- Accounting: costs, break-even and budgets
How do you analyze budget variances?
To analyze budget variances, set each line of actual results beside its budget and find the difference: favorable if it raises profit, unfavorable if it lowers it. Then compare costs with a flexible budget for the volume actually sold, and split each cost variance into price and quantity, to see what really went differently.
The topic explained
Budget against actual, line by line
A budget is a plan; after the month it becomes a yardstick. Each line of the actual results is set beside its budget, and the difference is a variance. Analyzing budget variances starts with one rule for the sign: a variance is favorable (F) when it raises profit, sales above budget or a cost below it, and unfavorable (U) when it lowers profit. A cost that came in ₪2,000 over budget is ₪2,000 U, even though the number is bigger.
A made-up furniture workshop budgeted 500 chairs at ₪300, with materials of ₪60 and labor of ₪40 a chair and fixed costs of ₪50,000: a profit of ₪50,000. It actually sold 450 chairs at ₪310. Sales were ₪10,500 U, fixed costs ₪2,000 U and profit ₪9,300 U. Materials, ₪29,700 against ₪30,000, look ₪300 favorable, and labor ₪2,900 favorable.
The flexible budget: comparing like with like
Those cost variances mislead. The budget was for 500 chairs and the workshop made 450, so of course it spent less. A flexible budget recalculates the budget for the volume actually sold, keeping the budgeted prices and costs per unit: for 450 chairs, sales ₪135,000, materials ₪27,000, labor ₪18,000, fixed costs still ₪50,000, profit ₪40,000.
Against it, the picture changes. Sales are ₪4,500 F, the ₪10 higher price on 450 chairs. Materials are ₪2,700 U, not favorable at all. Labor is ₪900 F, fixed costs ₪2,000 U, and profit ₪700 F. The rest of the ₪9,300 shortfall is the volume variance: 50 fewer chairs, each with a contribution of 300 − 60 − 40 = ₪200, cost ₪10,000 U. Check: 10,000 U + 700 F = ₪9,300 U.
Price or quantity? Splitting a cost variance
A cost variance can come from paying a different price or from using a different amount. The standard is 3 kg of wood per chair at ₪20 a kilo. The workshop bought 1,500 kg at ₪19.80, ₪29,700, while 450 chairs should have used 1,350 kg. The price variance is (19.80 − 20) × 1,500 = ₪300 F: the wood was a little cheaper. The quantity variance is (1,500 − 1,350) × 20 = ₪3,000 U: 150 kg more than the standard. Together, ₪2,700 U, the flexible budget variance.
The split points at people. Purchasing answers for the price, production for the quantity. Here the two may be linked: cheaper wood of poorer quality can mean more waste, so the small saving in price cost ten times as much in quantity.
Reading variances wisely
Favorable is not always good and unfavorable not always bad. Labor ₪900 F may mean the staff rushed and the waste of wood rose; fixed costs ₪2,000 U may be a repair that prevents a breakdown. A variance is a question to ask, not a verdict. Managers look first at the large ones, usually compared with the budget line, and at those that repeat month after month. The commonest mistake is to judge costs against the original budget when the volume has changed: always flex the budget first.
Practice: budget variances
For 12th grade accounting students. A T-shirt printer budgeted 1,000 shirts at ₪50, variable costs ₪20 a shirt and fixed costs ₪18,000. It sold 1,100 shirts at ₪48, with variable costs of ₪23,100 and fixed costs of ₪18,500. Check the answers at the end.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
Is each variance favorable or unfavorable: sales above budget; rent below budget; materials above budget; profit below budget?
Complete the variances of budget against actual.
Complete the variances of the flexible budget for 1,100 shirts against actual.
Why does the variable cost variance of ₪3,100 U against the original budget overstate the problem?
Split the profit variance of ₪800 U into the volume variance and the flexible budget variance.
Next month the workshop makes 500 chairs and uses 1,560 kg of wood at ₪21 a kilo; the standard is 3 kg at ₪20. Find the price and quantity variances.
A manager praises the buyer for the favorable price variance of ₪300 in the chairs month. What should he also look at?
Common questions
What is the difference between a favorable and an unfavorable variance?
A favorable variance raises profit compared with the budget: sales above budget or a cost below it. An unfavorable variance lowers profit: sales below budget or a cost above it.
What is a flexible budget?
The budget recalculated for the volume actually achieved, using the budgeted price and costs per unit and the budgeted fixed costs. It lets each cost be compared with what it should have been at the real volume.
Is a favorable variance always good?
No. A saving on cheap materials can cause waste, and a labor saving can come from rushed work. A variance shows where results differed from the plan; the reason has to be found before judging it.
What is a volume variance?
The part of the profit variance caused by selling more or fewer units than budgeted: the difference in units times the budgeted contribution per unit. It is the gap between the flexible and the original budget profit.
Which variances should a manager investigate?
Usually the large ones compared with their budget line, and the ones that recur month after month. Small, one-off variances are often normal and cost more to investigate than they are worth.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.