# What is a public good?

> Written with AI · [Taxes, subsidies and market failure](https://lessoons.com/en/taxes-and-market-failure) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/taxes-and-market-failure/what-is-a-public-good

A public good is a good that nobody can be kept from using, non-excludable, and that one person's use does not reduce for others, non-rival: national defense, street lighting, a lighthouse's beam. Because people can enjoy it without paying, each is tempted to be a free rider, so private sellers cannot cover its cost and it is usually paid for by taxes.

## The topic explained

### Two properties of a public good

Economists sort goods by two questions. Can a seller keep people who do not pay from using it? If not, the good is non-excludable. Does one person's use leave less for others? If not, it is non-rival. A public good has both properties: a lighthouse's beam guides every ship that passes, and a thousand ships see it as well as one.

The table shows the four kinds. A sandwich is a private good, rival and excludable. A streaming service or a half-empty cinema is a club good: you can be kept out, but your use does not crowd others. Fish in the sea are a common resource: anyone can take them, but each fish taken is gone for others. Paul Samuelson gave the modern definition of public goods in 1954.

### The free rider problem

A street of ten households wants lighting that costs ₪6,000 a year, and each household values it at ₪1,000. In total the street values it at ₪10,000, more than the cost: it is worth providing. If each paid an equal share of ₪600, each would gain 1,000 - 600 = 400.

But the light shines on everyone. A household that refuses to pay still gets ₪1,000 of value for nothing. Each household reasons the same way, waits for the others, and too little is collected: the good worth ₪10,000 is not provided. This is the free rider problem, and it is why a private firm cannot sell street lighting door to door.

### Why taxes pay for it

The usual answer is that the state provides the good and pays for it with taxes, which nobody can choose not to pay. Defense, police, flood barriers and basic research are financed this way. The hard question then becomes how much to provide, since people have reasons to understate how much they value a good they will get anyway.

The line is not always fixed. Ronald Coase showed in 1974 that many British lighthouses were long paid for by fees charged to ships in port, because the ships could be identified there. And a common resource has the opposite problem, overuse: when anyone can fish, each boat takes as much as it can, a pattern Garrett Hardin called “the tragedy of the commons” (1968).

### Common mistakes

Calling everything the state provides a public good: a school place or a hospital bed is rival and excludable, a private good the state chooses to fund. Treating rivalry as fixed: an empty road is non-rival, a jammed one is rival. And thinking free riders are dishonest: they respond to an incentive the good itself creates.

## Practice: public goods

For 11th grade economics students. Use the tables and figures on the sheet, show your reasoning, then check against the answers.

1. **Name the two properties of a public good and explain each in one sentence.** — Non-excludable: people who do not pay cannot be kept from using it. Non-rival: one person's use does not reduce what is left for others.
2. **Write the type of each good in the table: private, club, common resource or public.** — Pizza: private. National defense: public. Fish in the sea: common resource. A half-empty cinema: club good. Street lighting: public.
3. **A street of 20 households wants lighting that costs ₪4,000; each values it at ₪300. Fill in the table. Should the lighting be provided?** — Total value: 20 · 300 = 6,000. Equal share: 4,00020 = 200. Paying: 300 - 200 = 100. Free riding: 300. Yes, it is worth providing, since 6,000 is more than 4,000.
4. **Explain why a private firm would find it hard to sell national defense.** — It cannot exclude people who do not pay: if the country is defended, everyone in it is. So each person would wait for others to pay, and the firm could not cover its costs.
5. **Fishing boats in an open sea catch so many fish that the stock collapses. Why does this happen, and how does it differ from a public good?** — Fish are rival but non-excludable: each boat gains by taking more, and the cost of a smaller stock is shared by all. A public good is non-rival, so its problem is too little provision, not overuse. Quotas or licenses can limit the catch.
6. **Fill in the missing cell of the table, and give an example.** — Public goods: non-rival and non-excludable, such as a lighthouse's beam, national defense or street lighting.
7. **Write a short paragraph: should a city fund a large park through taxes, or charge an entry fee? Use the ideas on the page.** — A good answer says that a park is largely non-rival until crowded, and fencing it to charge a fee costs money and keeps out people who would gain at no extra cost, which supports tax funding. A fee could pay for upkeep and limit crowding, and puts the cost on users. It weighs both and links them to rivalry and excludability.

## Common questions

### What is the free rider problem?

When a good cannot be withheld from people who do not pay, each person is tempted to let others pay and enjoy it free. If many do so, too little is collected and a good worth more than its cost is not provided.

### Is education a public good?

Not in the economic sense: a school place is rival and excludable. Education does have positive externalities, benefits to society beyond the student, which is one reason states fund it.

### What is the difference between a public good and a common resource?

Both are non-excludable. A public good is non-rival, so the risk is that too little is provided. A common resource is rival, so the risk is that it is overused, as with overfishing.

### Can public goods be provided privately?

Sometimes, when a way is found to charge users, as with lighthouse fees collected in ports, or when a good is bundled with something people pay for. In general, though, the free rider problem leaves the market short.

### How are public goods asked on the bagrut?

Students classify goods by rivalry and excludability, explain the free rider problem with numbers, and explain why public goods are usually paid for by taxes.
