# What is prophecy according to Maimonides?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: Providence, Prophecy and the Commandments](https://lessoons.com/en/providence-prophecy-and-commandments) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/providence-prophecy-and-commandments/what-is-prophecy-according-to-maimonides

Prophecy according to Maimonides is an overflow from God that reaches first a person's intellect and then his imagination. It comes only to one who is wise and of perfect character and has prepared himself, yet God may still withhold it. In the Guide 2:32 he sets this, the Torah's view, between the many, who think God chooses anyone, and the philosophers, who think it comes by nature alone.

## The topic explained

### Three views, like the views on creation

Maimonides opens the subject with a parallel: “דעות בני אדם בנבואה כדעותם בקדמות העולם וחידושו” (people's views on prophecy are like their views on the eternity or creation of the world, Guide 2:32), three in each case. The first, of the many, is “שהאלוה ית׳ יבחר מי שירצה מבני אדם וישרה בו הנבואה וישלחהו” (that God chooses whom He wills among people, makes prophecy rest on him and sends him), wise or foolish, old or young.

The second, of the philosophers, is “שהנבואה – שלמות אחד בטבע האדם” (that prophecy is a perfection in human nature): whoever perfects his mind, character and imagination will prophesy by necessity. The third, the Torah's, agrees with the philosophers except in one thing: “שאנחנו נאמין שהראוי לנבואה המכין עצמו לה, אפשר שלא יתנבא וזה – ברצון אלהי” (we believe that one fit for prophecy who prepares for it may not prophesy, and that is by divine will). The common mistake is to think Maimonides simply sides with the many.

### What prophecy is

Maimonides defines it in 2:36: “אמיתת הנבואה ומהותה הוא שפע שופע מאת האלוה ית׳ וית׳ באמצעות השכל הפועל, על הכח הדברי תחלה, ואחר כן ישפע על הכח המדמה” (the reality and essence of prophecy is an overflow from God, through the Active Intellect, first to the rational faculty and afterwards to the imaginative faculty). The intellect receives the truth; the imagination clothes it in images, visions and parables.

So the prophet must be complete in both. In the Mishneh Torah: “ואין הנבואה חלה אלא על חכם גדול בחכמה, גבור במדותיו” (prophecy rests only on one great in wisdom, strong in his traits, Yesodei HaTorah 7:1), master of his desires, with a broad and settled mind; and the sages' rule he cites in the Guide is “אין הנבואה שורה אלא על חכם גיבור ועשיר” (prophecy rests only on one who is wise, strong and rich).

### Moses, the greatest of the prophets

Moses' prophecy, for Maimonides, is of another kind. “שכל הנביאים בחלום או במראה ומשה רבנו מתנבא והוא ער ועומד” (all prophets prophesy in a dream or a vision, and Moses our teacher prophesies awake and standing, 7:6). Other prophets receive through an angel, see parables and riddles, and tremble; Moses spoke without an angel, saw the thing itself, and was calm, as a man speaks with his friend.

This matters because Moses' prophecy gave the Torah: a prophecy of a different rank means a Torah that no later prophet can replace, which is Maimonides' ninth principle.

### Another voice, and how to weigh them

Yehuda Halevi sees prophecy differently: it is a gift tied to the people and the land, “כל מי שנתנבא לא נתנבא כי אם בה או בעבורה” (whoever prophesied, prophesied only in it or for its sake, Kuzari 2:14), and not the fruit of philosophical perfection. For Maimonides the path to prophecy runs through study and character; for Halevi through God's choice of a people and its land.

A strong answer gives the three views of 2:32, Maimonides' definition, and what makes Moses different, and sets one other view beside them.

## Practice: prophecy according to Maimonides

For 11th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Maimonides writes: “דעות בני אדם בנבואה כדעותם בקדמות העולם וחידושו” (people's views on prophecy are like their views on the eternity or creation of the world). What does the comparison tell us about the structure of the discussion?** — In both cases there are three views, and in both the Torah's view stands in relation to the philosophers' view: on prophecy it accepts their view except in one point, divine will.
2. **Fill in the two empty boxes in the table of views.** — In the philosophers' view God plays no part: prophecy comes by nature to the perfect. In the Torah's view only the prepared can prophesy.
3. **The Torah's view: “שאנחנו נאמין שהראוי לנבואה המכין עצמו לה, אפשר שלא יתנבא וזה – ברצון אלהי” (one fit for prophecy who prepares for it may not prophesy, and that is by divine will). What is the one difference from the philosophers?** — For the philosophers a prepared person prophesies by necessity; for the Torah God can withhold prophecy even from one who is fit, as with Baruch son of Neriah, Jeremiah's student.
4. **Write the missing last step in Maimonides' definition of prophecy.** — Then to the imagination: after the intellect, the overflow reaches the imaginative faculty, which gives the prophecy its images and visions (2:36).
5. **“ואין הנבואה חלה אלא על חכם גדול בחכמה, גבור במדותיו” (prophecy rests only on one great in wisdom, strong in his traits). Why must a prophet have both wisdom and strong traits?** — Wisdom prepares the intellect to receive the overflow, and strength of character means he rules his desires, so nothing in him blocks the overflow or distorts it.
6. **Fill in Moses' two empty boxes in the table.** — When: awake and standing, not in a dream. His state: calm and unafraid, as a man speaks with his friend.
7. **Yehuda Halevi writes: “כל מי שנתנבא לא נתנבא כי אם בה או בעבורה” (whoever prophesied, prophesied only in it or for its sake). How does his view differ from Maimonides'?** — For Halevi prophecy depends on God's choice of a people and its land; for Maimonides it depends on the perfection of the person's intellect, character and imagination, with God's will able to withhold it.
8. **Write a paragraph: can anyone become a prophet according to Maimonides? Use the three views, one quotation and your own assessment.** — A good answer explains that only one perfect in wisdom, character and imagination, who has prepared, can prophesy (the third view), contrasts the many and the philosophers, quotes 2:32 or 7:1, and assesses the view fairly.

## Common questions

### Where does Maimonides discuss prophecy?

In the Guide for the Perplexed, part 2, chapters 32 to 48, and in the Mishneh Torah, Hilkhot Yesodei HaTorah, chapter 7. Prophecy is also the sixth and seventh of his thirteen principles.

### Can a foolish person become a prophet?

Not according to Maimonides. He rejects the view of the many that God chooses anyone; prophecy rests only on one who is wise, strong in character and prepared, and even then God may withhold it.

### What is the Active Intellect?

In medieval philosophy the Active Intellect is the last of the separate intellects, through which knowledge reaches human minds. Maimonides holds that the prophetic overflow passes from God through it.

### How was Moses' prophecy different?

In Yesodei HaTorah 7:6 Maimonides lists four differences: Moses prophesied awake, without an angel, seeing the thing itself rather than riddles, and without fear, as a man speaks to his friend.

### Does Yehuda Halevi agree with Maimonides on prophecy?

No. For Halevi prophecy is a divine gift tied to the people of Israel and its land (Kuzari 2:14), not the natural fruit of philosophical perfection, as it largely is for Maimonides.
