# What is brain drain?

> Written with AI · [Geography: migration and refugees in the world](https://lessoons.com/en/world-migration) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/world-migration/what-is-brain-drain

Brain drain is the emigration of educated and skilled people, such as doctors, engineers and scientists, from the country that trained them. The origin loses their skills and the cost of their education, and the destination gains them, a brain gain. When people move back and forth and bring skills home, geographers speak of brain circulation, which can benefit both countries.

## The topic explained

### Drain, gain and circulation

Brain drain is the departure of educated and skilled people from the country that trained them. The phrase was coined in Britain, by the Royal Society, for the scientists and engineers who left post-war Europe for North America. For the receiving country the same move is a brain gain: it gets a trained doctor or engineer without paying for the training.

The common misreading is to call every emigrant a brain drain. The term is about skills, and the effect is not always a loss. In her book The New Argonauts (2006), AnnaLee Saxenian showed engineers who studied and worked in Silicon Valley and then took their skills, capital and contacts back to Taiwan, Israel, India and China. Geographers call this brain circulation: movement in both directions, in which both countries can gain.

### A clear case: doctors and nurses

Health workers show the pattern best, because each one costs years of public money to train. According to the OECD, about 19.6 percent of doctors in its member countries in 2023 had their first medical degree from abroad, up from about 15 percent a decade before, and 8.8 percent of nurses were trained abroad. Rich countries fill their hospitals partly with staff trained elsewhere.

For a poor country the loss can be severe. In 2023 the World Health Organization listed 55 countries with the most pressing shortages of health workers, 37 of them in Africa, and asked other countries not to recruit actively from them, under a code of practice it adopted in 2010. A nurse who leaves a country with few nurses leaves a gap no remittance fills.

### Losses and gains for the country of origin

The losses are plain: the money spent on schooling, fewer doctors and teachers, fewer people to start businesses, and an older population left behind. In an extreme case, East Germany lost about 3.5 million people by 1961, about a fifth of its population, many of them young and skilled, and that year it built the Berlin Wall to stop them.

The gains are real too. Emigrants send remittances; some return with savings, skills and ideas; diasporas open trade and investment links; and the chance of working abroad can lead more young people to study, so the stock of skills at home may even grow. Whether a country loses or gains overall depends on how many leave, how many return and how strong the links stay.

### Israel, and what countries can do

Israel shows both sides. It gained greatly from immigration: about 979,000 people arrived from the former Soviet Union between 1989 and 2006, many of them engineers, doctors and scientists. At the same time, nearly 60 percent of the doctors working in Israel in 2021 had trained abroad, by OECD figures, and about half of those were Israelis who studied medicine abroad and came back, a clear case of circulation. Israelis also leave for academic and technology jobs abroad, and how large that loss is remains debated.

Countries respond with ethical recruitment codes, grants that bring scientists home, more training places at home and ties with their diaspora. On the bagrut, weigh the effects for both countries and name the kind of worker.

## Practice: brain drain

For 12th grade geography students. Use the tables and charts printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your answers.

1. **Write the effect of each kind of movement in the table.** — Brain drain: the country of origin loses skills and the money spent on training. Brain gain: the destination gains trained workers. Brain circulation: both countries can gain, as people return with skills and keep links.
2. **About 19 percent of OECD doctors trained abroad in 2021. Write the missing value and describe the trend from about 2011 to 2023.** — 19 percent. The share rose from about 15 percent to 19.6 percent, an increase of 19.6 - 15 = 4.6 percentage points: rich countries rely more and more on doctors trained elsewhere.
3. **A hospital in an OECD country employs 500 doctors. If it matched the 2023 OECD average of 19.6 percent, about how many of them trained abroad?** — 500 × 0.196 ≈ 98 doctors, about one in five.
4. **Fill in the missing stage of brain circulation and explain how it benefits the country of origin.** — Return home, with skills. People come back with knowledge, savings and contacts, start firms or teach, and open links with the country where they worked.
5. **East Germany lost about 3.5 million people by 1961, about 20 percent of its population. Roughly what was its population before they left?** — 3.5 ÷ 0.20 = 17.5 million people.
6. **Write the aims of the two hidden policies.** — Ethical recruitment: to protect poor countries from losing their scarce health workers. Train more at home: to need fewer workers from abroad.
7. **A small African country trains 100 nurses a year, and 40 leave each year for jobs in Europe. Give one argument that this is a loss and one that it may bring gains, and say what would decide the balance.** — Loss: the country paid to train them and its clinics stay short of nurses, a country WHO lists as short of health workers. Gain: they send remittances, some return with skills, and the chance of working abroad may draw more young people into nursing. The balance depends on how many return, how much money they send and whether training expands to replace them.

## Common questions

### What is the difference between brain drain and brain gain?

They are the same move seen from two sides. For the country that trained the person it is brain drain, a loss of skills and of the money spent on education. For the country that receives the person it is brain gain, a trained worker it did not pay to educate.

### What causes brain drain?

Higher pay, better equipment and research funding, career chances and political stability in the destination pull skilled people; low pay, few jobs for graduates, insecurity or conflict push them from home. Language, visas and the recruitment of rich countries also shape where they go.

### Is brain drain always bad for poor countries?

Not always. Remittances, returnees and diaspora links can make up part of the loss, and the chance to emigrate can lead more people to study. The harm is greatest where few skilled people exist, as with health workers in the countries WHO lists as short of them.

### How can a country stop brain drain?

No country can simply stop it, but it can reduce it: pay and equip professionals better, offer grants and jobs to those who return, train more at home, and keep ties with its diaspora. Destination countries can follow ethical recruitment codes such as WHO's of 2010.

### Does Israel have a brain drain?

Israel has both drain and gain. Many Israeli researchers and engineers work abroad, and the size of that loss is debated; at the same time Israel gained hundreds of thousands of skilled immigrants, and about half of its foreign-trained doctors are Israelis who studied abroad and returned.
