# Why was Saul rejected as king?

> Written with AI · [Saul and David: the first kings](https://lessoons.com/en/saul-and-david) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-09 · https://lessoons.com/en/saul-and-david/why-was-saul-rejected-as-king

In 1 Samuel 15 Saul is rejected as king because he does not fully obey God's command about Amalek: he spares King Agag and the best of the flocks, then blames the people. Samuel answers “הִנֵּה שְׁמֹעַ מִזֶּבַח טוֹב” (to obey is better than sacrifice, 15:22), and when the robe tears he tells Saul that the Lord has torn the kingdom from him.

## The topic explained

### The command and what Saul did

Chapter 15 of 1 Samuel (“שמואל א”, Shmuel Alef) opens with “וְעַתָּה שְׁמַע לְקוֹל דִּבְרֵי ה׳” (now listen to the voice of the words of the Lord, 1 Samuel 15:1). God says “פָּקַדְתִּי אֵת אֲשֶׁר־עָשָׂה עֲמָלֵק לְיִשְׂרָאֵל” (I have taken note of what Amalek did to Israel, 15:2), on the way out of Egypt, when, says Deuteronomy 25:18, it struck the weak at the rear. The command is herem: a war with no spoil, in which all that belongs to the enemy, people and animals, is destroyed. “וְהַחֲרַמְתֶּם אֶת־כָּל־אֲשֶׁר־לוֹ וְלֹא תַחְמֹל עָלָיו” (devote to destruction all that he has, and do not spare him, 15:3).

Then: “וַיַּחְמֹל שָׁאוּל וְהָעָם עַל־אֲגָג וְעַל־מֵיטַב הַצֹּאן וְהַבָּקָר” (Saul and the people spared Agag and the best of the sheep and cattle, 15:9). Spare is the very verb forbidden in verse 3, and “וְכָל־הַמְּלָאכָה נְמִבְזָה וְנָמֵס אֹתָהּ הֶחֱרִימוּ” (all that was despised and worthless, that they destroyed): only what was worth nothing was destroyed. So Saul is rejected as king not for a war he did not fight but for a command he kept only in part.

### To obey is better than sacrifice

Saul greets Samuel: “הֲקִימֹתִי אֶת־דְּבַר ה׳” (I have carried out the word of the Lord, 15:13), and Samuel answers with an ironic question: “וּמֶה קוֹל־הַצֹּאן הַזֶּה בְּאָזְנָי” (then what is this bleating of sheep in my ears, 15:14). Saul explains that the people spared them to sacrifice (15:15), and Samuel replies: “הִנֵּה שְׁמֹעַ מִזֶּבַח טוֹב לְהַקְשִׁיב מֵחֵלֶב אֵילִים” (to obey is better than sacrifice, to listen than the fat of rams, 15:22). It is a synonymous parallelism: obey matches listen, sacrifice matches the fat of rams.

Listen to the voice is the chapter's leading word: God demands it (15:1), Saul claims “אֲשֶׁר שָׁמַעְתִּי בְּקוֹל ה׳” (I did listen to the voice of the Lord, 15:20), and finally admits: “כִּי יָרֵאתִי אֶת־הָעָם וָאֶשְׁמַע בְּקוֹלָם” (for I feared the people and listened to their voice, 15:24). He listened to a voice: the people's. A common mistake is to write that Saul was punished for mercy; the text says “וַתַּעַט אֶל־הַשָּׁלָל” (you swooped on the spoil, 15:19) and ties the sin to fear of the people.

### The torn robe

As Samuel turns to go, “וַיִּסֹּב שְׁמוּאֵל לָלֶכֶת וַיַּחֲזֵק בִּכְנַף־מְעִילוֹ וַיִּקָּרַע” (he took hold of the corner of his robe, and it tore, 15:27). By the plain sense, says Rashi, Saul grabbed Samuel's robe; the midrash disputes it. Samuel makes it a symbolic act, a deed that carries God's word: “וַיֹּאמֶר אֵלָיו שְׁמוּאֵל קָרַע ה׳ אֶת־מַמְלְכוּת יִשְׂרָאֵל מֵעָלֶיךָ הַיּוֹם וּנְתָנָהּ לְרֵעֲךָ הַטּוֹב מִמֶּךָּ” (Samuel said to him: the Lord has torn the kingdom of Israel from you today and given it to your neighbor, who is better than you, 15:28). The chapter is framed by the root nicham (regret): God regrets making Saul king (15:11, 35), yet “וְגַם נֵצַח יִשְׂרָאֵל לֹא יְשַׁקֵּר וְלֹא יִנָּחֵם” (the Eternal One of Israel does not lie or change his mind, 15:29). Radak explains that God does not take back a good he promised, and Saul was never promised the kingdom forever.

### Struggling with the command

The command is hard for many readers, and the difficulty is old. In the Talmud (Yoma 22b) Saul himself argues: if a person sinned, what did the animals sin, and if the adults sinned, what did the children sin? A heavenly voice answers him, do not be overly righteous (Ecclesiastes 7:16). Maimonides rules that no war is waged against anyone, Amalek included, without first offering peace (Laws of Kings 6:1, 6:4). Herem was also a war custom elsewhere in the ancient Near East: King Mesha of Moab writes on his stele (about 840 BCE) that he devoted the town of Nebo to his god. The bagrut asks what the text says and how it is built; studying the chapter is not approving violence.

## Practice: Saul is rejected, 1 Samuel 15

For 11th grade students of the Bible. Read the verses printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Read: “וְהַחֲרַמְתֶּם אֶת־כָּל־אֲשֶׁר־לוֹ וְלֹא תַחְמֹל עָלָיו” (devote to destruction all that he has, and do not spare him, 3); “וַיַּחְמֹל שָׁאוּל וְהָעָם עַל־אֲגָג וְעַל־מֵיטַב הַצֹּאן וְהַבָּקָר” (Saul and the people spared Agag and the best of the sheep and cattle, 9). Fill in what was done with each thing.** — King Agag was taken alive; the best of the sheep and cattle were spared; the people seized the spoil. Only what was despised and worthless was destroyed. The verb spare in verse 9 is exactly what verse 3 forbade.
2. **Saul says: “הֲקִימֹתִי אֶת־דְּבַר ה׳” (I have carried out the word of the Lord, 13). Samuel answers: “וּמֶה קוֹל־הַצֹּאן הַזֶּה בְּאָזְנָי” (then what is this bleating of sheep in my ears, 14). What is the irony in Samuel's answer?** — Saul claims he carried out the word, and at that very moment the sheep he should have destroyed can be heard. The evidence against him is the voice of what he spared.
3. **Compare: “אֲשֶׁר חָמַל הָעָם עַל־מֵיטַב הַצֹּאן וְהַבָּקָר לְמַעַן זְבֹחַ לַה׳ אֱלֹהֶיךָ” (which the people spared, the best of the sheep and cattle, to sacrifice to the Lord your God, 15); “כִּי יָרֵאתִי אֶת־הָעָם וָאֶשְׁמַע בְּקוֹלָם” (for I feared the people and listened to their voice, 24). Whom does Saul blame, and what reason does he give each time?** — Both times he puts it on the people. In verse 15 the reason is religious, to sacrifice to the Lord; in verse 24 he admits the real reason was fear of the people.
4. **Read: “וַיֹּאמֶר שְׁמוּאֵל הַחֵפֶץ לַה׳ בְּעֹלוֹת וּזְבָחִים כִּשְׁמֹעַ בְּקוֹל ה׳ הִנֵּה שְׁמֹעַ מִזֶּבַח טוֹב לְהַקְשִׁיב מֵחֵלֶב אֵילִים” (Samuel said: does the Lord delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices as much as in obeying the voice of the Lord? To obey is better than sacrifice, to listen than the fat of rams, 22). Fill in the second half in the table. What does the verse say about sacrifice and obedience?** — Second half: to listen, better than the fat of rams. It is a synonymous parallelism. God does not want sacrifices in place of obedience: listening to his voice is better than any offering.
5. **The words listen and voice repeat in the chapter, for example: “וְעַתָּה שְׁמַע לְקוֹל דִּבְרֵי ה׳” (now listen to the voice of the words of the Lord, 1); “וּמֶה קוֹל־הַצֹּאן הַזֶּה בְּאָזְנָי” (then what is this bleating of sheep in my ears, 14); “כִּי יָרֵאתִי אֶת־הָעָם וָאֶשְׁמַע בְּקוֹלָם” (for I feared the people and listened to their voice, 24). Fill in whose voice is heard in each verse.** — In 14 the voice of the sheep; in 22 the voice of God; in 24 the voice of the people. Saul had to listen to God and listened to the people: that is the chapter's leading word.
6. **Read: “וַיִּסֹּב שְׁמוּאֵל לָלֶכֶת וַיַּחֲזֵק בִּכְנַף־מְעִילוֹ וַיִּקָּרַע” (as Samuel turned to go, he took hold of the corner of his robe, and it tore, 27); “וַיֹּאמֶר אֵלָיו שְׁמוּאֵל קָרַע ה׳ אֶת־מַמְלְכוּת יִשְׂרָאֵל מֵעָלֶיךָ הַיּוֹם וּנְתָנָהּ לְרֵעֲךָ הַטּוֹב מִמֶּךָּ” (Samuel said to him: the Lord has torn the kingdom of Israel from you today and given it to your neighbor, who is better than you, 28). What is a symbolic act, and what does the torn robe stand for?** — A symbolic act is a deed that carries God's word. As the robe tore, so the kingdom is torn from Saul and given to another, better than he, who will turn out to be David.
7. **The chapter says “נִחַמְתִּי כִּי־הִמְלַכְתִּי אֶת־שָׁאוּל לְמֶלֶךְ” (I regret that I made Saul king, 11) and also “וְגַם נֵצַח יִשְׂרָאֵל לֹא יְשַׁקֵּר וְלֹא יִנָּחֵם” (the Eternal One of Israel does not lie or change his mind, 29). How can the contradiction be resolved?** — A good answer states the contradiction and at least one solution, for example Radak's: God does not take back a good he promised, and Saul was never promised the kingdom forever, so this is no broken promise.
8. **Write a paragraph: why was Saul rejected? Give a claim, two quotations with chapter and verse, and an explanation.** — A good answer argues that Saul was rejected for listening to the people instead of to God, quotes for example 15:22 and 15:24, and explains them. It does not say he was punished for mercy, because the text describes spoil and fear.

## Common questions

### What does to obey is better than sacrifice mean?

Samuel tells Saul that obeying God is better than offering sacrifices (1 Samuel 15:22). Saul brought the flocks to sacrifice them, and Samuel answers that an offering cannot replace listening to God's voice. The prophets return to the same idea.

### Who were the Amalekites?

According to the Torah, Amalek attacked Israel after the exodus: “וַיָּבֹא עֲמָלֵק וַיִּלָּחֶם עִם־יִשְׂרָאֵל בִּרְפִידִם” (Amalek came and fought with Israel at Rephidim, Exodus 17:8). Deuteronomy 25:17–19 says it struck the weak at the rear, and commands Israel to remember what it did.

### How does Jewish tradition deal with the command to destroy Amalek?

Already in the Talmud (Yoma 22b) Saul asks what the animals and the children had sinned. Maimonides rules that no war, even against Amalek, is waged without first calling for peace. On the bagrut you present what the text says and how the commentators struggled with it.

### Whose robe was torn in 1 Samuel 15?

The text does not say outright. By the plain sense, writes Rashi, Saul took hold of Samuel's robe and it tore; in the midrash some say Samuel tore Saul's robe. Samuel explains the tear: the Lord has torn the kingdom from you (15:28).

### Did God regret making Saul king?

The chapter says God regretted it (15:11, 35) but also that he does not change his mind (15:29). Radak explains that God does not take back a good he promised, and Saul was never promised the kingdom forever. It is a familiar bagrut question.
