# What is the difference between normative and informational social influence?

> Written with AI · [Social psychology: conformity, obedience and helping](https://lessoons.com/en/social-psychology) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/social-psychology/normative-and-informational-social-influence

Normative social influence is going along with a group to be liked and accepted; it usually changes what a person says in public but not what they believe. Informational social influence is going along because the group seems to know better, usually when the situation is unclear; it changes what a person privately believes. Asch's lines show the first, Sherif's moving light the second.

## The topic explained

### Two reasons to go along

People conform for two different reasons, a distinction Morton Deutsch and Harold Gerard set out in 1955. Normative social influence is conforming in order to be liked and accepted, or to avoid being laughed at or left out. Informational social influence is conforming because we think the others are right: when we are unsure, other people are a source of information about reality.

The two reasons lead to different kinds of change. Normative influence usually produces public compliance: you say what the group says while privately disagreeing. Informational influence produces private acceptance: you actually come to believe the group's view, and you keep it when you are alone. A simple test tells them apart: remove the audience. If the person goes back to their own answer in private, the influence was normative.

### Sherif's moving light: informational influence

Muzafer Sherif (1935) seated people in a completely dark room and showed them a small point of light about 15 feet away. The light did not move, but in total darkness it seems to drift, an illusion called the autokinetic effect. Asked alone how far it moved, people gave very different estimates. Then they judged it aloud in groups of three over several sessions. Their estimates drew together until each group settled on its own group norm, a shared answer. When they were tested alone again afterwards, they kept the group's answer.

That last result is the mark of informational influence. Nobody pressured anyone, and the task had no right answer. Each person used the others' estimates to define an ambiguous reality, and the norm became their own belief.

Informational influence is often sensible. A tourist who follows the crowd off a train at an unfamiliar station is using good information. It becomes dangerous when the others know no more than you do: in a crisis, when there is no time to check, a rumor can spread because each person takes the others' belief as evidence. It is strongest when a situation is ambiguous, when it is urgent, and when the others seem to be experts.

### Asch's lines: normative influence

Asch's study of 1951 is the opposite case. The lines were clear, and alone people answered almost perfectly. When a unanimous group of actors gave a wrong answer, about a third of the answers went along with them, and most of those who conformed said afterwards that they knew the group was wrong. When participants could write their answers privately, conformity fell. That pattern, going along in public without believing, is normative influence.

The common mistake is to treat a study as purely one kind. In Asch's interviews a few participants said they had begun to doubt their eyes, an informational effect, and in an ambiguous task the wish to fit in also plays a part. The two motives often work together, and the task decides which one is stronger: the more ambiguous the situation, the more informational influence; the clearer the answer and the more public the response, the more normative.

### How deep does the change go?

Herbert Kelman (1958) described three levels. Compliance: going along in public to gain approval or avoid disapproval. Identification: adopting a group's views while you belong to it and value it, like a new recruit who takes on the unit's way of speaking. Internalization: accepting a view as your own because it fits your values, so it lasts even when the group is gone. Normative influence usually stops at compliance or identification; informational influence can reach internalization.

## Practice: normative and informational social influence

For 12th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Write the kind of social influence in each case.** — New student copies the look: normative (to be accepted). Tourist follows the crowd to the train: informational (they seem to know the way). Copies the class on a hard question: informational (unsure, so the class is a source of information).
2. **Fill in the three missing cells of the table.** — Informational motive: to be right. Normative result: public compliance. Informational classic study: Sherif, 1935.
3. **What is the autokinetic effect, and why did Sherif use it?** — The autokinetic effect is the illusion that a still point of light in total darkness is moving. Sherif used it because the task had no right answer, so he could see how a group builds a shared answer in an ambiguous situation.
4. **Look at the sketch. What happens to the three estimates between session 1 and session 3? Draw where the group norm would be.** — They start far apart (1.5 to 7.5 inches) and draw together until they are all close to about 4 inches. The group norm is a horizontal line at about 4 inches.
5. **In Sherif's study the participants kept the group's estimate when tested alone; in Asch's, conformity fell when answers were private. What does each result show?** — Sherif: the group norm had become the person's own belief, private acceptance, so the influence was informational. Asch: people went along only in public, public compliance, so the influence was mainly normative.
6. **A soldier adopts her unit's slang and opinions during her service and drops them afterwards. Which of Kelman's levels is this? Explain.** — Identification: she takes on the group's views while she belongs to it and values it, and they fade when she leaves. If she had kept them for good because they fit her own values, it would be internalization.
7. **A student says: "Informational influence is good and normative influence is bad." Evaluate the claim.** — A good answer says neither is good or bad in itself. Informational influence helps when others really know more (following the crowd out of a burning building) but misleads when they do not (a rumor). Normative influence can keep people from saying what they see (Asch) but also supports useful norms such as queuing. It concludes that what matters is whether the group is right and whether the person can still speak up.

## Common questions

### Who first named normative and informational influence?

Morton Deutsch and Harold Gerard, in a 1955 study of individual judgment in groups. They argued that conformity in studies like Asch's mixes two motives, the wish to be accepted and the wish to be correct.

### Is conformity on social media normative or informational?

Often both. Liking a post because friends liked it can be normative, a wish to fit in; believing a claim because many people shared it is informational, using others as a guide. The number of shares says how popular a claim is, not whether it is true.

### Which kind of influence lasts longer?

Informational influence usually lasts longer, because it changes what people believe; Sherif's participants kept the group norm when alone. Normative influence often disappears when the group is not watching.

### What makes informational influence stronger?

Ambiguity, when the right answer is unclear; a crisis, when there is no time to think; and others who seem expert. All three make other people look like the best source of information available.

### Is conformity the same as obedience?

No. In conformity the pressure comes from equals and no one gives an order. In obedience a person with authority gives a direct instruction, as in Milgram's studies.
