# Who were Rabbi Alkalai and Rabbi Kalischer?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: Zionist Thinkers](https://lessoons.com/en/zionist-thinkers) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/zionist-thinkers/who-were-rabbi-alkalai-and-rabbi-kalischer

Rabbi Yehuda Alkalai (1798-1878) and Rabbi Zvi Hirsch Kalischer (1795-1874) were Orthodox rabbis who argued, decades before Herzl, that the redemption promised by the prophets would begin naturally, with Jews settling and farming the Land of Israel. They are called the forerunners of Zionism, and their idea made a religious Zionism possible.

## The topic explained

### Two rabbis before Herzl

Zionism is often dated from Herzl in the 1890s, but its first voices were rabbis. Rabbi Yehuda Alkalai, born in Sarajevo in 1798, served the Sephardic community of Semlin, today part of Belgrade. Rabbi Zvi Hirsch Kalischer, born in Lissa in 1795, was the acting rabbi of Thorn in Prussia for more than forty years and refused any salary.

They lived at two ends of Europe and came from different Jewish worlds, Sephardic and Ashkenazi. Yet both reached the same idea: the redemption the prophets promised would not begin with a miracle from heaven, but with Jews returning to the land and working it. That is why they are called the forerunners of Zionism. Neither man set out to found a political movement: each wrote as a rabbi answering a question of faith, whether Jews may act to bring the redemption closer.

### Alkalai: a plan for return

In 1840 the Jews of Damascus were falsely accused of ritual murder, and only the intervention of Jewish leaders in Europe saved them. The affair convinced Alkalai that the Jews needed a land of their own, and that the help of the powers could make it happen. In his Kabbalistic reading, 1840 also opened a period of redemption that people could take hold of or lose.

His proposals were practical: an assembly of Jewish notables to speak for the people, a tithe to fund settlement, Hebrew as the national language, and farming as the basis of life in the land. Land, he said, should be bought, as Abraham bought the cave of Machpelah: “וַיִּשְׁקֹל אַבְרָהָם לְעֶפְרֹן אֶת־הַכֶּסֶף” (and Abraham weighed out the silver to Ephron, Genesis 23:16). In 1874, at seventy-six, he settled in Jerusalem, where he died in 1878.

### Kalischer: redemption by natural means

Kalischer set out his view in Derishat Tzion, the Seeking of Zion, in 1862. Its first thesis is the boldest: the salvation promised by the prophets will come in a natural way, through the Jews' own efforts. The second is immigration to the land.

His plan had four steps: collect money from Jews in every country, buy land and farm it, found an agricultural school, and form a Jewish guard for the settlements. His campaign helped found a colonization society in Frankfurt in 1860, and led the Alliance Israélite Universelle to open the Mikveh Israel agricultural school in 1870. The second part of the book speaks to the nations who believe in the Bible, arguing that they too can hope for the Jews' return as part of the salvation of the whole world. The book made a deep impression in Eastern Europe and was translated into German in 1865.

### The critics and the legacy

Many rabbis rejected them. Some called Alkalai's idea, that human acts could hasten the Messiah, heretical; Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch opposed Kalischer, holding that the path to redemption is to become better Jews, repent and wait. The common misreading is that the forerunners were secular nationalists in rabbinic dress. They were the opposite: devout Jews who read settlement as a religious duty and the first step of redemption. Their central claim, that settling the land is itself a religious act and the start of redemption, became a pillar of later religious Zionism. Herzl's own grandfather is reported to have attended Alkalai's synagogue in Semlin. A strong bagrut answer presents both men, the critics' answer, and the link to later religious Zionism.

## Practice: Alkalai and Kalischer

For 12th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Why are Alkalai and Kalischer called the forerunners of Zionism?** — Because decades before Herzl they called for Jews to return to the Land of Israel and settle it, as the natural beginning of the redemption.
2. **Complete the table: what is Kalischer's known book, and where did Alkalai die?** — Derishat Tzion (1862); Alkalai died in Jerusalem.
3. **What event convinced Alkalai that the Jews needed a land of their own, and what else did it teach him?** — The Damascus affair of 1840; it also showed him that the intervention of European powers and Jewish leaders could help such a plan succeed.
4. **Complete the table: what did Alkalai propose about Hebrew?** — Hebrew as the national language of the Jews.
5. **Alkalai pointed to Abraham, who “וַיִּשְׁקֹל אַבְרָהָם לְעֶפְרֹן אֶת־הַכֶּסֶף” (weighed out the silver to Ephron). What does this precedent teach about how land should be gained?** — That land in the Land of Israel should be bought openly and paid for, as Abraham paid for the cave of Machpelah.
6. **Complete the diagram with the critics' answer.** — No: the way to redemption is to repent, become better Jews, and wait for it.
7. **Write a paragraph: explain Kalischer's claim that redemption comes by natural means, and present one objection to it.** — A good answer explains that the prophets' promise is fulfilled through human effort (money, land, farming, a guard), and presents the objection of Rabbi Hirsch or of rabbis who called hastening the Messiah heretical, weighing both.

## Common questions

### Who was Rabbi Zvi Hirsch Kalischer?

An Orthodox rabbi in Thorn, Prussia (1795-1874), who in Derishat Tzion (1862) argued that the redemption would begin naturally, through Jews buying and farming land in the Land of Israel.

### Who was Rabbi Yehuda Alkalai?

A Sephardic rabbi (1798-1878), born in Sarajevo and rabbi of Semlin, who called for a return to Zion, Hebrew as a national language and buying land, and settled in Jerusalem in 1874.

### What is Derishat Tzion?

Kalischer's book of 1862, the Seeking of Zion. It argues that salvation comes by natural means, calls for immigration, and proposes buying and farming land, an agricultural school and a Jewish guard.

### Were the forerunners of Zionism religious?

Yes. Alkalai and Kalischer were Orthodox rabbis who saw settling the land as a religious duty and the beginning of redemption, unlike later secular Zionists.

### Why did some rabbis oppose Kalischer and Alkalai?

Many held that redemption must come from God and that human acts to hasten it were wrong; Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch taught that the way was repentance and waiting.
