# What are the main cleavages in Israeli society?

> Written with AI · [Sociology: society, groups and inequality](https://lessoons.com/en/society-groups-and-inequality) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/society-groups-and-inequality/what-are-the-main-cleavages-in-israeli-society

Sociologists usually name five main cleavages in Israeli society: national, between Jews and Arabs; religious, between religious and secular Jews; ethnic, between Mizrahim and Ashkenazim; socioeconomic, between higher and lower incomes; and political, between right and left. A cleavage is a lasting line of division, and the groups on each side often describe it very differently.

## The topic explained

### What a social cleavage is

A social cleavage is a lasting line of division between groups that differ in identity, interests or values, a line that also shows up in organizations: parties, schools, newspapers, neighborhoods. In Trouble in Utopia (1989) the Israeli sociologists Dan Horowitz and Moshe Lissak described Israel as a multi-cleavage society, one in which several such lines run through the population at once.

Israeli sociology classes usually name five main cleavages in Israeli society: the national cleavage between Jews and Arabs, the religious cleavage between religious and secular Jews, the ethnic cleavage between Mizrahim (Jews whose families came from Asia and North Africa) and Ashkenazim (from Europe and America), the socioeconomic cleavage between higher and lower incomes, and the political cleavage between right and left. The misreading to avoid: a cleavage is a structure, not a quarrel. People on two sides of a line can live, work and study side by side; the cleavage names where their interests or values tend to part.

### Each side in its own words

The sociologist's first task is to state each side's view the way its own members would. On the religious cleavage, many religious Jews see Shabbat in public life and the religious law of marriage as what makes the state Jewish and keeps the Jewish people one; many secular Jews see the same arrangements as limits on personal choice. On the national cleavage, many Arab citizens describe themselves as a national minority seeking full equality in practice, while many Jews describe Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people in which every citizen has equal civil rights. Each account rests on real experience and real values.

A strong answer reports both accounts and then asks what evidence could test the claims inside them, without declaring a winner.

### Overlapping and cross-cutting cleavages

Cleavages matter most in how they combine. They are overlapping when the same people stand on the same side of several lines, so that each difference reinforces the others. They are cross-cutting when people who are on opposite sides of one line find themselves on the same side of another: a religious and a secular Jew with the same income and the same workplace share interests across the religious line.

Here is a made-up example of 100 adults in each of two towns. In town A, 40 are religious with higher incomes and 40 are secular with lower incomes, so 80 people sit on the two diagonal cells and the lines overlap. In town B, the four groups are equal, 25 each, and the lines cut across each other. Sociologists expect the conflict in town A to be sharper, because every dispute lines up the same two camps.

### What the surveys say, and what cuts across

In the Israel Democracy Institute's Israeli Democracy Index 2024, Israelis were asked which tension in society is the most acute. 48% named right and left, 31% Jews and Arabs, and 14% religious and secular; the rest chose other tensions or did not answer. Among Arab respondents, 55.5% named the tension between Jews and Arabs. The survey settles what people feel; it does not settle the causes of a tension or how wide the gaps behind it are. Places that cut across cleavages, such as hospitals, universities, workplaces and the Hebrew language itself, are where sociologists look for what holds a divided society together.

## Practice: cleavages in Israeli society

For 11th grade students of sociology. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Fill in the empty cells: between which groups does each cleavage run?** — National: Jews and Arabs. Ethnic: Mizrahim and Ashkenazim. Political: right and left.
2. **Which cleavage does each case show? (a) a debate over whether buses should run on Shabbat; (b) a gap in average wages between two neighborhoods; (c) an argument between two parties over the economy and security.** — (a) the religious cleavage; (b) the socioeconomic cleavage; (c) the political cleavage, between right and left.
3. **Here is made-up town B, with 100 adults. Are its two lines overlapping or cross-cutting? Compare it with town A, where the cells were 40, 10, 10 and 40.** — In town B the lines are cross-cutting: each religious group and each secular group is split equally between higher and lower incomes, 25 in each cell. In town A, 40 + 40 = 80 people sat on the diagonal, so the lines overlapped.
4. **Read the chart. By how many percentage points does the first answer exceed the second? What does the chart not tell you?** — By 48 - 31 = 17 points. The chart shows which tension people feel is the most acute; it does not show the causes of a tension, how wide the gaps are, or how many people feel each tension at all.
5. **Rewrite this sentence so that it describes the cleavage without taking a side: “The religious keep forcing their rules on everyone else.”** — For example: “Many religious Jews want public life to keep Shabbat and religious marriage law, and many secular Jews want more personal choice in these areas.” A good answer names both views in their holders' own terms and drops the loaded verb.
6. **Explain the difference between overlapping and cross-cutting cleavages, and say which one sociologists expect to sharpen conflict.** — Overlapping: the same people are on the same side of several lines, so differences reinforce each other. Cross-cutting: people who differ on one line share a side on another. Sociologists expect overlapping cleavages to sharpen conflict.
7. **Name one institution or shared experience that cuts across a cleavage in Israel, and explain in a short paragraph how it can connect people from both sides.** — A good answer names a real meeting place, such as a hospital, a university, a workplace or the Hebrew language, says which cleavage it cuts across, and explains that shared work, study or language creates common interests and contacts across the line, without claiming it removes the cleavage.

## Common questions

### What does multi-cleavage society mean?

It is a society with several lasting lines of division at once. Horowitz and Lissak used it for Israel in Trouble in Utopia (1989), describing national, religious, ethnic, economic and ideological divisions.

### Which cleavage is the deepest in Israel?

Sociologists disagree, and the answer depends on what is measured. In the Israeli Democracy Index 2024, the tension Israelis most often named as most acute was between right and left (48%), then between Jews and Arabs (31%).

### Is the ethnic cleavage still relevant?

Sociologists differ. Some point to marriages between Jews of different origins and to narrowing gaps; others point to differences that remain in education, income and recognition. A good answer gives both views and the data each relies on.

### What is the difference between a cleavage and a conflict?

A cleavage is a lasting structural line between groups; a conflict is an open struggle. A cleavage can stay calm for years, and people on both sides can cooperate across it.

### How do I answer a bagrut question on cleavages?

Define the cleavage, name the groups, present each side's view in its own terms, bring a fact or a survey finding, and say what cuts across the line. Avoid loaded words and do not declare one side right.
