# What is a spurious correlation?

> Written with AI · [Sociology: research methods](https://lessoons.com/en/sociological-research-methods) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/sociological-research-methods/what-is-a-spurious-correlation

A spurious correlation is a link between two variables that is not cause and effect: both change together because a third variable drives them. Towns with more libraries record more thefts, for example, only because bigger towns have more of both. Sociologists test for a spurious correlation by controlling for the third variable.

## The topic explained

### What a correlation is

Two variables are correlated when they change together across many cases. In a positive correlation both rise together: across Israeli workers, more years of schooling tend to go with higher pay. In a negative correlation one rises as the other falls. When there is no pattern, there is no correlation. Researchers sum up the strength of a straight-line link with the correlation coefficient r, which runs from −1, a perfect negative link, through 0, none, to +1, a perfect positive link.

A correlation is the starting point of much sociological research: it tells a researcher where to look. The misreading to avoid: a correlation describes a pattern across many cases, not a rule for each case. Plenty of people with long schooling earn little, and the correlation is still real. And a correlation, however strong, does not yet say which variable, if either, is the cause.

### A correlation that is not a cause

Here is a made-up example. A researcher collects figures from six towns, A to F, and finds that the more libraries a town has, the more thefts it records each year. Town A has 2 libraries and 220 thefts; town F has 12 libraries and 1,140 thefts. The correlation is very strong, r = 0.96. Do libraries cause theft?

No. The link is a spurious correlation: both variables depend on a third variable, the size of the town. A town of 120,000 has more libraries, more shops, more cars and more thefts than a town of 20,000, simply because it has more of everything. The two variables move together, but neither moves the other. Notice that the figures are accurate: the towns really do have those libraries and those thefts. What is wrong is the conclusion drawn from them. A spurious correlation is not a mistake in counting but a mistake in explaining.

### Controlling for the third variable

To test a suspicion like this, sociologists control for the third variable: they hold it constant or take it out of the figures. Here, dividing by population turns counts into rates. Town A has 220 thefts for 20,000 residents, 220 ÷ 20 = 11 thefts per 1,000 residents. Town F has 1,140 ÷ 120 = 9.5 per 1,000. The biggest town is not the most theft-prone at all.

Computed for all six towns, the correlation between libraries per resident and thefts per resident falls to r = 0.03, close to nothing. The strong link was an effect of size. The same logic explains the textbook case of fire damage: fires with more firefighters do more damage, because bigger fires bring both. Controlling does not always make a link vanish. Sometimes a correlation survives the control, which makes a causal story more believable, and sometimes it weakens without disappearing, which means the third variable explains only part of it.

### Three conditions for saying cause

Research methods textbooks set three conditions before a study may claim that one variable causes another. First, the two vary together. Second, the cause comes first in time. Third, the link is not spurious: no third variable explains it. Experiments meet the third condition by assigning people at random, but sociologists usually cannot assign people to a family, a town or a class, so they compare groups and control for the variables they can measure.

Take schooling and pay again. Part of that link may run through a third variable, family background, which can raise both a person's schooling and their pay, so researchers compare people from similar backgrounds before they speak of the effect of education. The most common mistake in a bagrut answer is to read a cause straight off a correlation. A better answer names a possible third variable and says what data would test it.

## Practice: spurious correlation

For 11th grade students of sociology. All the figures on this sheet are made up for practice. Answer from what is printed, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Positive, negative or no correlation? (a) the older a car, the lower its price; (b) the more hours students study, the higher their grades; (c) shoe size and the month of birth.** — (a) negative: as age rises, price falls; (b) positive: both rise together; (c) no correlation: there is no reason for any pattern.
2. **Fires with more firefighters at the scene cause more damage. Write the third variable in the empty box.** — The size of the fire. A big fire brings more firefighters and does more damage; the firefighters do not cause the damage.
3. **Calculate the thefts per 1,000 residents for towns A and F.** — Town A: 220 ÷ 20 = 11 thefts per 1,000. Town F: 1,140 ÷ 120 = 9.5 per 1,000. The bigger town has the lower rate.
4. **The graph shows the six towns again, this time as rates. What does it show about the link between libraries and thefts?** — The points form no clear pattern: towns with more libraries per resident do not have more thefts per resident (r = 0.03). Once population is controlled, the correlation almost disappears, so the original link was spurious.
5. **A survey finds that students who eat breakfast get higher grades. Which of the three conditions for a causal claim is most in doubt, and why?** — The third, no third variable. Families with a steady morning routine may also help with homework and sleep, and that could raise grades. (Time order is also unclear in a single survey.) A good answer names a plausible third variable.
6. **Write the missing condition.** — The cause comes first: the supposed cause must happen before the effect.
7. **Design a check: a researcher finds that neighborhoods with more police officers record more crime. Name a possible third variable and say what data you would collect to test it.** — A good answer names a variable such as the size of the neighborhood's population or the number of visitors, and proposes collecting it and comparing rates (crimes and officers per 1,000 residents), or comparing neighborhoods of similar size. It may add that more officers can also mean more crimes are recorded, not more committed.

## Common questions

### What is the difference between correlation and causation?

A correlation means two variables change together. Causation means a change in one produces a change in the other. A correlation is needed for causation but is not enough: the cause must also come first, and no third variable may explain the link.

### What is a third variable?

A third variable is a factor that affects both variables in a correlation and so makes them move together. In the made-up towns, population size drives both the number of libraries and the number of thefts.

### What does it mean to control for a variable?

To control for a variable is to remove its effect, by holding it constant, comparing like with like, or turning counts into rates. If the correlation disappears once the variable is controlled, the original link was spurious.

### Can a correlation be negative?

Yes. In a negative correlation one variable rises as the other falls, as with the age of a car and its price. The correlation coefficient is then below 0, down to −1 for a perfect negative link.

### Why can sociologists rarely run experiments?

Sociologists study families, towns, classes and religions, and they cannot assign people to them at random. They compare groups that already exist and control statistically for the differences they can measure, which leaves room for variables they did not measure.
