# What is a total institution?

> Written with AI · [Socialization: how a person becomes social](https://lessoons.com/en/socialization-and-the-self) · Grade 10 · 2026-11-11 · https://lessoons.com/en/socialization-and-the-self/what-is-a-total-institution

A total institution is a place where many people in the same situation live, work and sleep together under one authority, cut off from the wider society for a long time and following a fixed, formally run routine. The sociologist Erving Goffman made the term known in Asylums (1961). Prisons, psychiatric hospitals, army barracks, boarding schools and monasteries are examples.

## The topic explained

### What Goffman meant by a total institution

Most people sleep in one place, work or study in another and spend free time in a third, with different people and under different authorities. A total institution breaks down those barriers. The sociologist Erving Goffman (1922–1982) described it as a place of residence and work where many people in the same situation, cut off from the wider society for a long period, lead an enclosed, formally administered life. He drew the idea mainly from about a year of fieldwork, in 1955–56, among the patients of St. Elizabeths Hospital, a large psychiatric hospital in Washington, D.C.

Goffman named four features. Every part of life happens in one place under one authority; it happens in the company of a large group treated alike; the day is tightly scheduled from above; and all of it is joined in one official plan that serves the institution's aims.

### Five kinds of total institution

Goffman sorted total institutions into five kinds: places that care for people seen as unable to look after themselves and harmless, such as homes for the aged; places that care for people seen as a risk to others without meaning it, such as psychiatric hospitals; places that protect the community from people seen as dangerous, such as prisons; places set up for a work-like task, such as army barracks, ships and boarding schools; and retreats from the world, such as monasteries.

The common misreading is to hear the term as a verdict. Goffman grouped places by how daily life is organized, not by whether they are good or bad: a monastery that people join by choice and a prison share the same structure.

### How a total institution remakes a self

On arrival a new inmate goes through what Goffman called mortification of the self: the supports of the old identity are taken away. Admission records a name and often a number, personal clothes are exchanged for standard issue, hair may be cut, privacy disappears and the timetable belongs to the institution. A system of privileges and punishments then teaches the new rules. This is resocialization, replacing old norms and habits with new ones. Goffman also showed that inmates are not passive: they find unofficial ways to get by, which he called the underlife of the institution.

Basic training in the Israeli army shows several of these features: recruits wear uniform, live and train with their unit, follow a timetable set by their commanders and learn a new language of ranks and orders. Goffman himself listed army barracks among total institutions. The differences matter too: soldiers go home on leave, service has a fixed end, and the aim is to train people for a role.

### What the idea explains and what it misses

The concept explains why people inside such places act in ways that look strange from outside: they are adapting to the institution, not only showing their personality. Its limits are just as clear. Goffman's account rests largely on one hospital and on the patients' point of view, and critics note that totality varies: many prisons, hospitals and schools today allow visits, phones and short stays. A strict day school is not a total institution at all, because its pupils go home every afternoon.

The three schools read total institutions differently too. A functionalist asks what task the institution performs for society, such as training soldiers or caring for the sick. A conflict theorist asks who has the power to send people there and whose interests the rules serve. Goffman, an interactionist, looked at how inmates and staff make meaning in daily life. A good bagrut answer names the features, applies them to the case and says where the case does not fit.

## Practice: total institutions and resocialization

For 10th grade students of sociology. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Define a total institution, and name the four features Goffman gave it.** — A total institution is a place where many people in the same situation live and work together, cut off from the wider society for a long time, under a formally run routine. Its features: one place and one authority; life in a large group treated alike; a timetable set from above; one official plan.
2. **Which of these are total institutions? (a) a day school; (b) a boarding school; (c) a prison; (d) an office; (e) a monastery; (f) a navy ship on a long voyage. Explain the ones that are not.** — (b), (c), (e) and (f) are total institutions. (a) and (d) are not: people go home at the end of the day and sleep, rest and work in different places under different authorities.
3. **Fill in the three empty cells of the table comparing everyday life with a total institution.** — Boss: one authority. Company: one large batch of people treated alike. Plan: one official plan.
4. **Name Goffman's type for each place: (a) a home for the aged; (b) a prison; (c) a monastery; (d) a merchant ship at sea for months.** — (a) type 1, care for people seen as unable to look after themselves and harmless; (b) type 3, protecting the community; (c) type 5, a retreat from the world; (d) type 4, a work-like task.
5. **Fill in the two missing steps on the path of resocialization in a total institution.** — Step 2: stripping, personal clothes, belongings and sometimes hair are taken away. Step 3: new rules and privileges, a system of rewards and punishments that teaches the institution's norms.
6. **A made-up case: on her first day at a strict boarding school, Maya hands in her phone, receives a uniform and a timetable from 6:30 to 22:00, and is told she can earn a weekend at home by good conduct. Which parts of Goffman's account does the case show?** — It shows mortification of the self: her phone and own clothes, supports of her old identity, are taken away. It shows a timetable set from above, and a privilege system, a reward for following the new rules, which is part of resocialization.
7. **In what ways does basic training in the Israeli army fit Goffman's model of a total institution, and in what ways does it differ?** — It fits: recruits wear uniform, live and train together under one command, follow a timetable set from above and learn new norms and language. It differs: soldiers go home on leave, service has a fixed end, and the aim is to train for a role. A good answer gives at least two of each.
8. **Write a short paragraph: what does the concept of a total institution explain well, and what is one criticism of it?** — A good answer says that the concept explains why people inside such places behave as they do, as adaptation to the institution, and how it remakes a self. It gives a criticism, such as that Goffman's account rests largely on one hospital and the patients' view, or that totality varies between institutions and over time, and explains it.

## Common questions

### Is the army a total institution?

Goffman listed army barracks among total institutions, in the group set up for a work-like task. Basic training has many of the features: uniform, a shared timetable and life under one command. But soldiers go home on leave and service has a fixed end, so the army is less total than a closed hospital or a prison.

### Is a school a total institution?

A boarding school can be, because pupils live, sleep and study there under one authority. An ordinary day school is not: its pupils go home every afternoon. A day school still resocializes and teaches norms, but it does not control the whole of life.

### What is mortification of the self?

Mortification of the self is Goffman's term for how a total institution strips away a new inmate's old identity: personal clothes and belongings are taken, a number may replace a name, privacy disappears and the timetable is the institution's. It prepares the ground for resocialization.

### What is the difference between a total institution and resocialization?

A total institution is a kind of place, defined by how daily life is organized. Resocialization is a process, replacing old norms and habits with new ones. Total institutions resocialize intensively, but resocialization also happens elsewhere, for example when someone joins a new religious community or moves to a new country.

### Who came up with the term total institution?

Erving Goffman made the term known, first in a 1957 paper and then in his book Asylums (1961). Some scholars think he took the phrase from the sociologist Everett Hughes, but the analysis of how such places work is Goffman's own.
