# Is living in the Land of Israel a mitzvah?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: The Land of Israel](https://lessoons.com/en/the-land-of-israel-in-jewish-thought) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/the-land-of-israel-in-jewish-thought/is-living-in-the-land-of-israel-a-mitzvah

Whether living in the Land of Israel is a mitzvah is a classic dispute. The Ramban counts settling the land as a positive commandment for every generation, even in exile. Maimonides leaves it out of his count of the 613, yet rules that a Jew should always live in the land and may not leave it without good reason.

## The topic explained

### The Ramban: a commandment for every generation

The question whether living in the Land of Israel is a mitzvah begins with a verse: “וְהוֹרַשְׁתֶּם אֶת־הָאָרֶץ וִישַׁבְתֶּם־בָּהּ כִּי לָכֶם נָתַתִּי אֶת־הָאָרֶץ לָרֶשֶׁת אֹתָהּ” (you shall take possession of the land and settle in it, for to you I have given the land to possess it, Numbers 33:53). Maimonides counted 613 commandments in his Sefer HaMitzvot; the Ramban, in his glosses, added those he thought were missing. The fourth is this: “שנצטוינו לרשת הארץ אשר נתן האל יתעלה לאבותינו לאברהם ליצחק וליעקב ולא נעזבה ביד זולתנו מן האומות או לשממה” (that we were commanded to take possession of the land that God gave our fathers, Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, and not to leave it in the hands of other nations or desolate).

He blocks a narrower reading: “ואל תשתבש ותאמר כי המצוה הזאת היא המצוה במלחמת ז' עממין” (do not err and say that this commandment is the commandment of the war against the seven nations). And he concludes: “א"כ היא מצות עשה לדורות מתחייב כל אחד ממנו ואפילו בזמן גלות” (so it is a positive commandment for all generations, binding on each one of us, even in the time of exile).

### Maimonides: not counted, yet required

Maimonides does not list such a commandment. Yet in his code he rules: “לעולם ידור אדם בארץ ישראל אפלו בעיר שרבה עכו"ם ואל ידור בחוצה לארץ ואפלו בעיר שרבה ישראל” (a person should always live in the Land of Israel, even in a city mostly of gentiles, and not live outside the land, even in a city mostly of Jews, Hilkhot Melakhim 5:12). He adds that leaving is forbidden except to study Torah, to marry, or to escape real hardship, and that “גדולי החכמים היו מנשקין על תחומי ארץ ישראל ומנשקין אבניה ומתגלגלין על עפרה” (the great sages would kiss the borders of the Land of Israel, kiss its stones and roll in its dust, 5:10).

His source is the Talmud: “שכל הדר בארץ ישראל דומה כמי שיש לו אלוה” (whoever lives in the Land of Israel is like one who has a God, Ketubot 110b). The common mistake is to say Maimonides did not value the land. He did; the question is only whether it is one of the 613.

### Why does Maimonides not count it?

The commentary Megillat Esther on Sefer HaMitzvot answers: “לפי שמצות ירושת הארץ וישיבתה לא נהגה רק בימי משה ויהושע ודוד וכל זמן שלא גלו מארצם” (because the commandment of possessing the land and settling it applied only in the days of Moses, Joshua and David, and as long as they were not exiled from their land). After the exile, it says, the commandment is suspended until the Messiah, because of the oaths in Ketubot 111a not to take the land by force.

Another reading holds that settling the land is part of the commandment to conquer it in Joshua's time, and so needs no separate count; this is exactly the reading the Ramban warns against. Each answer leaves something open: Megillat Esther must explain why Maimonides still requires living in the land, and the second must explain the Ramban's objection.

### Why the dispute still matters

With the return to Zion the question became practical. Religious Zionist rabbis built on the Ramban: settling the land is a commandment today. Others followed Megillat Esther and the oaths, and saw no obligation before the Messiah. A strong bagrut answer quotes the Ramban, presents Maimonides' ruling and one explanation of his silence, and keeps the halakhic question apart from the political one.

## Practice: settling the Land of Israel

For 11th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Numbers 33:53 says: “וְהוֹרַשְׁתֶּם אֶת־הָאָרֶץ וִישַׁבְתֶּם־בָּהּ כִּי לָכֶם נָתַתִּי אֶת־הָאָרֶץ לָרֶשֶׁת אֹתָהּ” (you shall take possession of the land and settle in it). Which two verbs does the Ramban build his commandment on?** — To take possession (lareshet) and to settle (lashevet): the land must be held by Israel and lived in.
2. **Write the conclusion of the Ramban's argument in the last box.** — It is binding in every generation, on each person, even in exile.
3. **The Ramban writes: “ואל תשתבש ותאמר כי המצוה הזאת היא המצוה במלחמת ז' עממין” (do not err and say that this commandment is the war against the seven nations). Why does this matter?** — Because the war against the seven nations belonged to one time; if settling were only that, it would not bind later generations. The Ramban insists it is a separate commandment for all time.
4. **Fill in the two empty boxes for the Ramban.** — In the count: yes, as positive commandment 4 in his additions. Binding: in every generation, even in exile.
5. **Maimonides rules: “לעולם ידור אדם בארץ ישראל אפלו בעיר שרבה עכו"ם ואל ידור בחוצה לארץ ואפלו בעיר שרבה ישראל” (a person should always live in the Land of Israel, even in a city mostly of gentiles). How does this fit the fact that he does not count the commandment?** — He requires living in the land as law and praises it greatly, but does not list it among the 613; the dispute is about counting, not about the land's importance.
6. **Write Megillat Esther's answer in the diagram.** — The commandment applied only before the exile, in the days of Moses, Joshua and David; after the exile it is suspended until the Messiah.
7. **Write a paragraph: is settling the Land of Israel a commandment today? Present the Ramban, Maimonides and one explanation of the dispute.** — A good answer quotes the Ramban's commandment for every generation, presents Maimonides' ruling in Hilkhot Melakhim 5 and his silence in the count, gives Megillat Esther's explanation or the conquest reading, and weighs them.

## Common questions

### What is mitzvat yishuv haaretz?

The commandment of settling the Land of Israel: to take possession of it and live in it, from Numbers 33:53. The Ramban counts it as a positive commandment for every generation.

### Why doesn't Maimonides count settling the land?

Megillat Esther explains that he saw it as binding only before the exile, in the days of Moses, Joshua and David. Another reading includes it in the war of conquest, a reading the Ramban rejects.

### Did Maimonides think living in Israel was important?

Yes. In Hilkhot Melakhim 5:9 to 12 he forbids leaving the land without good reason and rules that a person should always live there, even in a city mostly of gentiles.

### What does the Talmud say about living in Israel?

Ketubot 110b teaches that one should live in the Land of Israel even in a city mostly of gentiles, and that whoever lives there is like one who has a God.

### Is moving to Israel a mitzvah today?

According to the Ramban, yes, in every generation. According to Megillat Esther's reading of Maimonides, not before the Messiah. Many rabbis today follow the Ramban, and others disagree.
