# What did Asch's conformity experiment show?

> Written with AI · [Social psychology: conformity, obedience and helping](https://lessoons.com/en/social-psychology) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/social-psychology/what-did-aschs-conformity-experiment-show

Asch's conformity experiment (1951) showed that many people will give an answer they can see is wrong rather than stand alone against a group. On the critical trials about a third of the answers went along with a unanimous wrong majority, and 74% of participants conformed at least once. It also showed independence: most answers stayed correct, and one ally cut conformity sharply.

## The topic explained

### A task with an obvious answer

Conformity is changing what you say or do to match a group. Solomon Asch, a psychologist at Swarthmore College in the United States, wanted to know how strong that pull is when the group is plainly wrong. In 1951 he seated groups of eight male college students around a table and showed them two cards: one standard line, and three comparison lines. Each person in turn said aloud which comparison line matched the standard. The task was easy: alone, a control group of 37 students made mistakes on fewer than 1 percent of the trials.

Only one person in each group was a real participant. The other seven were confederates, actors who had been told what to say. On 12 of the 18 trials, the critical trials, they all gave the same wrong answer, and the real participant answered near the end, after hearing them. Asch told everyone the study was about visual judgment, so the participant had no reason to suspect the others. He later reported the same design with 123 students from three universities (1955, 1956).

### What Asch found

Across the 50 participants, about a third of the answers on critical trials (35.7 percent) went along with the wrong majority. 74 percent of the participants conformed at least once, 12 percent did so on nearly every critical trial, and 26 percent never did. In the interviews afterwards some said they began to doubt their own eyes; most said they knew the group was wrong but did not want to stand out.

The common misreading is that Asch proved people are sheep. Read the other way, the same numbers say that nearly two thirds of the answers stayed correct under pressure, and that the typical participant resisted the group more often than he gave in. Asch himself was interested in independence as much as in conformity, and later reviews of textbooks found that most of them reported only the conforming third.

### What made the pressure rise and fall

Asch then changed one thing at a time. When a single confederate gave the correct answer, a true partner, conformity fell sharply: the participant was no longer alone. When participants wrote their answers instead of saying them aloud, conformity fell, which shows that much of it was public going along rather than a changed perception. The size of the majority mattered up to a point: one opponent produced very little conformity, two or three produced much more, and larger groups added nothing further. Even when the wrong line was far from the standard, some participants still conformed.

The partner result is the most useful one outside the laboratory. The pressure came from unanimity, the sense that everyone else agrees, more than from the number of people. A single voice that breaks the agreement, even one that is wrong in a different way, gives a person permission to say what they see. That is why one classmate who speaks up in a meeting can change what the rest are willing to say.

### How far the result travels

The participants were young American men in the early 1950s, a time when going along was strongly valued. Bond and Smith (1996) combined 133 Asch-type studies from 17 countries and found higher conformity in collectivist cultures, which stress the group, than in individualist ones, and a decline in American samples since the 1950s. A 1980 British replication by Perrin and Spencer, with science and engineering students, found almost no conformity. The lines were also a trivial task with strangers; with friends, or on a question that matters, the pressure may differ. A good answer gives the numbers, the variations that changed them, and one of these limits.

## Practice: Asch's conformity experiment

For 12th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Look at the cards. Which comparison line matches the standard? Why did Asch choose a task this easy?** — Line 3. Asch chose an easy task so that any wrong answer could only come from the group's pressure: alone, people made mistakes on fewer than 1 percent of trials.
2. **Fill in the missing step of a critical trial.** — The seven confederates give the same wrong answer aloud, one after another.
3. **What is a confederate, and what is a critical trial?** — A confederate is an actor working with the researcher who pretends to be a participant. A critical trial is one on which all the confederates give the same wrong answer; there were 12 of them out of 18 trials.
4. **Read the chart. What percentage of participants conformed at least once? What percentage never did?** — 74 percent conformed at least once (62 + 12). 26 percent never conformed.
5. **Write the effect of each change on conformity.** — One honest partner: conformity fell sharply. Answers written privately: conformity fell. A majority of one person: very little conformity.
6. **Conformity fell when participants wrote their answers. What does this tell us about why most of them went along?** — Most of them did not really see the lines differently; they went along in public to avoid standing out. Writing in private removed the pressure of being seen to disagree.
7. **A student writes: "Asch proved that people always follow the crowd." Write a short evaluation of this claim.** — A good answer says the claim goes too far: about a third of the answers conformed and about two thirds stayed correct, 26 percent never conformed, and one ally cut conformity sharply. It adds a limit on generalizing (young American men in the 1950s; higher conformity in collectivist cultures and a decline over time, Bond and Smith 1996) and concludes that the study shows a real but conditional pressure.

## Common questions

### Was the Asch experiment ethical?

It used deception: participants were told it was a test of perception and did not know the others were actors. They were interviewed and told the truth afterwards, and the stress was mild compared with later studies such as Milgram's, but today an ethics committee would ask for careful debriefing.

### Did the participants really believe the group?

Mostly not. In the interviews most said they knew the group was wrong but went along so as not to stand out. A few said they began to doubt their own eyes. That is why conformity fell when answers were written privately.

### Why did Asch use a task with an obvious answer?

So that the group was clearly wrong. If the task had been hard, a participant might agree because the group seemed to know more. With an obvious answer, going along shows the power of the group itself.

### Has the Asch experiment been repeated?

Many times. A 1996 meta-analysis by Bond and Smith combined 133 studies from 17 countries and found the effect everywhere, stronger in collectivist cultures and weaker in American samples over time.

### What is the difference between conformity and obedience?

In conformity the pressure comes from equals, and nobody gives an order: you match the group. In obedience a person with authority gives a direct instruction, as in Milgram's studies of obedience.
