# What is the Kuleshov effect?

> Written with AI · [Communications: the visual language of film, television and photography](https://lessoons.com/en/visual-language-of-film-and-television) · Grade 10 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/visual-language-of-film-and-television/what-is-the-kuleshov-effect

The Kuleshov effect is the idea that viewers read the meaning of a shot from the shot next to it. The Soviet filmmaker Lev Kuleshov, around 1920, cut the same neutral face of an actor with a bowl of soup, a girl in a coffin and a woman on a sofa, and viewers were said to see hunger, grief and desire. Later experiments give mixed but partly supporting results.

## The topic explained

### One face, three meanings

The Kuleshov effect is named after Lev Kuleshov, a young Soviet filmmaker and teacher who experimented with editing in Moscow in the late 1910s and early 1920s. In the version usually told, he took a close-up of the actor Ivan Mozzhukhin with a neutral expression and cut it with three different shots: a bowl of soup, a girl in a coffin and a woman lying on a sofa. Viewers praised the actor's subtle acting, seeing hunger in the first sequence, grief in the second and desire in the third. But the face was the same shot each time.

Kuleshov's conclusion was that a shot has no fixed meaning by itself; it gets its meaning from its place among other shots. The accounts of the experiment, written down later, differ in the details, which is a reason to treat the story with care.

### Montage: meaning made by the join

The experiment became a founding example for montage, the idea that editing does more than join shots in order: it creates meaning that no single shot holds. A face plus soup gives hunger, though hunger is in neither picture. The viewer builds the link, by assuming that the face is reacting to what the next shot shows. Soviet filmmakers of the 1920s made montage the center of their art, cutting images against each other to produce ideas and emotions.

The same mechanism explains the eyeline match in ordinary continuity editing: we see a character look, then an object, and we assume she is looking at it. The common misreading is that the Kuleshov effect means acting does not matter. It means that context changes how we read a face, especially a face that shows little; a strong expression resists the context much more.

### Does it really work?

Scientists have tried to repeat the experiment. In 1992 Stephen Prince and Wayne Hensley recreated it as it is usually described and found no effect: most viewers saw no emotion in the face. In 2006 a brain-imaging study by Dean Mobbs and colleagues, with a revised design, found that faces were rated differently depending on the scene before them. In 2016 Daniel Barratt and colleagues showed 24 sequences to 36 viewers and concluded that some sort of Kuleshov effect exists. The fair summary is that context does shape how people read neutral faces, but the effect is weaker and less automatic than the legend suggests.

Why do the studies disagree? They used different faces, different second shots and different questions. Critics of the 1992 study noted that each viewer saw only one sequence, which gave it little statistical power, while later studies showed many sequences to each viewer. This is a useful lesson in itself: a famous story about the media is a hypothesis to test, not a fact to repeat.

### The effect outside the cinema

Editors of news and advertising use the same power, and viewers should know it. In a made-up report, a politician's calm face cut next to pictures of a disaster can look indifferent; the same face next to a hospital visit can look caring. An advertisement that cuts from a tired face to a drink and then to a smile implies that the drink changed the mood, without ever saying so. Because the claim is made by the cut and not in words, it is hard to check and easy to miss.

A strong exam answer describes the experiment, explains montage and the viewer's inference, gives the evidence for and against, and applies the idea to a sequence from the news or advertising.

## Practice: the Kuleshov effect

For 10th grade communications and film students. The news and advertising examples are made up. Answer from what is printed on the page, then check yourself against the answers.

1. **Fill in the missing cell in the table of the experiment.** — Grief: when the neutral face was followed by a girl in a coffin, viewers were said to read sorrow in it.
2. **In the experiment, which part of the film changed between the three sequences, and which stayed the same?** — The second shot changed (soup, a girl in a coffin, a woman on a sofa); the shot of the actor's face stayed exactly the same.
3. **What does the viewer do at the step marked with a question mark?** — The face is read as hunger: the viewer assumes the face is reacting to the soup and reads the emotion into it, though hunger is in neither shot.
4. **Define montage in one sentence.** — Montage is editing that creates a meaning by joining shots, a meaning that no single shot holds by itself.
5. **Fill in the missing result on the timeline.** — 1992: Prince and Hensley recreated the experiment as usually described and found no effect.
6. **A student writes: “The Kuleshov effect proves that actors' faces mean nothing.” Correct the sentence.** — The effect shows that context changes how viewers read a face, mostly a neutral one. Strong expressions resist the context, and the replications show the effect is weaker than the legend says.
7. **A made-up advertisement cuts from a tired face, to a can of an invented drink, to the same person laughing. What does the sequence claim, and why is the claim hard to check?** — It implies that the drink caused the change of mood. The claim is made by the editing, not in words, so it is never stated and cannot easily be tested or challenged.
8. **Plan two versions of a made-up news sequence about a mayor at a ceremony, using the Kuleshov effect so that the same shot of the mayor seems happy in one and bored in the other. Then explain the ethical problem.** — For example: the mayor's face followed by children receiving prizes (happy), or followed by an empty row of seats (bored). The ethical problem is that editing can create an impression that did not happen; a fair editor joins shots in ways that reflect what really took place.

## Common questions

### Who was Lev Kuleshov?

A Soviet filmmaker and film teacher, active from the late 1910s, who ran a workshop in Moscow and experimented with how editing creates meaning. His experiments made him one of the founders of Soviet montage theory.

### Has the Kuleshov experiment been replicated?

Partly. A 1992 recreation by Prince and Hensley found no effect, while studies by Mobbs and colleagues in 2006 and Barratt and colleagues in 2016, with different designs, found that context does change how neutral faces are read.

### What is the difference between montage and continuity editing?

Continuity editing hides the cuts and keeps space and time smooth. Montage makes the cut itself produce meaning, joining shots so that the viewer infers an idea or emotion. Both rely on the viewer linking one shot to the next.

### Why does the Kuleshov effect matter for news?

Because a news editor who places a shot of a person next to another image can change how the person seems, without any words. Knowing this helps viewers ask what was joined to what, and helps journalists edit fairly.

### Does the Kuleshov effect work with sound?

Similar effects are often described with music: the same images can feel joyful or sinister under different scores. This is a related idea about context rather than Kuleshov's own experiment, which joined images.
