# What is the functionalist theory of stratification?

> Written with AI · [Sociology: society, groups and inequality](https://lessoons.com/en/society-groups-and-inequality) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-11 · https://lessoons.com/en/society-groups-and-inequality/what-is-the-functionalist-theory-of-stratification

The functionalist theory of stratification, set out by Kingsley Davis and Wilbert Moore in 1945, says that inequality is necessary. Positions differ in how important they are and how hard they are to fill, so every society offers higher rewards to draw its most able people into the most important positions. Melvin Tumin answered in 1953 that the theory ignores power and inherited advantage.

## The topic explained

### The functionalist theory of stratification in brief

Functionalism sees society as a system of parts that each meet a need. In 1945 the American sociologists Kingsley Davis and Wilbert Moore applied this to inequality in an article called Some Principles of Stratification. Every society, they argued, must fill its positions and get people to do them well. Positions differ in two ways: their functional importance to society, and the scarcity of people able to fill them, because of rare talent or long training. So societies attach greater rewards, in income, prestige and comfort, to positions that are both important and hard to fill. Stratification is, in their words, an “unconsciously evolved device”: nobody plans it, but it ensures that the most important positions go to the most qualified people.

Take a surgeon. Her decisions can save a life, the work needs rare abilities and many years of study, and if she earned what a parking attendant earns, few would take on the training. A common misreading is that Davis and Moore said the rich deserve their wealth. They explained positions, not persons, and wrote that a reward need only be high enough to get the position filled well. Note too that important means useful to society as a whole, not hard or unpleasant: collecting garbage is unpleasant work, yet the theory expects modest pay for it, because many people are able to do it.

### Why the theory persuades

At its strongest the theory explains three things. Inequality appears in every known society, even in those built to be equal: in 1951 the sociologist Eva Rosenfeld described a kibbutz where incomes were equal yet members differed in prestige and influence, as the theory would predict. Rewards are not only money, which explains why prestige can make up for lower pay. And pay does rise for skills that are scarce, which helps explain why students choose long, demanding courses of study. Rewards also move when scarcity moves: when a skill becomes common its pay tends to fall, and when a new skill is in short supply, as computer programming has been in recent decades, its pay tends to rise.

### Tumin's critique

In 1953 Melvin Tumin answered in the same journal, and his points still frame the debate. Functional importance cannot be measured: a factory needs its unskilled workers as much as its engineers. The pool of talent is larger than the theory assumes, and stratification itself hides talent, since children of poor families seldom get the training. The sacrifice of training is overstated: parents often pay for it, and higher pay later repays it. People are also moved by satisfaction and the wish to serve, not only by rewards. Finally, stratification can divide a society, breeding suspicion and hostility between strata rather than holding it together.

The COVID-19 pandemic of 2020 gave a vivid example of the first point: many countries called cashiers, cleaners and delivery workers essential, yet they remain among the lowest paid. Davis replied to Tumin in the same issue, and the exchange became a classic of sociology.

### How to weigh the debate

Conflict theorists go further than Tumin: rewards, they say, reflect the power to set them and the advantages handed down in families, not the needs of society. Functionalists reply that a society that ignored scarcity and importance would struggle to fill its hardest jobs. A fair conclusion is that the theory describes how rewards could work in a truly open society, and less well how they work where origin weighs heavily. A good bagrut answer sets out the argument step by step, gives two of Tumin's criticisms with examples and ends with a reasoned judgment.

## Practice: the functionalist theory of stratification

For 11th grade students of sociology. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.

1. **According to Davis and Moore, which two features of a position decide how highly a society rewards it?** — Its functional importance to society, and the scarcity of people able to fill it, because the position needs rare talent or long training.
2. **Fill in the missing step of the Davis and Moore argument.** — Long, costly training: the people who could fill vital positions must give up years of earning to train, so they need a reason to do it.
3. **Which two of these positions would Davis and Moore expect to be rewarded most, and why? (a) an airline pilot; (b) a person who hands out leaflets; (c) a heart surgeon; (d) a cloakroom attendant.** — (a) and (c). Both positions are vital, since lives depend on them, and both need rare abilities and long training, so society must offer high rewards to fill them well. (b) and (d) are easy to fill.
4. **Fill in three of Tumin's replies in the table.** — Talent is scarce: the pool of talent is larger than assumed. Training costs years: later pay repays it, and parents often pay for it. Ranking unites: it breeds suspicion and hostility.
5. **In the COVID-19 pandemic of 2020, many countries called cashiers, cleaners and delivery workers essential, though they are among the lowest paid. Which of Tumin's criticisms does this support? Explain.** — That functional importance cannot be measured, or at least is not what sets pay: these jobs proved vital, yet their rewards stayed low, which suggests that other factors, such as bargaining power, decide rewards.
6. **A gifted girl from a poor family cannot afford a long degree and starts work at 18. Which of Tumin's criticisms does her case illustrate?** — That stratification is a barrier to talent: unequal resources stop able children of poor families from getting the training, so the society loses talent instead of using it, against what Davis and Moore assumed.
7. **In 1951 Eva Rosenfeld described a kibbutz where incomes were equal but members differed in prestige and influence. How could a functionalist use this finding, and what does it show about rewards?** — A functionalist could use it to support the claim that some ranking appears in every society, even one built on equality. It also shows that rewards need not be money: prestige and influence can do the same work.
8. **Write a short paragraph: is inequality necessary for a society to work? Use Davis and Moore, Tumin and one example.** — A good answer sets out the Davis and Moore argument (importance, scarcity, rewards), gives at least one criticism by Tumin with an example (essential workers, hidden talent), may add the conflict view of power and inheritance, and ends with a reasoned position, for example that some reward for scarce skills may be needed but not the size of today's gaps.

## Common questions

### Who were Davis and Moore?

Kingsley Davis and Wilbert E. Moore were American sociologists of the functionalist school. Their article Some Principles of Stratification, published in the American Sociological Review in 1945, became the best-known functionalist account of social inequality and the starting point of a long debate.

### What was Tumin's main criticism of Davis and Moore?

Melvin Tumin argued in 1953 that functional importance cannot be measured, that talent is more common than the theory assumes, and that stratification blocks talented children of poor families from training. Instead of uniting society, he wrote, stratification can divide it.

### Is stratification inevitable according to functionalism?

Yes. Davis and Moore held that every society needs some unequal rewards to fill its important and difficult positions, so some stratification is universal and necessary. They did not say how large the gaps must be, and wrote that rewards need only be enough to fill each position well.

### How does the conflict view of stratification differ?

Conflict theorists, following Marx, see inequality as the result of power: those who own resources or control institutions set the rewards and pass advantages to their children. For them stratification serves the powerful, not society as a whole.

### Does the functionalist theory justify inequality?

Critics say it does, because it presents existing rewards as useful to everyone. Davis and Moore replied that they were explaining why stratification exists, not defending any particular society or salary. The bagrut asks students to present both readings and weigh them with evidence.
