• Drama for the literature bagrut: tragedy and the modern play

What makes a tragedy according to Aristotle?

Written with AI (How we create content)Target level: Grade 11Last updated: Report an error
Quick answer

According to Aristotle's Poetics, a tragedy is the imitation of a serious, complete action that arouses pity and fear and brings about their catharsis. Its plot shows a tragic hero, a man of high standing who is neither very good nor wicked, falling from good fortune to bad through an error (hamartia), often by way of a reversal (peripeteia) and a recognition (anagnorisis).

The topic explained

What a tragedy is, according to Aristotle

Tragedy according to Aristotle is defined by its plot and by what that plot does to an audience. In the Poetics, written in the fourth century BCE, about a century after the plays of Sophocles, he states: “Tragedy, then, is an imitation of an action that is serious, complete, and of a certain magnitude,” acted rather than narrated, and working “through pity and fear effecting the proper purgation of these emotions” (S. H. Butcher's translation).

The plot comes first; Aristotle calls it “the soul of a tragedy,” ahead of character. Each event must be “the necessary or probable result of the preceding action,” so the disaster grows out of what the hero does. The first misreading to avoid: not every play with a sad ending is a tragedy. A good king killed by an earthquake is unlucky, not tragic, because nothing he did brought it on.

A staircase of five boxes stepping down from left to right: high standing, hamartia the error, reversal, recognition and catastrophe, joined by arrows; from the last step an arrow leads left to a box marked catharsis.high standinghamartia: the errorreversalrecognitioncatastrophecatharsis
The arc of a tragedy: the hero falls step by step, and the audience is left with pity and fear.

The tragic hero and the tragic error

Aristotle finds the tragic hero by elimination. A virtuous man falling into misery moves neither pity nor fear: “it merely shocks us.” A bad man rising is not tragic at all, and a villain's downfall feels just but stirs no pity or fear, “for pity is aroused by unmerited misfortune, fear by the misfortune of a man like ourselves.” What remains is a man “not eminently good and just,” brought down “not by vice or depravity, but by some error or frailty,” and “highly renowned and prosperous,” like Oedipus.

That error is hamartia, from a Greek verb for missing the mark, as an arrow misses. Israeli classes call it “טעות טרגית” (ta'ut tragit, tragic error) or “חטא טרגי” (chet tragi, tragic sin). The common mistake is to read it as wickedness or as a fixed flaw. Oedipus kills a stranger where three roads meet without knowing he is his father: an error of knowledge. Many readers add hubris, pride that oversteps human limits, as in his rage at the prophet Teiresias. A strong answer says which it means and shows it in the text.

A table of the four plots Aristotle considers in Poetics chapter 13: a good man who falls only shocks us; a bad man who rises is not tragic; a villain who falls is just but stirs no pity or fear; a man like us who falls arouses pity and fear.WhoChangeWhat we feela good manfallsshock, no pitya bad manrisesnothing tragica villainfallsjust, no pity or feara man like usfallspity and fear
Only the last plot is tragic: the hero who falls through an error.

Reversal and recognition

A reversal (peripeteia; in Hebrew מהפך, mahapach) is “a change by which the action veers round to its opposite.” Aristotle's example is Oedipus the King: “the messenger comes to cheer Oedipus and free him from his alarms about his mother, but by revealing who he is, he produces the opposite effect.” The point is not that things get worse, but that an act meant to bring one result brings its opposite.

A recognition (anagnorisis; in Hebrew הכרה, hakara, or התוודעות, hitvada'ut) is “a change from ignorance to knowledge.” Aristotle adds: “The best form of recognition is coincident with a Reversal of the Situation, as in the Oedipus.” The messenger's good news turns into the truth Oedipus has been hunting, and the hunter finds himself. Students often write that the hero realizes his mistake; in the strongest recognitions he learns who he is.

Catharsis, and how to apply the terms

Catharsis is Butcher's “purgation”: the release, or on other readings the purifying or clarifying, of the pity and fear the play arouses. Aristotle never explains the word in the surviving Poetics, so an answer should name the emotions and their causes: pity because Oedipus suffers more than he deserves, fear because he is a man like us, who acted on what he believed was true.

To apply the terms, take four steps: name the term, point to the exact moment, quote the words, and say what the moment does to the audience. Not every tragedy uses every term, and forcing a checklist onto a play is the most common mistake. In Sophocles' Antigone, Creon's recognition comes when he cries “Woe is me, for the wretched blindness of my counsels!” and the chorus answers “Ah me, how all too late thou seemest to see the right!” (R. C. Jebb's translation).

A diagram: at the top the hero's fall; arrows lead down to two boxes, pity because the fall is undeserved, on the left, and fear because he is one like us, on the right; from both, arrows lead down to catharsis.the hero's fallpity: undeservedfear: one like uscatharsis
Two emotions, two causes, one release.
Free printable worksheet

Aristotle's terms for tragedy: practice

For 11th grade students reading tragedy for the literature bagrut. Read each passage on the sheet, answer in full sentences, then check your work against the answers.

Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.

Free printable worksheetlessoons.com
Aristotle's terms for tragedy: practiceName:
  1. Match each term to its definition. Terms: a. hamartia, b. peripeteia (reversal), c. anagnorisis (recognition), d. catharsis. Definitions: 1. a change from ignorance to knowledge; 2. the release of pity and fear in the audience; 3. the hero's error, a missing of the mark; 4. an action that turns into its opposite.

  2. Aristotle sorts four plots by what they make the audience feel. Complete the right-hand column of the table.

    The table of Aristotle's four plots with the right-hand column empty: a good man falls, a bad man rises, a villain falls, a man like us falls, and a question mark for what the audience feels in each.WhoChangeWhat we feela good manfalls?a bad manrises?a villainfalls?a man like usfalls?
  3. Oedipus fears an oracle that says he will marry his mother. A messenger from Corinth tries to reassure him (Jebb's translation): Messenger: “Then why have I not freed thee, king, from this fear, seeing that I came with friendly purpose?” A few lines later: Messenger: “Because Polybus was nothing to thee in blood.” Why does Aristotle call this moment a reversal?

  4. Complete the arc of the tragedy of Oedipus the King: what fills each step?

    An empty staircase of the tragedy of Oedipus, stepping down from left to right: high standing, hamartia, reversal, recognition and catastrophe, each followed by a question mark, and a box marked catharsis at the bottom left.high standing: ?hamartia: ?reversal: ?recognition: ?catastrophe: ?catharsis
  5. Pity or fear? Say which emotion each sentence describes, and why. a. He did not know the man was his father; no one deserves such a fate. b. He trusted what he knew, as anyone would. It could happen to me.

  6. Is this a tragedy in Aristotle's terms? A kind, honest king loses his family in an earthquake. Explain in two sentences.

  7. A student wrote: “In Oedipus the King there is a reversal because something bad happens to Oedipus.” What is wrong with the answer? Rewrite it.

  8. Apply the terms to Creon in Sophocles' Antigone. He forbids the burial of Polyneices, condemns Antigone to death and ignores every warning until the prophet Teiresias foretells the death of his son. At the end he cries: “Woe is me, for the wretched blindness of my counsels!” Name his hamartia, his reversal and his recognition.

More topics and worksheets at lessoons.com© 2026 Lessons

Common questions

What is the difference between hamartia and hubris?

Hamartia is Aristotle's word for the error that brings the hero down, a missing of the mark. Hubris is pride that oversteps the limits set for human beings. The two can meet in one character, as when anger drives Oedipus's error, but they are not the same: Aristotle's tragic hero falls through an error, and pride is not part of his definition.

Is hamartia a tragic flaw?

Not exactly. Tragic flaw is a popular English rendering, but Aristotle's word means an error, and he sets it against “vice or depravity.” The error can come from ignorance, as with Oedipus, who did not know whom he had killed. Write tragic error unless you can show a trait of character driving the hero's mistake.

What is the difference between reversal and recognition?

Reversal happens to the action: a deed turns into its opposite. Recognition happens in a mind: a character passes from ignorance to knowledge. In Oedipus the King they come together, which is why Aristotle praised it: the news that reverses Oedipus's fortune also tells him who he is.

Does every tragedy end in death?

No. Aristotle asks for a change of fortune “not from bad to good, but, reversely, from good to bad,” and says unhappy endings are the most tragic on stage. Death is common, but the core is the fall: Oedipus does not die at the end of Oedipus the King. He lives on, blind, and asks to be sent away from Thebes.

What does catharsis mean?

Catharsis is a Greek word for cleansing; Butcher translates it as “purgation.” Aristotle uses it of the pity and fear a tragedy arouses, and because he never defines it in the surviving Poetics, scholars read it as a release of these emotions, a purifying of them or a clarifying of what they teach. In an answer, say what the audience feels and why.

Why did Aristotle see Oedipus the King as the model tragedy?

Because it has what he valued most: a hero of high renown who falls through an error rather than wickedness, and a recognition that comes at the very moment of the reversal. He names the play again and again in the Poetics, and says that even hearing its story told should make one “thrill with horror and melt to pity.”

Still have a question? Ask Lessi

Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.

Try asking

Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.

Learn it with a teacher

Learn this topic live with Lessi

Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.