- Biotechnology: bioethics and the regulation of research
What is the difference between somatic and germline gene editing?
Somatic gene editing changes the DNA of body cells, such as blood stem cells, so only the treated person is affected and the change is not inherited. Germline gene editing changes an egg, sperm or early embryo, so the change is in every cell of the person who develops and can pass to their children. Somatic CRISPR therapies are approved; heritable editing is banned in many countries.
The topic explained
One person, or every generation after
What is the difference between somatic and germline gene editing? It lies in which cells are changed. Somatic cells are the cells of the body, skin, liver, blood; a change in them stays with the person who has it. Germ cells are eggs and sperm and the cells that make them, and an early embryo is still a small group of cells from which every cell of a future person will come. Change the DNA there, and the change is in every cell of that person, including their own eggs or sperm, so it can pass to their children and to all later generations who inherit it.
The first approved CRISPR therapy is somatic. In Casgevy, blood stem cells are taken from a patient with sickle cell disease, edited outside the body so that they make fetal hemoglobin, and returned. Britain's regulator approved it on 16 November 2023 and the US FDA on 8 December 2023. A common misreading is that editing stem cells is germline editing. Blood stem cells are body cells: the patient's children inherit nothing from the edit.
The case of 2018
In November 2018 the Chinese researcher He Jiankui announced that he had used CRISPR on human embryos to disable a gene called CCR5, aiming to make the children resistant to HIV, and that twin girls had been born. Scientists around the world condemned the work: the babies were healthy and had no condition to treat, the safety of the edits was unknown, and the parents' consent was questioned. On 30 December 2019 a court in Shenzhen sentenced him to three years in prison and a large fine for illegal medical practice, and confirmed that a third gene-edited baby had been born.
The case showed the risks the rules had anticipated. An edit made in an embryo can miss some cells, leaving a mosaic person with edited and unedited cells, or change the DNA at unintended places, off-target edits, and any error would be inherited. Even a perfect edit of CCR5 carries a cost no one can measure in advance, because the gene may have jobs in the body that are not yet understood.
What the rules say
The Oviedo Convention of the Council of Europe, signed in 1997, allows an intervention on the human genome only for prevention, diagnosis or therapy, and only if it does not aim to change the genome of descendants; in 2022 its bioethics committee confirmed that this covers research as well as treatment. In Israel, the Prohibition of Genetic Intervention Law of 1999 forbids using reproductive cells that have been deliberately genetically changed to bring about a pregnancy. It was passed for a fixed period and has been extended since, again in 2024. Somatic editing, by contrast, is regulated like any new treatment, through clinical trials and approval. So the legal line runs exactly where the biological one does: at whether the change can reach the next generation.
The arguments on each side
Supporters of allowing heritable editing one day, under strict conditions, argue that it could spare a family a serious inherited disease when no other route exists, and spare every later generation too. Opponents answer that the risks fall on people who cannot consent, the children and their descendants; that screening embryos for the disease before pregnancy already serves most such families; and that once allowed for disease, editing could slide toward enhancement and widen inequality. Many scientists hold a middle view: no heritable editing now, while safety and public agreement are lacking. A bagrut answer gives each side its reasons and the evidence it rests on.
Practice: somatic and germline gene editing
For 12th grade biotechnology students. Answer each question in full sentences, then compare with the answers.
Free, no sign-up. The answer key prints on the second page. Regenerating a new worksheet on the same topic needs a free account.
Complete the hidden row: is a somatic edit inherited? Is a germline edit? Explain the difference.
Fill in the third generation of the germline column, and explain why.
Casgevy edits a patient's blood stem cells. Is it somatic or germline editing? Explain.
Give three reasons scientists condemned the 2018 gene-edited twins.
Fill in the event of 2023, and say why it matters for this topic.
What does Article 13 of the Oviedo Convention allow and forbid?
Present one argument for and one against allowing heritable gene editing in the future.
Common questions
Is germline gene editing legal?
Using edited embryos or germ cells to start a pregnancy is prohibited in many countries, including Israel and the states bound by the Oviedo Convention. Laboratory research on embryos is regulated differently from place to place.
Are somatic gene therapies approved?
Yes. Several somatic gene therapies are approved, and in 2023 Casgevy became the first approved therapy made with CRISPR, after clinical trials. Whether a therapy suits a person is a decision for doctors.
What is mosaicism in gene editing?
A state in which some of a person's cells carry an edit and others do not, which can happen when an embryo is edited after its cells have begun to divide.
Why did He Jiankui target the CCR5 gene?
CCR5 codes for a protein that most strains of HIV use to enter cells, and he aimed to make the children resistant. Critics noted that safer ways to prevent infection already existed.
What is the difference between gene editing and embryo screening?
Embryo screening tests embryos made by IVF and chooses one without a disease variant; nothing is changed. Gene editing changes the DNA itself.

Still have a question? Ask Lessi
Any question about this subject. Lessi answers right here, step by step.
Try asking
Asking needs a free account; your question is kept while you sign up. Answers are written by AI and can contain mistakes. Lessi doesn’t give medical or legal advice.
Learn it with a teacher
Learn this topic live with Lessi
Lessi, the AI teacher, explains it out loud on a board, with short quizzes, at your pace. The first 60 minutes are free.