# Why are women exempt from time-bound commandments?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: Women and the Family](https://lessoons.com/en/women-and-family-in-jewish-thought) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/women-and-family-in-jewish-thought/why-are-women-exempt-from-time-bound-commandments

Women are exempt from most positive time-bound commandments, such as sukkah, shofar and tefillin, by a rule in Mishnah Kiddushin 1:7. The Mishnah gives no reason. Abudarham explained that a wife's time was bound to her home; Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch, that women need fewer reminders. Women may still keep these commandments, and are obligated in kiddush, matzah and more.

## The topic explained

### The rule in the Mishnah

The rule is stated in one line: “וכל מצות עשה שהזמן גרמה אנשים חיבין ונשים פטורות” (every positive commandment that time causes, men are obligated and women are exempt, Mishnah Kiddushin 1:7). A positive time-bound commandment is one that must be done at a set time: sukkah, lulav, shofar and tzitzit are the Talmud's examples (Kiddushin 33b).

The rule is narrow. Positive commandments without a set time, such as mezuzah, bind men and women alike, and so do all the prohibitions: “וכל מצות לא תעשה בין שהזמן גרמה בין שלא הזמן גרמה אחד אנשים ואחד נשים חיבין” (and every negative commandment, whether time causes it or not, men and women alike are obligated). Another Mishnah lists: “נשים ועבדים וקטנים פטורין מקריאת שמע ומן התפלין וחיבין בתפלה ובמזוזה ובברכת המזון” (women, slaves and minors are exempt from the Shema and tefillin, and obligated in prayer, mezuzah and grace after meals, Berakhot 3:3).

### A rule full of exceptions

The Talmud itself questions the rule: “וכללא הוא הרי מצה שמחה הקהל” (is it a rule? what about matzah, rejoicing and hakhel?, Kiddushin 34a): all are time-bound, and women are obligated in them. Women are also obligated in Shabbat kiddush: “נשים חייבות בקדוש היום דבר תורה” (women are obligated in the sanctification of the day by Torah law, Berakhot 20b).

Abudarham, a fourteenth-century commentator on the prayers in Seville, counts seven time-bound commandments that women must keep, among them the Megillah, Chanukah lights and the four cups of Passover. The common misreading is that women have almost no part in the festivals; in fact they share in the central commandments of Shabbat, Passover and Purim.

### Why? Three answers

The Mishnah gives no reason, and the Talmud learns the rule from tefillin, not from a principle. Abudarham offers a reason: “לפי שהאשה משועבדת לבעלה לעשות צרכיו” (because a woman is bound to her husband, to tend to his needs). If she were obligated, she might be torn between his request and God's command at the same moment, “לפיכך פטרה הבורא ממצותיו כדי להיות לה שלום עם בעלה” (therefore the Creator exempted her from His commandments, so that she would have peace with her husband).

Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch, in nineteenth-century Germany, answered differently, in words we summarize. He noted that the exceptions are nearly as many as the rule, so the exemption cannot mean that women are of lesser worth. In his view these commandments are reminders, renewed at fixed times, and the Torah judged that women, firm in their faith, need them less than men. Some modern readers find both explanations tied to the society of their time; others see in them a real respect for women's role.

### Exempt is not forbidden

An exemption does not forbid. The Talmud reports: “מיכל בת כושי היתה מנחת תפילין ולא מיחו בה חכמים” (Michal, daughter of Kushi, used to put on tefillin and the sages did not protest, Eruvin 96a). The Shulchan Arukh allows women to blow the shofar, and the Rema adds: “והמנהג שהנשים מברכות על מצות עשה שהזמן גרמא” (the custom is that women bless on positive time-bound commandments, Orach Chayim 589:6). In many Ashkenazi communities women hear the shofar and bless on the lulav, following the Rema; many Sephardi communities follow Rabbi Yosef Karo, and women keep these commandments without a blessing.

A strong bagrut answer states the rule and its exceptions, presents the reasons each in its own words without mocking any of them, and distinguishes exempt from forbidden. It may also note what the exemption leaves open: a woman who keeps a commandment she is exempt from still does a deed the tradition values.

## Practice: women and time-bound commandments

For 11th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **What is a positive time-bound commandment? Give two examples.** — A commandment to do something at a set time, such as sukkah, shofar, lulav or tzitzit.
2. **Complete the table: are women obligated in positive time-bound commandments and in negative commandments?** — Positive time-bound: exempt. Negative commandments: obligated, like men.
3. **The Talmud asks: “וכללא הוא הרי מצה שמחה הקהל” (is it a rule? what about matzah, rejoicing and hakhel?). What is the Talmud's difficulty?** — These are time-bound commandments, yet women are obligated in them, so the rule has exceptions.
4. **Complete the table with the Passover commandment that women are obligated in.** — Eating matzah on Passover (taught in Kiddushin 34a).
5. **Abudarham writes that the Creator exempted women “לפיכך פטרה הבורא ממצותיו כדי להיות לה שלום עם בעלה” (so that she would have peace with her husband). Explain his reason.** — A wife's time was bound to her husband's needs; if obligated, she could be torn between his request and God's command, so she was exempted to keep peace at home.
6. **Complete the table with Rabbi Hirsch's explanation and say why he insists the exemption is not a sign of lesser worth.** — Women need fewer reminders. He points out that the exceptions are nearly as many as the rule, so the exemption cannot mean lesser worth.
7. **Write a paragraph: what is the difference between exempt and forbidden? Use the story of Michal and the Rema.** — A good answer explains that exempt means not obligated, so a woman may still keep the commandment; Michal wore tefillin and the sages did not protest, and the Rema records the custom that women bless on these commandments.

## Common questions

### What does mitzvat aseh shehazman grama mean?

A positive commandment that time causes: one that must be done at a set time, such as sukkah, lulav, shofar or tefillin. By Mishnah Kiddushin 1:7 women are exempt from most of them.

### Are women obligated in any time-bound commandments?

Yes. Women are obligated in Shabbat kiddush, matzah on Passover, rejoicing on festivals and hakhel, and, by rabbinic law, in the Megillah, Chanukah lights and the four cups.

### Can women wear tefillin?

The Talmud reports that Michal, daughter of Kushi, wore tefillin and the sages did not protest (Eruvin 96a). The Rema later ruled that women should not (Orach Chayim 38:3), and practice differs among communities today.

### Are women obligated to pray?

Yes. Mishnah Berakhot 3:3 says women are exempt from the Shema and tefillin but obligated in prayer, in mezuzah and in grace after meals.

### Do women say a blessing on shofar or lulav?

Rabbi Yosef Karo rules that women may blow the shofar but do not bless; the Rema records the custom that women do bless on time-bound commandments (Orach Chayim 589:6). Communities follow different customs.
