# What are the reasons for the commandments?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: Providence, Prophecy and the Commandments](https://lessoons.com/en/providence-prophecy-and-commandments) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/providence-prophecy-and-commandments/what-are-the-reasons-for-the-commandments

The question of the reasons for the commandments (ta'amei ha-mitzvot) asks whether each commandment has a purpose people can know. The Talmud distinguishes mishpatim, which reason would require, from chukim, whose reason is hidden. Maimonides holds that every commandment has a reason: to teach true beliefs, to set a just order or to train good traits, even where we do not yet see it.

## The topic explained

### Mishpatim and chukim

The Talmud sorts the commandments in two, reading Leviticus 18:4. On “אֶת־מִשְׁפָּטַי תַּעֲשׂוּ” (my laws you shall do) it says: “דברים שאלמלא (לא) נכתבו דין הוא שיכתבו” (things that, had they not been written, reason would require them to be written, Yoma 67b): idolatry, forbidden relations, bloodshed, robbery. On “וְאֶת־חֻקֹּתַי תִּשְׁמְרוּ” (and my statutes you shall keep): “דברים שהשטן משיב עליהן” (things the satan objects to): eating pork, wearing shaatnez, the goat sent away on Yom Kippur.

For the chukim the Talmud adds: “אני ה׳ חקקתיו, ואין לך רשות להרהר בהן” (I am the Lord, I decreed it, and you have no right to question it). The question of the reasons for the commandments, ta'amei ha-mitzvot, begins here. The common mistake is to think chukim have no reason at all; the Talmud says only that the reason is not given to us.

### Why the reasons were hidden

The Talmud even asks why: “מפני מה לא נתגלו טעמי תורה? שהרי שתי מקראות נתגלו טעמן, ונכשל בהן גדול העולם” (why were the reasons of the Torah not revealed? Because the reasons of two verses were revealed, and the greatest man in the world stumbled over them, Sanhedrin 21b). The Torah says of a king “וְלֹא יַרְבֶּה־לּוֹ נָשִׁים וְלֹא יָסוּר לְבָבוֹ” (he shall not have many wives, so that his heart not turn away, Deuteronomy 17:17).

Solomon, knowing the reason, said: “אני ארבה ולא אסור” (I will have many and not turn away). Yet “וַיְהִי לְעֵת זִקְנַת שְׁלֹמֹה נָשָׁיו הִטּוּ אֶת־לְבָבוֹ” (when Solomon was old, his wives turned his heart, 1 Kings 11:4). A reason invites a person to decide that the commandment does not apply to him.

### Maimonides: every commandment has a reason

Maimonides answers that all the commandments have a purpose, “והיות לכולם עילה אלא שאנחנו נסכול עילת קצתם ולא נדע אפני החכמה בהם” (they all have a cause, only we do not know the cause of some of them, nor the ways of wisdom in them, Guide 3:26). Mishpatim are those whose benefit the many see; chukim, those whose benefit is hidden from them. Otherwise, he argues, how could the nations call Israel “רַק עַם־חָכָם וְנָבוֹן הַגּוֹי הַגָּדוֹל הַזֶּה” (surely a wise and understanding people is this great nation, Deuteronomy 4:6)?

Each of the 613 commandments is “לנתינת דעת אמיתי, או להסיר דעת רע, או לנתינת סדר ישר, או להסיר עול, או להתלמד במדות טובות, או להזהיר ממדות רעות” (for giving a true belief, removing a bad belief, giving a just order, removing injustice, training in good traits or warning from bad traits, 3:31): beliefs, character and society.

### Seeking reasons, and keeping without them

Even in his law code Maimonides holds both sides: “ראוי לאדם להתבונן במשפטי התורה הקדושה ולידע סוף ענינם כפי כחו” (a person should reflect on the laws of the holy Torah and know their purpose as far as he can), yet “ודבר שלא ימצא לו טעם ולא ידע לו עלה אל יהי קל בעיניו” (a thing for which he finds no reason and knows no cause should not be light in his eyes, Hilkhot Me'ilah 8:8).

Other thinkers stress the hidden side: keeping a commandment because God commanded it, not because one understands it, is for them the heart of service. A strong answer gives the two kinds, the danger in reasons, Maimonides' view, and one objection.

## Practice: the reasons for the commandments

For 11th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **On “אֶת־מִשְׁפָּטַי תַּעֲשׂוּ” (my laws you shall do) the Talmud says: “דברים שאלמלא (לא) נכתבו דין הוא שיכתבו” (things that, had they not been written, reason would require them to be written). Give two examples and explain what makes them mishpatim.** — For example the bans on murder and robbery: every society sees why they are needed, so reason would demand them even without the Torah.
2. **Fill in the two empty boxes of the table.** — Chukim are commandments the satan mocks, whose reason is not given. The second example of mishpatim: do not rob.
3. **“אני ה׳ חקקתיו, ואין לך רשות להרהר בהן” (I am the Lord, I decreed it, and you have no right to question it). Does this mean chukim have no reason? Explain.** — No. It means the reason is not given and the commandment is kept because God decreed it; the Talmud does not say there is no reason, only that a person should not make his keeping depend on finding one.
4. **Write the end of Solomon's story in the diagram, and explain what it teaches.** — His wives turned his heart: Solomon knew the reason and thought it did not apply to him, and failed. Revealed reasons can lead a person to think he is the exception.
5. **Name the purpose replaced by a question mark, and give a commandment that serves it.** — Good traits: training in good character. Example: returning a lost object trains honesty and care for others.
6. **Maimonides writes: “והיות לכולם עילה אלא שאנחנו נסכול עילת קצתם ולא נדע אפני החכמה בהם” (they all have a cause, only we do not know the cause of some of them). How does he understand the difference between mishpatim and chukim?** — Both have reasons; the difference is only whether the benefit is clear to the many. Mishpatim are understood by all; chukim have a reason that is hidden from most people.
7. **“ודבר שלא ימצא לו טעם ולא ידע לו עלה אל יהי קל בעיניו” (a thing for which he finds no reason should not be light in his eyes). Why does Maimonides add this warning to his call to seek reasons?** — So that the search for reasons does not become a condition for keeping the commandment: a person who does not find a reason must still keep it seriously, as Solomon's story warns.
8. **Write a paragraph: is it good to seek reasons for the commandments? Present two views with a quotation from this sheet and your own position.** — A good answer presents Maimonides' view (all have reasons; seek them, 3:26 and Me'ilah 8:8) and the opposing caution (chukim, Solomon in Sanhedrin 21b), and argues a reasoned position fairly.

## Common questions

### What is the difference between chukim and mishpatim?

In Yoma 67b, mishpatim are commandments reason would require, such as the ban on murder; chukim are commandments whose reason is not given, such as the ban on shaatnez, which the satan and the nations mock.

### Did Maimonides think every commandment has a reason?

Yes. In Guide 3:26 he holds that all the commandments have a purpose, even those whose reason we do not know, and in 3:31 he groups the purposes under beliefs, character traits and the order of society.

### Why did the Torah not give reasons for most commandments?

Rabbi Yitzchak in Sanhedrin 21b answers that where the Torah gave a reason, King Solomon thought it did not apply to him and stumbled; a known reason can lead a person to make himself an exception.

### Do I need to know the reason to keep a commandment?

No, according to these sources. Maimonides urges seeking reasons, but writes in Hilkhot Me'ilah 8:8 that a commandment whose reason one does not find must not be taken lightly.

### What did Saadia Gaon say about the reasons for the commandments?

Saadia divided the commandments into commandments of reason, which the mind could reach, and commandments of hearing, known from revelation, though he held these too have benefits. See our page on Saadia Gaon.
