difference in education, occupation and income between Jews whose families came from Asia and North Africa, the Mizrahim, and those whose families came from Europe and America, the Ashkenazim. It opened with the mass immigration of the 1950s, narrowed in schooling, and sociologists still disagree about how much of it remains.
The topic explained
What the ethnic gap means
Sociologists use the term ethnic gap (in Hebrew, “הפער העדתי”) for the average differences in education, occupation and income between two broad groups of Israeli Jews: Mizrahim, whose families came from countries such as Morocco, Iraq and Yemen, and Ashkenazim, whose families came from countries such as Poland, Romania and the former Soviet Union. The Central Bureau of Statistics classifies Jews by their own continent of birth or, if born in Israel, by their father's: Asia-Africa or Europe-America. A person whose father was born in Israel is recorded simply as of Israeli origin.
Two misreadings to avoid. A gap is a difference between averages: each group includes rich and poor, professors and people who left school early. And neither group is one community: immigrants from Iraq and from Morocco, for example, arrived at different times and were settled in different places.
The gap in the first decades
The immigrants of the late 1940s and 1950s arrived with different levels of schooling and were settled in different places. Many immigrants from North Africa were sent to development towns and moshavim far from the center, while earlier immigrants, many from Europe and some from Asia, already lived in the cities. In secondary school, Mizrahi students were much more often placed in vocational tracks than in academic ones. Immigrants from Asia, many of whom had arrived earlier and settled in the center, closed the distance faster on several measures than immigrants from North Africa, one reason sociologists warn against treating Mizrahim as one block. Yinon Cohen (1998), using official income surveys, found that the years of schooling of young Israeli-born Mizrahim were 77 percent of those of Ashkenazim in 1975 and 88 percent in 1995.
A common mistake is to treat that progress as the end of the gap. Years at school drew closer, but the gap in academic degrees, which leads to the best-paid jobs, closed far more slowly.
Two explanations
The modernization explanation, linked to S. N. Eisenstadt and the sociology of absorption of the 1950s, traced the gap to starting points: many immigrants came from more traditional societies, with less of the schooling and the skills a modern economy rewards. With education and time, it predicted, the gap would close. Its critics say it blamed the immigrants' culture and left out what the state did.
The critical explanation, set out by the sociologist Shlomo Swirski in a book titled “לא נחשלים אלא מנוחשלים” (Not Backward but Made Backward, 1981), traces the gap to policy: where immigrants were settled, which schools and tracks they were sent to, and which jobs were open to them. On this view the gap is reproduced from one generation to the next. Its critics say it underplays the real mobility of many Mizrahim and the differences among Mizrahi groups.
Mixing, and the third generation
Marriage has blurred the line between the groups. The demographers Barbara Okun and Orna Khait-Marelly (2006) estimated that about 14 percent of Jewish marriages in 1957 to 1961 were between Ashkenazim and Mizrahim, and about 28 percent in the early 1990s. Many young Israelis now have grandparents from both groups, and official statistics no longer record their origin at all. Ethnic identity, how people see themselves and are seen, can stay important even where the numbers draw closer.
Studies of the third generation disagree. A survey study by Cohen, Lewin-Epstein and Lazarus (2019) found smaller education gaps than in the second generation, especially among women. A study of administrative data for 2018, published by the National Insurance Institute, found that the gap in higher education had not narrowed, and that the earnings advantage of Ashkenazim came from that education gap. A strong answer reports both and says what each measured.
Practice: the ethnic gap in Israel
For 12th grade students of sociology. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
Complete the table: how does the Central Bureau of Statistics record the origin of Ashkenazim?
Read the chart. By how many percentage points did the schooling of young Mizrahim draw closer to that of Ashkenazim between 1975 and 1995?
Modernization or critical explanation? (a) The immigrants brought fewer of the skills a modern economy rewards. (b) Students in development towns were sent to vocational tracks. (c) With education and time the gap will close. (d) The gap passes from parents to children through state institutions.
Complete the table: what future does each explanation expect?
Fill in the missing link in the chain of the critical explanation.
Read the chart. How did the share of marriages between Ashkenazim and Mizrahim change, and what does it mean for studying the ethnic gap today?
Two studies of the third generation reached different conclusions. Write a paragraph that presents both and suggests one reason they might differ.
Common questions
Who are Mizrahim and Ashkenazim?
Mizrahim are Jews whose families came from Asia and North Africa, such as Morocco, Iraq, Yemen and Iran. Ashkenazim are Jews whose families came from Europe and America. Both are broad groups made of many communities.
What did Swirski mean by not backward but made backward?
That the weaker position of many Mizrahim was not brought from their countries of origin but produced in Israel, by where they were settled, the schools and tracks they were sent to and the jobs open to them.
Does the ethnic gap still exist?
Sociologists disagree. Gaps in years of schooling have narrowed and many families are of mixed origin, but some studies of administrative data find that the gap in higher education, and with it in earnings, has not closed.
Why is the third generation hard to study?
Official statistics record origin by one's own or one's father's place of birth. Once the father was born in Israel, the person is recorded as of Israeli origin, so researchers need surveys or linked records of grandparents.
What is the difference between the ethnic gap and ethnic identity?
The gap is measured in numbers, such as degrees and income. Ethnic identity is how people see themselves and are seen by others, which can stay important even where the numbers draw closer.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.