# What did Milgram's obedience experiment show?

> Written with AI · [Social psychology: conformity, obedience and helping](https://lessoons.com/en/social-psychology) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/social-psychology/what-did-milgrams-obedience-experiment-show

Milgram's obedience experiment (1961–1963) showed that ordinary people will follow an authority's orders to harm someone far further than anyone predicted: 26 of 40 men (65%) went on giving what they believed were electric shocks up to the last switch, 450 volts. His variations showed that obedience depends heavily on the situation, falling to 10% when two peers refused.

## The topic explained

### A study of learning that was really about obedience

Obedience is doing what a person with authority tells you to do. Stanley Milgram, a young psychologist at Yale University, began his experiments in August 1961, a few months after the trial of Adolf Eichmann opened in Jerusalem, and asked how far ordinary people would go when ordered to hurt someone. He reported the first study in 1963. Forty men aged 20 to 50 from the New Haven area answered an advertisement for a study of memory and learning.

A rigged draw always made the participant the teacher. The learner, actually an actor, was strapped into a chair in the next room. The teacher read word pairs and, for each mistake, pressed a switch on a shock generator, one step higher each time. The experimenter, in a grey lab coat, stood beside the teacher. No shock was ever real.

### Thirty switches and the result

The generator had 30 switches, from 15 to 450 volts in steps of 15, labeled from Slight Shock to Danger: Severe Shock. At 300 volts the learner pounded on the wall, and after that he fell silent. When a teacher hesitated, the experimenter used four set prods in order, from "Please continue" to "You have no other choice, you must go on."

Every one of the 40 men reached 300 volts, and 26 of them, 65 percent, went to 450. Psychology students and psychiatrists whom Milgram asked beforehand predicted that almost no one would. Obedience did not mean calm: many sweated, trembled, laughed nervously and argued, and still pressed the switch. The common mistake is to read this as proof that the men were cruel. Milgram's point was the opposite: they were ordinary people in a situation built to make stopping hard: a respected university, a calm scientist who took responsibility, and small steps of 15 volts, so that each new switch was only a little worse than the last.

### The variations: obedience depends on the situation

In later versions, each with 40 new participants, Milgram changed one feature at a time. In a run-down office in Bridgeport, with no link to Yale, 47.5 percent obeyed fully. With the learner in the same room, 40 percent; when the teacher had to press the learner's hand onto a shock plate, 30 percent. When two other teachers, both actors, refused to go on, only 10 percent continued. Distance from the victim, the prestige of the setting and the presence of others who disobey all changed the outcome.

Milgram explained the results with the agentic state: a person under authority comes to see himself as the instrument of another's wishes, no longer responsible for what he does. Haslam and Reicher (2012) offered a different reading, engaged followership: people continued because they identified with the scientific goal the experimenter stood for, which fits the finding that the bluntest prod, "you have no other choice," usually produced refusal.

### How solid is it?

Diana Baumrind (1964) attacked the study's ethics: deception and real distress, with no right to stop that felt real. Gina Perry (2012), after reading Milgram's files, argued that only about half the participants fully believed the shocks were real, and most of those who believed disobeyed. Yet Jerry Burger (2009), stopping at 150 volts for ethical reasons, found obedience at about the rate Milgram had found at that point. Milgram replied that every participant was told the truth afterwards and met the unharmed learner, and that in his follow-up survey 84 percent said they were glad or very glad to have taken part. The argument over whether that justifies the study is part of what students are asked to weigh. A strong answer gives the 65 percent, a variation that lowered it, an explanation, and one criticism.

## Practice: Milgram's obedience experiment

For 12th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Write who played each role in Milgram's experiment.** — Teacher: the real participant. Learner: an actor working with Milgram. Experimenter: a researcher in a grey lab coat who gave the prods.
2. **What did the participants believe the study was about, and why did Milgram not tell them the truth?** — They believed it was a study of memory and learning (the effect of punishment on learning). If they had known it was about obedience, they would have behaved differently, so the deception was needed to measure real obedience.
3. **Fill in the label at 450 volts on the scale.** — 26 of 40 (65 percent) reached 450 volts, the last switch.
4. **Read the chart. Which version produced the least obedience? By how many percentage points did touching the learner lower obedience compared with the Yale baseline?** — Two peers refuse, 10 percent. Touching the learner lowered obedience from 65 to 30 percent, a fall of 35 percentage points.
5. **Explain the agentic state, using one participant who kept going while saying he was not responsible.** — In the agentic state a person sees himself as an instrument carrying out someone else's wishes, so he shifts responsibility to the authority. A participant who keeps pressing the switch while saying "he is responsible, not me" is in this state.
6. **The Bridgeport office lowered obedience less than the touch version did. What does that suggest about what mattered most?** — The prestige of Yale mattered, but less than the closeness of the victim: seeing and touching the person being hurt made it much harder to obey (30 percent, against 47.5 in Bridgeport).
7. **Write a paragraph evaluating Milgram's conclusion that obedience comes from the situation, not from the person. Use one finding that supports it and one criticism.** — A good answer cites support (obedience moved from 65 to 10 percent when only the situation changed; Burger 2009 found similar rates) and a criticism (Perry 2012: many did not fully believe the shocks; Baumrind 1964 on ethics; the engaged followership reading of Haslam and Reicher), and concludes.

## Common questions

### Did anyone actually get shocked in the Milgram experiment?

No. The learner was an actor and the generator gave no real shocks, except a mild sample shock of 45 volts that the teacher received at the start so the machine would seem real.

### Were women tested in Milgram's studies?

Yes, in one later version with 40 women. Their rate of full obedience did not differ significantly from the men's, although Milgram reported that the women showed more signs of conflict.

### Why is the Milgram experiment connected to the Eichmann trial?

Milgram began in August 1961, a few months after Adolf Eichmann's trial opened in Jerusalem, and he presented his work as a way to ask how ordinary people come to take part in terrible acts. Historians stress that a laboratory cannot explain the Holocaust, which had many causes.

### Could the Milgram experiment be done today?

Not in its original form: an ethics committee would not allow the distress or the pressure on participants who wanted to stop. Burger's 2009 partial replication stopped at 150 volts, screened out vulnerable people and told everyone the truth at once.

### What is the difference between obedience and conformity?

In obedience a person with authority gives a direct order. In conformity no one gives an order: the pressure comes from equals, as in Asch's line study.
