# What is the bystander effect?

> Written with AI · [Social psychology: conformity, obedience and helping](https://lessoons.com/en/social-psychology) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/social-psychology/what-is-the-bystander-effect

The bystander effect is the finding that a person is less likely to help in an emergency when other people are present. In Darley and Latané's 1968 study, 85% of participants who thought they were the only listener reported a seizure before it ended, but only 31% did when they thought four others could hear it. Responsibility is spread across the group.

## The topic explained

### More witnesses, less help

The bystander effect is the finding that the presence of other people makes each of them less likely to help someone in need, and slower to do it. The research began after the murder of Kitty Genovese in New York on 13 March 1964. The New York Times reported that 38 neighbors had watched and done nothing. Later investigation showed the story was exaggerated: there were far fewer eyewitnesses, several could only hear the attack, and police were called. In 2016 the newspaper itself called its report flawed. The case was wrong in its details, but the question it raised was real.

John Darley and Bibb Latané tested it in 1968. Seventy-two students took part in a discussion about university life over an intercom, each alone in a booth. Each believed the group had 2, 3 or 6 people. Partway through, one speaker, actually a recording, began to have a seizure. When the participant thought no one else could hear, 85 percent went for help before the seizure ended; with 3 people, 62 percent; with 6, only 31 percent. The average response time rose from 52 to 166 seconds.

### Five decisions before anyone helps

Latané and Darley (1970) described helping as five decisions in a row, and a no at any one of them means no help. The bystander must notice the event, interpret it as an emergency, take responsibility, decide how to help, and act. The presence of others weakens two of the steps. At step 3, diffusion of responsibility: with many witnesses each feels only a share of the duty, and assumes someone else has called. At step 2, pluralistic ignorance: each person looks calm while checking whether the others are worried, so everyone concludes there is no emergency.

The common mistake is to explain the bystander effect with apathy, as if people simply do not care. In the seizure study the participants who did not report it were not indifferent: many were anxious, sweating and asked afterwards whether the victim was all right. They were stuck between two steps, not cold.

### The room that filled with smoke

In a second study, published the same year, Latané and Darley had students fill in a questionnaire while white smoke began to pour through a vent. Alone, 75 percent of them reported it. In groups of three real participants, only 38 percent did. With two actors who had been told to stay calm and keep writing, 10 percent did, and the others sat on in the smoke, waving it from their faces. This is pluralistic ignorance in its pure form: each person read the calm of the others as information.

### What the newer evidence adds

A meta-analysis by Fischer and colleagues (2011) found that the effect weakens, and can disappear, when an emergency is clearly dangerous, perhaps because danger is easy to interpret and others can help physically. Philpot and colleagues (2020) watched 219 real street disputes recorded on security cameras in Lancaster, Amsterdam and Cape Town: in over 90 percent at least one bystander stepped in, and the more bystanders there were, the more likely someone was to help. So each single bystander may be less likely to act, while the group as a whole usually helps. Knowing the steps is itself a defense: point at one person and give a clear task, "you, call an ambulance."

## Practice: the bystander effect

For 12th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Read the chart. By how many percentage points did helping fall between a group of 2 and a group of 6?** — From 85 to 31 percent, a fall of 54 percentage points.
2. **Fill in the two missing steps of the bystander decision model.** — Step 2: interpret the event as an emergency. Step 3: take responsibility for helping.
3. **What is the difference between diffusion of responsibility and pluralistic ignorance?** — Diffusion of responsibility: each witness feels only part of the duty to help, so each waits for someone else (step 3). Pluralistic ignorance: each witness reads the others' calm as a sign that nothing is wrong (step 2).
4. **Write which step failed in each case.** — On headphones, did not see: step 1, noticing. Smoke, but everyone calm: step 2, interpreting (pluralistic ignorance). So many people, someone will call: step 3, taking responsibility (diffusion of responsibility).
5. **In the smoke study, why did the two calm actors lower reporting more than two real participants did?** — The actors stayed calm on purpose, so the participant had strong evidence that there was no danger. Real participants were also unsure and might show some worry, so their calm was weaker evidence (38 against 10 percent).
6. **A student falls in the schoolyard and dozens of students are standing around. Using the model, write two things you could do so that she gets help quickly.** — Name the emergency aloud so that no one misreads it (step 2), and give one named person one task, "Noa, call the nurse," so responsibility is not spread (step 3). Then help yourself (steps 4 and 5).
7. **Philpot and colleagues (2020) found that someone intervened in over 90 percent of real street disputes. Does this disprove the bystander effect? Explain.** — Not fully. The laboratory studies measure each individual's chance of helping, which falls with group size; the camera study measures whether anyone in the group helps, which rises with more people. A good answer adds that real disputes are often clearly dangerous, where Fischer et al. (2011) found the effect weakens.

## Common questions

### Did 38 people really watch Kitty Genovese and do nothing?

No. Later research, including a 2007 article in American Psychologist, showed that there were far fewer eyewitnesses, many only heard noises, and police were called. In 2016 the New York Times called its own report flawed. The case started the research but is not good evidence for it.

### Is the bystander effect the same as apathy?

No. People who do not help are often anxious and unsure, not indifferent. The effect comes from how others' presence changes interpreting the situation and feeling responsible, not from a lack of caring.

### Does the bystander effect happen online?

Researchers have studied it in online settings, such as many people seeing a cry for help in a group chat, and the same logic of spread responsibility applies. If you see one, write to the person directly or tell a trusted adult instead of assuming someone else did.

### How can I avoid the bystander effect in an emergency?

Decide that you are the one responsible, say clearly that it is an emergency, and give specific people specific tasks: one calls the emergency number, one fetches an adult. In Israel the emergency numbers are 101 for an ambulance and 100 for the police.

### Who were Darley and Latané?

John Darley and Bibb Latané were American social psychologists who began studying bystander behavior in New York after the Genovese case. Their seizure and smoke studies were published in 1968, and their book on the five-step model in 1970.
