# What is a negative externality?

> Written with AI · [Taxes, subsidies and market failure](https://lessoons.com/en/taxes-and-market-failure) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/taxes-and-market-failure/what-is-a-negative-externality

A negative externality is a cost that a producer or a consumer imposes on other people who are not part of the deal, such as smoke from a factory or noise from an airport. Because the cost is not in the price, the market produces more than is good for society, and a corrective tax, regulation or tradable permits can bring it back.

## The topic explained

### Costs that fall outside the deal

Most trades affect only the buyer and the seller. An externality is an effect on someone else. A negative externality is a cost imposed on third parties: smoke from a cement plant that neighbors breathe, the noise of a late party, traffic that slows everyone. A positive externality is a benefit: a vaccinated person also protects others, and a well-kept garden pleases the whole street.

The table sorts them by whether they come from producing or from consuming. In Hebrew textbooks the term is “השפעה חיצונית”, also called “תוצאה חיצונית”.

### Why the market overproduces

A cement plant counts its private cost: fuel, wages, machines. Society bears the social cost: the private cost plus the harm to others, here ₪20 per ton. With demand P = 100 - Q and private cost P = 20 + Q, the market settles where 100 - Q = 20 + Q: 40 tons at ₪60.

The efficient quantity counts the whole cost: 100 - Q = 40 + Q gives 30 tons at ₪70. The last 10 tons cost society more than buyers value them; the triangle between the social cost and demand, 1/2 · 20 · 10 = 100, is the deadweight loss. For a positive externality the logic reverses, and the market produces too little.

### Three answers to pollution

Arthur Pigou proposed in 1920 to tax the harm. A corrective tax of ₪20 a ton, equal to the external cost, raises the plant's cost to the social cost, and the market moves to 30 tons by itself. Regulation sets a legal limit on emissions. Tradable permits fix a cap on total pollution and let firms buy and sell permits, so the cuts are made where they are cheapest; the European Union's emissions trading system has worked this way since 2005.

Ronald Coase argued in 1960 that when property rights are clear and few people are involved, the parties can bargain to the efficient outcome without the state. Each tool has its weakness, as the table shows.

### Common mistakes

Calling every cost an externality: the price a buyer pays is not one; only costs borne by people outside the deal are. Thinking the efficient amount of pollution is zero: it is where the benefit of the last unit equals its full cost, which may be above zero. And forgetting that the external cost must be estimated, which is the hardest part in practice.

## Practice: externalities

For 11th grade economics students. Use the tables and graph on the sheet, show each calculation, then check against the answers.

1. **Define a negative externality and a positive externality, with an example of each.** — A negative externality is a cost imposed on people outside a trade (factory smoke); a positive externality is a benefit to them (a vaccination that also protects others).
2. **Write for each case in the table whether the externality is negative or positive.** — Barking dog: negative. Beehives beside an orchard: positive, the bees pollinate the trees. Noisy airport: negative. A student who studies: positive, an educated person benefits others too.
3. **In the market in the figure, demand is P = 90 - Q, private cost P = 10 + Q and social cost P = 20 + Q. Find the market point and the efficient point, the two dots on the demand line.** — Market: 90 - Q = 10 + Q, so Q = 40 and P = 50. Efficient: 90 - Q = 20 + Q, so Q = 35 and P = 55.
4. **In the same market, compute the deadweight loss, and the corrective tax that would bring the market to the efficient quantity.** — Deadweight loss: 1/2 · 10 · (40 - 35) = 25. The tax equals the external cost, ₪10 a unit.
5. **Flu vaccines protect the people around the person vaccinated. Does the market produce too much or too little vaccination? What policy would help?** — Too little: buyers count only their own benefit, not the protection of others. A subsidy, or free vaccination paid by the state, raises the quantity toward the efficient level.
6. **Fill in the table: one strength and one weakness of a corrective tax and of regulation.** — Corrective tax: lets each firm choose how much to cut and raises revenue; but the harm per unit is hard to measure. Regulation: simple and certain; but the same limit for all firms makes cuts costlier than needed.
7. **Write a short paragraph: a factory upstream pollutes a river used by one fish farm. How might Coase's idea solve it without the state, and why would it fail for city air pollution?** — A good answer says that if the property rights are clear, the factory and the farm can bargain: the farm can pay the factory to cut, or the factory can pay the farm, and they reach the efficient level. For city air, millions of people are affected, bargaining is impossible and each would free ride, so a tax or regulation is needed.

## Common questions

### What is the difference between private cost and social cost?

Private cost is what the producer pays: inputs, wages, machines. Social cost is the private cost plus the cost to everyone else, such as harm from pollution. With a negative externality, social cost is higher.

### What is a Pigouvian tax?

A corrective tax equal to the external cost per unit, named after Arthur Pigou. It makes the producer pay the full cost, so the market moves to the efficient quantity by itself.

### How do tradable pollution permits work?

The state caps total emissions and issues permits for that amount. Firms that can cut cheaply sell permits to those for whom cutting is costly, so the cap is met at the lowest total cost.

### Is a positive externality a market failure too?

Yes. Because buyers do not count the benefit to others, the market produces less than the efficient amount, as with education or vaccination. A subsidy can correct it.

### How are externalities asked on the bagrut?

Students classify externalities, draw private and social cost on a graph, find the market and the efficient quantities and the deadweight loss, and compare taxes, regulation and permits.
