# What is confirmation bias?

> Written with AI · [Psychology: thinking, decisions and intelligence](https://lessoons.com/en/thinking-and-intelligence) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/thinking-and-intelligence/what-is-confirmation-bias

Confirmation bias is the tendency to look for, notice and remember information that supports what we already believe, and to overlook information that could prove it wrong. Peter Wason showed it in his 2-4-6 task (1960): most people tested only examples that fitted their guess, so few found the real rule at once.

## The topic explained

### Looking for what agrees

Confirmation bias is the tendency to search for, interpret and remember information in a way that supports what we already believe, and to give less weight to information that could show it is wrong. It is not lying or stubbornness. It happens to careful people who sincerely want the truth, because evidence that agrees with us is easier to look for, easier to accept and easier to recall.

It works at every stage. In searching, we ask questions whose answer we expect to be yes. In interpreting, we read mixed evidence as support. In remembering, we recall the cases that fit. In one study by Snyder and Cantor (1979), people read about a woman who did both shy and outgoing things; those later asked whether she would suit a job as a librarian recalled more of her shy behavior, and those asked about a sales job recalled more of the outgoing behavior.

### Wason's 2-4-6 task

The classic experiment was run by Peter Wason at University College London and published in 1960. Each of 29 psychology students was tested alone. They were told that the numbers 2, 4, 6 fit a simple rule, and that their task was to discover it by writing down sets of three numbers. After each set the experimenter said whether it fitted. When they felt sure, they announced the rule.

The rule was simply three numbers in increasing order. Only 6 of the 29 announced it correctly the first time. 13 announced one wrong rule first, 9 announced two or more, and one gave up without a rule. The most common wrong rule was numbers rising by two. A student would guess it, test 8, 10, 12 and then 20, 22, 24, hear yes each time, and announce the guess with confidence. Wason concluded that people looked for confirming cases instead of trying to eliminate their own hypotheses.

### Why a yes can teach you nothing

The trap is logical. A guess like rising by two sits inside the true rule, so every test chosen to fit the guess also fits the rule, and every answer is yes. Only a test that the guess forbids, such as 1, 5, 9, can show that the guess is too narrow. A student's common mistake is to think that many confirming results prove a rule; they cannot, while a single clear counterexample can disprove it.

Klayman and Ha (1987) argued that testing cases that fit your idea, a positive test strategy, is not always a bias: it is often a sensible strategy, and it fails mainly when the true rule is broader than the guess, as in Wason's task. The same trap appears in everyday tests. A student who believes she studies better with music, and notices only the good evenings with music on, collects confirmations. A real test compares evenings with and without music, on similar material, with the measure chosen in advance, such as the score on a short quiz the next day.

### The selection task and everyday life

In 1966 Wason devised a second puzzle, the selection task: four cards, each with a number on one side and a color on the other, and a rule to test such as "if one side is even, the other side is blue". Fewer than 10 percent chose the right cards, the even number and the non-blue card, the only ones that could break the rule. When the same logic is about a social rule, such as who may drink alcohol, most people solve it. To work against confirmation bias, ask what result would prove you wrong, then go and look for it.

## Practice: confirmation bias

For 12th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Define confirmation bias in one sentence, and name the three stages where it can work.** — Confirmation bias is the tendency to look for, interpret and remember information that supports an existing belief. It works in searching for evidence, in interpreting it and in remembering it.
2. **Read the chart. How many of the 29 students announced at least one wrong rule before the right one?** — 13 + 9 = 22 students. Only 6 were right at once, and one gave up without a rule.
3. **A student guesses that the numbers go up by 2. Does each test fit Wason's real rule? Which tests could show the guess is wrong?** — 10, 12, 14: yes. 1, 2, 3: yes. 5, 3, 1: no. Only 1, 2, 3 can show the guess is wrong: the guess predicts no, the experimenter says yes. 10, 12, 14 always gets a yes, and 5, 3, 1 gets the no that both rules predict.
4. **Why did students who tested 8, 10, 12 and 20, 22, 24 still announce a wrong rule?** — Both tests fitted their guess and also the true rule, so both got a yes. Confirming results cannot tell a narrow guess from a broader true rule; only a test the guess forbids can.
5. **Which cards must you turn over to test the rule, and why?** — The 8 and the red card. An 8 with a color other than blue breaks the rule, and a red card with an even number on the back breaks it. The 3 and the blue card cannot break it: the rule says nothing about odd numbers, and blue may go with any number.
6. **Write one everyday example of confirmation bias that is not about politics, and say which stage it shows.** — A good answer is specific, for example: a student who believes a classmate dislikes her remembers the times he ignored her and forgets the times he helped (remembering); or someone sure a new phone is better reads only the positive reviews (searching).
7. **Klayman and Ha argued that a positive test strategy is not always a bias. Explain their point and when the strategy fails.** — Testing cases that fit your idea is often sensible and informative. It fails when the true rule is broader than the guess, as in the 2-4-6 task: every positive test gets a yes, so the guess is never challenged. A good answer adds that seeking a test that could disprove the guess solves the problem.

## Common questions

### Who discovered confirmation bias?

The English psychologist Peter Wason gave it its modern form with his 2-4-6 task (1960) and his selection task (1966). His 1960 paper did not use the term, but he interpreted the results as a preference for confirming evidence over disproof.

### What is an example of confirmation bias?

A student who is sure a teacher grades her unfairly notices every low mark and forgets the high ones. In research, Snyder and Cantor (1979) found people recalled different details about the same woman depending on which job they were judging her for.

### How can you reduce confirmation bias?

Ask what evidence would prove you wrong and look for it on purpose, consider the opposite of your view, ask someone who disagrees to check your reasoning, and decide in advance what result would change your mind.

### Is confirmation bias the same as a heuristic?

Not quite. A heuristic is a shortcut for judging, such as availability. Confirmation bias is a systematic error in how evidence is gathered and weighed; one explanation of it is a heuristic, the positive test strategy described by Klayman and Ha (1987).

### What is the Wason selection task?

A 1966 puzzle in which four cards must be checked against an if-then rule. Fewer than 10 percent chose the correct cards in Wason's study, but people do much better when the rule is about a familiar social situation, such as a legal drinking age.
