# What is cognitive dissonance?

> Written with AI · [Social psychology: conformity, obedience and helping](https://lessoons.com/en/social-psychology) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/social-psychology/what-is-cognitive-dissonance

Cognitive dissonance is the uncomfortable tension a person feels when two of their thoughts, or a thought and an action, contradict each other, such as "I care about my health" and "I smoke." Leon Festinger's theory (1957) says people reduce it, often by changing an attitude. In a 1959 study, students paid $1 to lie liked a dull task more than those paid $20.

## The topic explained

### When a thought and an action clash

An attitude is a lasting evaluation of something, a person, an idea or an object, and it has three components: what we feel about it (affective), what we do about it (behavioral) and what we believe about it (cognitive). Usually the three fit together. Cognitive dissonance is the unpleasant tension a person feels when two cognitions, thoughts, beliefs or knowledge of one's own actions, contradict each other. Leon Festinger set out the theory in 1957.

Festinger argued that dissonance works like hunger: it is uncomfortable, so people are driven to reduce it, and the more important the clash, the stronger the drive. A student who believes cheating is wrong and has just copied an answer feels dissonance. He cannot undo the copying, so he is likely to adjust the belief: "everyone does it on this kind of test."

### The one dollar study

Festinger and James Carlsmith (1959) gave 71 male students at Stanford an hour of deliberately boring work: half an hour moving 12 spools onto a tray and off again, then half an hour turning 48 pegs a quarter turn at a time. Afterwards some were asked to tell the next participant, actually a confederate, that the tasks had been enjoyable, and were paid either $1 or $20 to do it. A control group told no one anything. Then every participant rated how enjoyable the tasks had been, from −5 to +5.

The $20 group had a good reason for the lie, the money, so they felt little dissonance and still rated the tasks as dull (−0.05, close to the control group's −0.45). The $1 group had no good reason: "I lied for one dollar" clashes with "I am an honest person." They reduced the clash by deciding the tasks had not been so bad after all (+1.35). The common mistake is to predict the opposite, that a bigger reward produces a bigger change. Here the smaller reward changed the attitude more.

### Four ways to reduce dissonance

A person can change the behavior (stop smoking), change the belief (decide the risk is exaggerated), add a justifying thought (it calms me), or trivialize or avoid the information (everything causes cancer; skip the warning on the pack). The theory predicts the easiest route, and since past behavior cannot be changed, the belief usually moves.

Two classic findings follow. Effort justification: Aronson and Mills (1959) found that students who had gone through an embarrassing initiation to join a discussion group rated its boring discussion as more interesting than those whose initiation was mild; having suffered for it, they valued it more. Post-decision dissonance: in Brehm's study (1956), women who chose one appliance as a gift then rated it higher and the rejected one lower.

### Strengths, limits and a rival account

The theory explains a wide range of behavior with one idea and has held up in many experiments. Daryl Bem (1967) offered a rival, self-perception theory: we infer our attitudes from our behavior the way an observer would, without any tension, "I said it was fun for only a dollar, so I must have found it fun." Later studies suggest both happen: dissonance when an act clearly contradicts an attitude we care about, self-perception when our attitude was weak to begin with. The classic studies also used small samples of American students. A good answer defines the term, describes the $1 and $20 study with its numbers, and names a limit.

## Practice: cognitive dissonance

For 12th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Write the component of the attitude that each sentence shows.** — I feel good when I recycle: affective. I take bottles to the bin: behavioral. Recycling saves resources: cognitive.
2. **Fill in the middle box of the flow.** — An unpleasant tension, cognitive dissonance, caused by the clash between the two thoughts.
3. **In the chart, what rating did the $1 group give? Explain why it was higher than the $20 group's.** — +1.35. The $20 group had a strong outside reason for lying, so little dissonance; the $1 group had none, so they reduced the dissonance by deciding the tasks were more enjoyable.
4. **Why did Festinger and Carlsmith need a control group that told no lie?** — To know how boring the tasks seemed with no lie at all (−0.45). Only against that baseline could they show that the $1 group's rating had moved and the $20 group's had not.
5. **A student skipped training for a week and says: "The coach isn't serious anyway." Which way of reducing dissonance is this? Name one other way she could use.** — She changes or adds a belief (the coach is not serious) to justify her behavior. She could instead change the behavior: go back to training.
6. **Soldiers who finished a hard selection course often speak of their unit with great pride. Use effort justification to explain this, with the study it comes from.** — Effort justification: having invested great effort, a person reduces the dissonance of "I suffered for nothing" by valuing the goal more. Aronson and Mills (1959) found that a severe initiation made a dull group seem more interesting. Pride also has other sources, such as real achievement.
7. **Compare dissonance theory with self-perception theory as explanations of the $1 result.** — Dissonance: the $1 students felt tension between lying and seeing themselves as honest, and changed their attitude to reduce it. Self-perception (Bem 1967): with no tension, they looked at their own behavior and inferred they must have liked the task. A good answer adds that dissonance fits strong attitudes and self-perception weak ones.

## Common questions

### What is an everyday example of cognitive dissonance?

Buying an expensive phone and then reading reviews that praise it while skipping the critical ones. The purchase cannot be undone, so the buyer reduces the dissonance by seeking information that supports the choice.

### Is cognitive dissonance a mental disorder?

No. It is a normal experience that everyone has, and a theory about how attitudes change. It is not a diagnosis. If someone feels constant distress about a conflict in their life, a school counselor is a good person to talk to.

### What was When Prophecy Fails?

A 1956 book by Festinger, Riecken and Schachter about a small group that expected to be rescued by a spacecraft before a predicted disaster. When nothing happened, most members did not abandon the belief but reinterpreted the failure, an early case for the theory.

### Why did 20 dollars change attitudes less than one dollar?

Because $20, a large sum in 1959, was enough to explain the lie. With a good outside reason there is little dissonance and nothing to reduce. With $1 the lie could only be explained by deciding the task was not so bad.

### Is cognitive dissonance used in advertising?

Advertisers try to ease the doubts that follow a purchase, for example with messages that reassure buyers they chose well. Asking for a small commitment first, then a larger one, also uses the wish to act consistently.
