# What is a production quota in economics?

> Written with AI · [Taxes, subsidies and market failure](https://lessoons.com/en/taxes-and-market-failure) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/taxes-and-market-failure/what-is-a-production-quota-in-economics

A production quota is a legal limit on how much of a good may be produced or sold. If the limit is below the free-market quantity, buyers compete for the smaller supply and the price rises to where they want only that much. The holders of the quota gain the gap between that price and their cost, the quota rent, while buyers lose more.

## The topic explained

### A limit on the quantity

A production quota is a limit set by law on how much of a good may be produced or sold. Each producer holds a right to a share of the total, and selling beyond it is not allowed. Quotas are used for milk and eggs in several countries, for fish in the sea, and in a different form for taxi licenses. In Israel, according to a 2023 State Comptroller report, the state supervises raw milk production according to quotas assigned to producers, under the Dairy Sector Planning Law of 2011.

A quota matters only when it is binding: below the quantity the free market would trade. A limit above that quantity changes nothing, because nobody wanted to sell more anyway.

### A worked example: the price under a quota

Take a milk market (numbers made up for this page) with demand Q_(d) = 200 - 20P and supply Q_(s) = 20P - 40, in millions of liters. Without a quota they meet at 200 - 20P = 20P - 40, so P = 6 shekels and Q = 80 million liters.

Now the law allows only 60 million liters. The price is set by demand, not supply: buyers bid up the scarce milk until they want exactly 60, 60 = 200 - 20P, so P = 7. On the supply curve the 60th liter costs only (60 + 40)/20 = 5 shekels to produce. The gap between the two, ₪2 on every liter, is the quota rent: 2 · 60 = 120 million shekels a year for the quota holders.

### Who gains and who loses

Consumers pay ₪1 more on the 60 million liters they still buy and lose the surplus on the 20 million they no longer buy: their surplus falls from 1/2 · 4 · 80 = 160 to 1/2 · 3 · 60 = 90, a loss of 70 million shekels. Producers, who now sell less at a higher price, gain 50. The difference, 20, is the deadweight loss: liters that buyers valued above their cost and that are no longer produced.

The right to produce becomes an asset. If a quota brings ₪2 a liter above cost each year, a newcomer will pay for it close to what that stream is worth, so the gain goes to whoever held the quota when it was handed out, not to the farmer who buys one later.

A quota also fixes who produces. Under a tax, a farm with lower costs can grow by selling more; under a quota it can grow only by buying rights from others, and if rights may not be traded, the cheapest producers cannot expand at all. That is one reason economists usually prefer a tax or tradable rights to fixed shares.

### A quota or a tax, and common mistakes

A tax of ₪2 a liter would give the same result: buyers pay ₪7, sellers keep ₪5, 60 million liters are sold and 20 is lost. The difference is who collects the 120 million: under a tax, the state; under a quota, the holders of the rights.

Three mistakes are common. Reading the price off the supply curve at the quota, ₪5, instead of off demand, ₪7. Counting the quota rent as part of the deadweight loss: the rent is a transfer from buyers to holders, not a loss. And thinking a quota lowers prices because it brings order: a binding quota always raises the price.

## Practice: production quotas

For 11th grade economics students. Use the equations, the graph and the tables on the sheet, show each calculation, then check against the answers.

1. **Define a production quota, and explain when a quota is binding.** — A legal limit on how much of a good may be produced or sold. It is binding when it is below the quantity the free market would trade, here 80 million liters.
2. **Demand is Q_(d) = 200 - 20P and supply Q_(s) = 20P - 40. Find the free-market price and quantity.** — 200 - 20P = 20P - 40, so 40P = 240, P = 6 shekels and Q = 200 - 120 = 80 million liters.
3. **Use the graph. The quota is cut to 40 million liters. What price do buyers pay, and what does the 40th liter cost to produce?** — Price: 40 = 200 - 20P, so P = 8 shekels. Cost of the 40th liter: (40 + 40)/20 = 4 shekels.
4. **Fill in the two missing cells of the table for the quota of 40.** — Rent: (8 - 4) · 40 = 160 million shekels. Deadweight loss: 1/2 · 4 · (80 - 40) = 80 million shekels.
5. **Under the quota of 40, by how much does consumer surplus fall from its free-market level of 160?** — New surplus: 1/2 · (10 - 8) · 40 = 40. It falls by 160 - 40 = 120 million shekels.
6. **What tax per liter would bring the market to the same 40 million liters? Who would receive the 160 million then?** — A tax of ₪4: buyers pay ₪8 and sellers keep ₪4, and both sides then choose 40. The 160 million would go to the state instead of the quota holders.
7. **Fill in the last box of the flow, and explain it in one sentence.** — The quota holders gain. The price rises above their cost of production, so each liter they may sell brings a rent of the gap between the two.
8. **Write a short paragraph: a farmer bought a quota ten years after quotas were handed out. Explain why she may earn no more than a farmer in a free market.** — A good answer says that the yearly rent made the quota an asset, so its price rose to about the value of the rent it brings. The farmer paid that price up front, so the rent only repays what she paid; the gain went to the first holders, who received the quota free.

## Common questions

### What is quota rent?

The gap between the price buyers pay under a quota and the cost of producing the last allowed unit, times the quantity. It goes to the holders of the quota, and it is a transfer from buyers, not a loss to the economy.

### Is a quota the same as a price floor?

No. A price floor fixes the price and lets the quantity follow; a quota fixes the quantity and lets the price follow. Both can keep the price above the free-market level, and both create a deadweight loss.

### Why do governments use production quotas?

Usually to give producers a stable, higher income, as in farming, or to protect a resource that would otherwise be overused, as with fishing quotas. The aim is political or environmental; the price effect is the same.

### Does a quota raise the price in every case?

Only when it binds, that is, when it is below the quantity the market would trade freely. A quota above that quantity changes neither the price nor the quantity.

### How are quotas asked on the bagrut?

Students find the price under a quota from the demand equation, compute the rent of the holders, the change in consumer surplus and the deadweight loss, and compare the quota with a tax that cuts the same quantity.
