# What is Zelinsky's mobility transition model?

> Written with AI · [Geography: migration and refugees in the world](https://lessoons.com/en/world-migration) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/world-migration/what-is-zelinskys-mobility-transition-model

Zelinsky's mobility transition model (1971) says that the way people move changes as a society passes through the demographic transition. In five phases, a traditional society with little migration gives way to mass movement from villages to cities and abroad, then to movement between cities and to suburbs, daily commuting and the arrival of immigrant workers.

## The topic explained

### Migration changes as a society changes

In 1971 the American geographer Wilbur Zelinsky published The Hypothesis of the Mobility Transition in the Geographical Review. His idea was to complete the demographic transition model, which follows births and deaths, with a third part: movement. Zelinsky's mobility transition model says that each stage of the demographic transition has its own typical kinds of migration and of circulation, the short, repeated movements such as commuting and travel that do not change a person's home.

The model describes five phases. In a premodern traditional society there is little migration. In an early transitional society there is mass movement from villages to cities and emigration abroad. In a late transitional society moves between cities overtake moves from the countryside. In an advanced society people move from city to city, out to the suburbs and daily to work, and immigrant workers arrive. In a future super-advanced society nearly all moves are within and between cities.

### Two trends across the phases

Read the model as two curves. Migration from village to city rises steeply in phase II, when the death rate has fallen, the countryside is crowded with young people and factories in the cities need workers; it slows in phase III and becomes small in phases IV and V, when few people are left on the farms. Circulation goes the other way: it grows through every phase, with railways, cars, commuting and holidays.

The common misreading is that migration simply rises with development. What changes is mainly its kind: from village to city, then between cities, and from moving house to traveling every day. Zelinsky even speculated that in phase V better communication might replace some travel, a guess that video calls and working from home have partly borne out.

### The link to the demographic transition

Each mobility phase sits beside a stage of the demographic transition. In stage 1 births and deaths are both high and the population hardly grows, so there is little pressure to move. In stage 2 deaths fall fast while births stay high; the rural population swells, and the surplus leaves for the cities or abroad. Europe in the 19th century fits: industrializing countries sent tens of millions of emigrants to the Americas. In stages 3 and 4 births fall, the countryside empties, and movement shifts to cities and suburbs. A low birth rate also leaves jobs unfilled, which helps explain immigration in phase IV: West Germany recruited guest workers from southern Europe and Türkiye from 1955 until 1973.

### What the model misses

Critics call the model diffusionist: it assumes that mobility spreads from rich countries to poor ones along one path, as if every country must repeat Europe's history. Later research, for example by Hein de Haas, found that emigration from a poor country often rises at first as incomes and schooling grow, because more people can afford to leave, and falls only later. The model also says little about refugees and about borders and visas, which decide who can move at all. Still, Thomas Cooke and colleagues argued in 2018 that the model remains a useful, flexible frame.

On the bagrut, place a country in a phase with evidence, link it to its demographic stage, and add one criticism.

## Practice: the mobility transition

For 12th grade geography students. The curves are models made up for this sheet. Use the tables and graphs printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your answers.

1. **Fill in the main movement of phase II and phase IV.** — Phase II: mass movement from villages to cities, and emigration abroad. Phase IV: movement from city to city and out to the suburbs, daily commuting, and the arrival of immigrant workers.
2. **Which curve shows migration from village to city, and which shows circulation? Explain using the phases.** — Curve A is village-to-city migration: it peaks in phase II, when the rural population swells, and falls as the countryside empties. Curve B is circulation: commuting and travel keep growing through every phase.
3. **Fill in the births and deaths for demographic stages 2 and 3, and explain why stage 2 pushes people out of the countryside.** — Stage 2: deaths fall fast while births stay high. Stage 3: births fall. In stage 2 the rural population grows faster than the land can support, so young people leave for the cities or abroad.
4. **A country has a low birth rate, most people live in cities, millions commute daily, and many workers arrive from poorer countries. Which phase is it in? Give two clues.** — Phase IV, an advanced society. Clues: daily commuting (high circulation), the arrival of immigrant workers, and an urban population with a low birth rate.
5. **Write the two missing criticisms.** — One path for all: countries differ and need not repeat Europe's history. Emigration falls early: in fact emigration from poor countries often rises first as incomes and schooling grow.
6. **West Germany recruited guest workers from 1955 until 1973. Explain how this fits phase IV of Zelinsky's model.** — In phase IV a developed country with a low birth rate and a fast-growing economy runs short of workers, so it draws immigrant workers, often for unskilled and semi-skilled jobs, from less developed countries, as West Germany did from southern Europe and Türkiye.

## Common questions

### What are the five phases of the Zelinsky model?

Phase I, the premodern traditional society, with little migration; phase II, the early transitional society, with mass movement to cities and abroad; phase III, the late transitional society, with more moves between cities; phase IV, the advanced society, with suburbs, commuting and immigrant workers; phase V, a future super-advanced society.

### What is circulation in the Zelinsky model?

Circulation is short, repeated movement that does not change a person's home: commuting to work, trips to study, shopping and holidays. In the model it grows through every phase, while moving house from village to city peaks early and then declines.

### How is the Zelinsky model linked to the demographic transition model?

Each mobility phase matches a demographic stage. When deaths fall and births stay high, in stage 2, the countryside fills up and people leave for cities and abroad; when births fall in stages 3 and 4, the countryside empties and movement shifts between cities and to suburbs.

### What is the main criticism of the Zelinsky model?

That it assumes every country follows Europe's path in the same order, a diffusionist and universal view. Research shows emigration often rises at first with development, and the model says little about refugees, borders and visas.
