- Jewish Thought: Free Will and Providence in Depth
Why was Pharaoh punished if God hardened his heart?
Pharaoh was punished because he first chose evil freely: for the first five plagues the Torah says he hardened his own heart. Maimonides explains that God's hardening was itself the punishment, the withholding of repentance from a man who had sinned greatly. Sforno reads it the other way: it kept Pharaoh free from fear, so his choice stayed his own.
The topic explained
The question in the verses
Before the plagues God tells Moses: “וַאֲנִי אַקְשֶׁה אֶת־לֵב פַּרְעֹה” (and I will harden Pharaoh's heart, Exodus 7:3). Judaism holds that every person is free to choose, and that reward and punishment follow from that freedom. So the Ramban states the problem plainly: “אם השם הקשה את לבו מה פשעו” (if God hardened his heart, what was his sin?).
A careful reading of the verbs helps. In the first five plagues the verses say only that Pharaoh's heart was hardened, or that he hardened it himself: “וַיַּכְבֵּד פַּרְעֹה אֶת־לִבּוֹ גַּם בַּפַּעַם הַזֹּאת” (and Pharaoh hardened his heart this time also, Exodus 8:28). Only at the sixth plague, the boils, does a verse say: “וַיְחַזֵּק ה׳ אֶת־לֵב פַּרְעֹה” (and the Lord hardened Pharaoh's heart, Exodus 9:12). The hardening of Pharaoh's heart comes after five free refusals, not before them. Each time a plague stopped, Pharaoh had a real chance to keep his word, and each time he broke it.
Maimonides: a punishment that takes away the way back
Maimonides answers in the laws of repentance. A person may sin so greatly that the just punishment is “שמונעין ממנו התשובה ואין מניחין לו רשות לשוב מרשעו” (that repentance is withheld from him, and he is not given leave to return from his wickedness, Hilkhot Teshuvah 6:3). That is what happened to Pharaoh: “לפי שחטא מעצמו תחלה והרע לישראל הגרים בארצו” (because he sinned of himself first and did evil to Israel who lived in his land).
Maimonides closes the law with a sentence that guards free will: “נמצאת אומר שלא גזר האל על פרעה להרע לישראל” (so you find that God did not decree on Pharaoh to do evil to Israel). The common misreading is that God built Pharaoh to be wicked. For Maimonides, Pharaoh chose cruelty freely; the hardened heart is the price of that choice, and the price fits the sin. Maimonides lists others who lost the way back in the same manner, among them Sihon king of the Amorites, and so the case of Pharaoh becomes a general law about sin and repentance.
The Ramban and Sforno: freedom from fear
The Ramban gives Maimonides' answer and adds a second one. By the later plagues Pharaoh wanted to let Israel go only because he could no longer bear the pain, not because he accepted God's will. God strengthened his spirit so that the plagues would not force his hand.
Sforno, a sixteenth-century commentator in Italy, builds his whole reading on this. “ואין ספק שלולא הכבדת הלב היה פרעה משלח את ישראל” (there is no doubt that without the hardening of the heart Pharaoh would have sent Israel away), but out of fear of the plagues, and that is no repentance at all. “אבל אם היה פרעה חפץ להכנע לאל יתברך ולשוב אליו בתשובה שלמה לא היה לו מזה שום מונע” (but had Pharaoh wished to submit to God and return to Him in full repentance, nothing would have stopped him). For Sforno the hardening does not take Pharaoh's freedom away: it gives it back, by removing the terror that would have decided for him.
Weighing the two answers
The two answers agree that Pharaoh was free at the start and responsible for his first cruelty. They differ on what the hardening is. For Maimonides it closes a door; for Sforno it keeps a door open by taking away pressure. A strong bagrut answer quotes the verbs of the story, explains each thinker in his own words, and adds what both teach about people today: a choice made again and again becomes a habit, and a habit can harden a heart until change is hard.
Practice: the hardening of Pharaoh's heart
For 12th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
Exodus 7:3 says: “וַאֲנִי אַקְשֶׁה אֶת־לֵב פַּרְעֹה” (and I will harden Pharaoh's heart). Why does this verse seem to clash with the belief in free will?
Complete the table: who hardens the heart in plagues one to five, and in the sixth plague?
Why does the order of the verbs matter for the question of free will?
Fill in the missing step in Maimonides' reading.
Maimonides writes: “נמצאת אומר שלא גזר האל על פרעה להרע לישראל” (God did not decree on Pharaoh to do evil to Israel). What misreading does this sentence prevent?
Complete the diagram with Sforno's answer and explain it in one sentence.
Write a paragraph comparing Maimonides and Sforno. Which answer protects free will better, in your view?
Common questions
Did Pharaoh have free will?
According to Maimonides, the Ramban and Sforno, yes: Pharaoh chose freely to enslave Israel and to refuse Moses in the first plagues; the hardening came only after that, as a response to his own choices.
How many times did Pharaoh harden his own heart?
In the first five plagues the verses say only that Pharaoh's heart was hardened or that he hardened it himself; the first verse that says God hardened it comes at the sixth plague, the boils (Exodus 9:12).
What does Maimonides say about Pharaoh's heart?
In Hilkhot Teshuvah 6:3 he explains that a person who sins greatly may be punished by having repentance withheld, and that this is what happened to Pharaoh, who sinned of his own will first.
What is Sforno's explanation of the hardening?
Sforno says that without it Pharaoh would have freed Israel only out of fear of the plagues, which is not repentance; the hardening let him choose freely, and nothing stopped him from true repentance.
What can a modern reader learn from Pharaoh's hardened heart?
That repeated choices shape a person: a wrong done again and again becomes a habit, and the habit can make it very hard to change, though the first choices were free.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.