# What is a double-blind study?

> Written with AI · [Psychology: research methods and statistics](https://lessoons.com/en/psychology-research-methods) · Grade 10 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/psychology-research-methods/what-is-a-double-blind-study

A double-blind study is one in which neither the participants nor the researchers who deal with them know who is in which condition, for example who got the real pill and who got the placebo. It stops the expectations of both sides from creating a result, so that any difference between the groups can be put down to the treatment itself.

## The topic explained

### Who knows what in a study

In an open study everyone knows who gets which condition. In a single-blind study the participants do not know, but the researcher does. In a double-blind study neither the participants nor the researchers who give the treatment and measure the results know who is in which group; a third person holds the code, a list linking each participant to a condition, and opens it only when the data are in.

The reason is that people bring expectations into a study, and expectations change behavior. A double-blind study controls three of them at once: the placebo effect in the participants, the demand characteristics that make participants play along, and the experimenter effect of a researcher who hopes for a result. Each has a famous study behind it.

### The placebo effect

A placebo is a treatment that looks real but has no active ingredient, such as a sugar pill. People who believe they are being treated may feel and report improvement anyway, so a drug can only be judged against a placebo group that receives an identical-looking pill. In 1955 the anesthesiologist Henry Beecher published "The Powerful Placebo", which argued that placebo effects were large and stressed the need for double-blind, placebo-controlled trials. Later work cut the claim down: a 1997 reassessment found that much of his patients' improvement was regression to the mean, and a 2001 review of trials in 40 conditions by Hróbjartsson and Gøtzsche found a clear placebo effect only for pain.

A common misreading is that a double-blind study removes the placebo effect. It does not: the placebo group still believes it is being treated. Blinding makes the belief equal in both groups, so the difference between them is the treatment's own effect.

### Participants who play along

Demand characteristics are the cues in a study that tell participants what the researcher is looking for. Martin Orne (1962) showed how far people go to be good participants. He gave them sheets of random digits, each needing 224 additions, and took their watches; they kept working for hours, and once the experimenter gave up after five and a half hours. When each finished sheet had to be torn into at least 32 pieces before the next, they still went on for hours with little sign of anger, simply because it was an experiment. A participant who guesses the aim may act it out, so keeping the condition hidden, a single blind, is the first defense.

### Researchers who see what they expect

The researcher's hopes are the other half. In Rosenthal and Fode's 1963 study, student experimenters were told that their rats had been bred to be maze-bright or maze-dull; the "bright" rats learned better, although the rats did not differ. More than a century ago the horse Clever Hans seemed to do arithmetic until Oskar Pfungst showed it was reading the questioner's tiny movements, and it failed when the questioner did not know the answer. A double blind, with staff who do not know the code, protects against these cues. Where blinding the participants is impossible, as in comparing a therapy with no therapy, the people who rate the outcome can still be kept blind.

## Practice: blind and double-blind studies

For 10th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **What is a placebo, and why does a drug trial need a placebo group?** — A placebo is a treatment that looks real but has no active ingredient, such as a sugar pill. The placebo group shows how much improvement comes from belief and time alone, so the drug's own effect is the difference between the groups.
2. **Fill in the table: in each kind of study, does the participant know the condition, and does the researcher?** — Single blind: the participant does not know, the researcher does. Double blind: neither the participant nor the researcher knows.
3. **Write the remedy for each problem.** — Placebo effect: a placebo group. Demand characteristics: a single blind, so participants do not know their condition or the aim. Experimenter effect: a double blind, so the researchers who deal with participants do not know the condition either.
4. **What happens in the last step of the double-blind trial, and why only then?** — The code is opened and the two groups are compared. It is opened only after the ratings are done, so no one's expectations could affect how a participant was treated or rated.
5. **In Orne's study, what did participants do, and what does it show about demand characteristics?** — They added random digits on sheet after sheet, and even tore each finished sheet into at least 32 pieces, for hours. It shows that participants try to do what they think the experiment wants, so cues about the aim can shape behavior.
6. **Why did the "maze-bright" rats in Rosenthal and Fode's study learn better?** — Not because they were brighter: the rats did not differ. The students who expected bright rats probably handled and recorded them differently, an experimenter effect. A double blind, where the handlers do not know which rats are which, prevents it.
7. **A school tests whether a mindfulness program lowers exam stress: one class does the program, another does not, and the program's own teacher rates the students' stress. Name two problems and suggest improvements.** — A good answer names demand characteristics (students in the program know what is expected and may report less stress) and an experimenter effect (the teacher hopes for a result and rates the students). Improvements: a comparison activity that looks equally real, random allocation of students, and raters or questionnaires scored by someone who does not know which group a student was in.

## Common questions

### What is the difference between single-blind and double-blind?

In a single-blind study only the participants do not know their condition. In a double-blind study the researchers who give the treatment and measure the results do not know either, which also controls the researchers' expectations.

### What is a triple-blind study?

A study in which a third party is also kept blind, usually the people who analyze the data or a monitoring committee. Many guidelines now prefer that a report simply states who was blind to what.

### Is a double-blind study ethical if people get a placebo?

It can be, if participants agree in advance knowing they may get a placebo, and if no one is denied a treatment already known to work. Where an effective treatment exists, the new one is usually compared with it instead of with a placebo.

### Can every study be double-blind?

No. A participant knows whether they are doing exercise or therapy, so they cannot be blind. Researchers then keep the people who measure the outcome blind, and use a comparison activity that looks equally real.

### Is the placebo effect real?

People do report feeling better after a placebo, especially for pain, but reviews suggest the effect is smaller than once thought, and part of the improvement comes from regression to the mean: people often join a study when they feel worst and improve anyway.
