# What is Maimonides' golden mean?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: The Human Being](https://lessoons.com/en/the-human-being-in-jewish-thought) · Grade 10 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/the-human-being-in-jewish-thought/what-is-maimonides-golden-mean

Maimonides' golden mean is his teaching, in Hilkhot De'ot, that the right way for each trait is the middle between two extremes: angry only at a great wrong, desiring only what the body needs. He calls it “הדרך הישרה” (the straight path) and the way of God. Two traits are exceptions: pride and anger, which a person should flee to the far end.

## The topic explained

### The straight path between two extremes

Maimonides opens Hilkhot De'ot (the Laws of Character Traits) by describing people: one is always angry, another never; one desires everything, another denies the body what it needs. Then he rules: “שתי קצוות הרחוקות זו מזו שבכל דעה ודעה אינן דרך טובה” (the two extremes of each trait are not a good way, 1:3), and “הדרך הישרה היא מדה בינונית שבכל דעה ודעה” (the straight path is the middle measure of each trait, 1:4). This is Maimonides' golden mean, the derech ha-emtza.

The middle is defined by examples: a person should “לא יכעס אלא על דבר גדול שראוי לכעס עליו” (not be angry except at a great matter that deserves anger), and “וכן לא יתאוה אלא לדברים שהגוף צריך להן” (likewise not desire anything except what the body needs). The common mistake is to read the middle as being lukewarm about everything. It is a measured response: angry when anger is right, and in the right amount.

### Why the middle is God's way

Maimonides ties the middle to the commandment to walk in God's ways: “מה הוא נקרא חנון אף אתה היה חנון” (as He is called gracious, so you be gracious, 1:6). God is called slow to anger and abundant in kindness, not without anger and not cruel; the middle path is therefore called the way of the Lord. The idea echoes Aristotle's ethics of the mean, which Maimonides knew well, but he grounds it in the Torah.

There is also a higher rung. One who “ומי שהוא מדקדק על עצמו ביותר ויתרחק מדעה בינונית מעט לצד זה או לצד זה נקרא חסיד” (is very strict with himself and moves a little from the middle to one side or the other is called a chasid, 1:5): the pious go beyond the line of the law, but the commandment for everyone is the middle.

### How a trait is corrected

A bad trait is, for Maimonides, an illness of the soul, and the sick should go “ילכו אצל החכמים שהן רופאי הנפשות” (to the sages, who are physicians of souls, 2:1). The cure is surprising: “אם היה רחוק לקצה האחד ירחיק עצמו לקצה השני וינהג בו זמן רב” (if he was far toward one extreme, let him take himself to the other extreme and act so a long time, 2:2), and only then return to the middle.

Example: a person quick to anger trains himself for a long time not to react even when insulted, until the anger is uprooted, then settles in the middle. Habit does the work: “יעשה וישנה וישלש במעשים שעושה על פי הדעות האמצעיות” (let him do, repeat and do a third time the deeds that follow the middle traits, 1:7) until they are easy.

### Two exceptions: pride and anger

Two traits do not follow the rule: “ויש דעות שאסור לו לאדם לנהג בהן בבינונית אלא יתרחק מן הקצה האחד עד הקצה האחר” (there are traits in which a person may not keep to the middle, but must go from one extreme to the other, 2:3). For pride, humble is not enough; one must be very lowly, as Moses was very humble. And “וכן הכעס מדה רעה היא עד למאד” (anger, too, is a very bad trait), so a person should train himself not to be angry even when anger is deserved, at most showing anger to correct others without feeling it.

Why these two? A student can argue: pride and anger take over the whole person, and a little of them grows. A strong answer explains the rule, an example, the cure and the exceptions, each with its source.

## Practice: Maimonides' golden mean

For 10th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Maimonides writes: “הדרך הישרה היא מדה בינונית שבכל דעה ודעה” (the straight path is the middle measure of each trait, 1:4). In your own words, what is the straight path?** — For every trait there are two extremes; the straight path is the point equally far from both, for example anger only when it is truly deserved.
2. **Fill in the two empty boxes of the middle path in the table.** — Anger: angry only at great wrongs that deserve it. Desire: only what the body needs.
3. **A student says: the golden mean means never feeling strongly about anything. What is wrong with this?** — The middle is a measured response, not indifference: Maimonides wants anger at a great wrong and desire for what the body needs. Feeling nothing at all is itself an extreme.
4. **“מה הוא נקרא חנון אף אתה היה חנון” (as He is called gracious, so you be gracious, 1:6). How does this line connect the middle path to God?** — The Torah commands walking in God's ways, and God is described with balanced traits, slow to anger and abundant in kindness. Imitating Him means keeping to the middle, which is why it is called the way of the Lord.
5. **Label the long low stretch of the sketch of the cure, and explain why the cure goes there.** — Feels no anger: the person goes to the opposite extreme for a long time until the old trait is uprooted, then returns to the middle path (2:2).
6. **“ומי שהוא מדקדק על עצמו ביותר ויתרחק מדעה בינונית מעט לצד זה או לצד זה נקרא חסיד” (one who is very strict with himself and moves a little from the middle is called a chasid, 1:5). How does the chasid differ from the wise person?** — The wise person keeps to the middle, which the commandment requires of everyone. The chasid goes a little beyond it, beyond the line of the law, by his own choice.
7. **Mark the target on the line of pride, and explain why pride is an exception.** — The far end, very lowly: for pride being merely humble is not enough. Moses is called very humble, and the sages say whoever is proud has denied a principle.
8. **Write a paragraph: choose a trait you see in daily life, place it between its extremes, describe the middle path, and say how Maimonides would correct an extreme, with a quotation.** — A good answer names a trait (for example spending money), gives its two extremes and the middle, quotes 1:4 or 2:2, and describes the cure: going to the other extreme for a while and then returning to the middle.

## Common questions

### Where does Maimonides teach the golden mean?

In the first two chapters of Hilkhot De'ot, the laws of character traits in Sefer HaMadda, the first book of the Mishneh Torah. He also discusses it in the Eight Chapters, his introduction to tractate Avot.

### Did Maimonides take the golden mean from Aristotle?

The idea of virtue as a mean between extremes is central in Aristotle's ethics, which Maimonides knew well. He gives it a Jewish ground: the commandment to walk in God's ways and imitate His traits.

### Why are pride and anger exceptions?

In Hilkhot De'ot 2:3 Maimonides says that for pride and anger the middle is not enough: a person must go to the far end, very lowly and not angry even when anger is deserved, since these traits are especially destructive.

### How do you correct a bad trait according to Maimonides?

By going for a long time to the opposite extreme, then returning to the middle, and by repeating good deeds until they become easy and fixed in the soul (Hilkhot De'ot 1:7 and 2:2).

### What is the difference between a wise person and a chasid?

The wise person keeps the middle path, which is required of everyone. The chasid leans a little beyond it toward one side, going beyond the letter of the law (Hilkhot De'ot 1:5).
