# Why did prophecy end?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: Prophecy and Revelation](https://lessoons.com/en/prophecy-and-revelation-in-jewish-thought) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/prophecy-and-revelation-in-jewish-thought/why-did-prophecy-end

According to the sages, prophecy ended with the last prophets, Haggai, Zechariah and Malachi, early in the Second Temple period, and after the Temple's destruction the authority to teach God's will passed to the sages. From then on the Torah was decided by study, argument and the majority, not by visions, as the story of the oven of Achnai shows.

## The topic explained

### When the holy spirit departed

Why did prophecy end, and when? The sages give a date for the end of prophecy: “משמתו נביאים האחרונים חגי זכריה ומלאכי נסתלקה רוח הקודש מישראל” (when the last prophets, Haggai, Zechariah and Malachi, died, the holy spirit departed from Israel, Sanhedrin 11a). They lived in the first generations after the return from Babylon, when the Second Temple was built.

Something smaller remained: “ואף על פי כן היו משתמשין בבת קול” (and even so, they still made use of a bat kol), a heavenly voice, literally the daughter of a voice. The same passage tells that such a voice once said that one of the sages present was worthy that the Divine Presence rest on him as on Moses, but his generation was not worthy of it, and the sages turned their eyes to Hillel the Elder.

### Taken from the prophets, given to the sages

Rabbi Avdimi of Haifa put it more boldly: “מיום שחרב בית המקדש ניטלה נבואה מן הנביאים וניתנה לחכמים” (from the day the Temple was destroyed, prophecy was taken from the prophets and given to the sages, Bava Batra 12a). The Talmud asks whether a sage is not a prophet, and explains: “אף על פי שניטלה מן הנביאים מן החכמים לא ניטלה” (although it was taken from the prophets, it was not taken from the sages).

Ameimar goes further: “וחכם עדיף מנביא” (and a sage is greater than a prophet). The common misreading is that the sages were second best, what remained when the real thing was gone. The Talmud says the opposite: insight that comes through learning and reasoning is not a lesser gift.

Rabbi Yochanan adds a sharper, almost ironic line: “מיום שחרב בית המקדש ניטלה נבואה מן הנביאים וניתנה לשוטים ולתינוקות” (from the day the Temple was destroyed, prophecy was taken from the prophets and given to fools and children, Bava Batra 12b). What is left of foresight outside the house of study is a chance remark, not a source of law.

### It is not in heaven

The story of the oven of Achnai tests the new order (Bava Metzia 59b). Rabbi Eliezer stands alone against the sages and calls on wonders: “אם הלכה כמותי חרוב זה יוכיח” (if the law is as I say, let this carob tree prove it), and the tree moves, a stream flows backward, the walls lean. Finally a heavenly voice declares that the law follows him.

Rabbi Yehoshua stands and quotes the Torah: “לֹא בַשָּׁמַיִם הִוא” (it is not in heaven, Deuteronomy 30:12). Rabbi Yirmiyah explains: “שכבר נתנה תורה מהר סיני אין אנו משגיחין בבת קול” (the Torah was already given at Mount Sinai; we pay no attention to a heavenly voice), for the Torah itself says to follow the majority. And when Rabbi Natan asked Elijah what God did at that hour, the answer was that He smiled and said “נצחוני בני נצחוני בני” (My children have defeated Me, My children have defeated Me).

### What changed, and why it matters

With the end of prophecy the Torah passed into human hands: a sage must bring a proof, can be answered, and can be outvoted. This is why the Talmud records minority views and arguments. Maimonides draws the legal rule from the same verse: “הא למדת שאין נביא רשאי לחדש דבר מעתה” (from this you learn that no prophet may innovate anything from now on, Hilkhot Yesodei HaTorah 9:1). A prophet who claims that God told him the law follows one sage is, for Maimonides, a false prophet, even if he shows a sign. A strong bagrut answer gives the sages' date for the end of prophecy, explains the claim that a sage is greater than a prophet, and reads the oven of Achnai as a story about where authority lies once heaven no longer decides.

## Practice: the end of prophecy

For 11th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Who were the last prophets, according to Sanhedrin 11a?** — Haggai, Zechariah and Malachi, who lived after the return from Babylon in the days of the Second Temple.
2. **Fill in the missing step: what remained after the last prophets died?** — A bat kol, a heavenly voice: the holy spirit departed, but they still made use of a bat kol.
3. **Rabbi Avdimi says: “מיום שחרב בית המקדש ניטלה נבואה מן הנביאים וניתנה לחכמים” (prophecy was taken from the prophets and given to the sages). How does the Talmud explain that a sage is also a kind of prophet?** — Prophecy was taken from the prophets but not from the sages: the insight into God's will continues through the sages' learning.
4. **Complete the table: who decides for the sages, and can a sage be argued with?** — The majority decides, and a sage can be argued with, since he brings a proof rather than a vision.
5. **Fill in Rabbi Yehoshua's answer in the oven of Achnai, and explain it.** — It is not in heaven (Deuteronomy 30:12): the Torah was given at Sinai, so a heavenly voice cannot decide the law; the majority of sages decides.
6. **God's answer is “נצחוני בני נצחוני בני” (My children have defeated Me). What does the smile in the story suggest about how God sees the sages' decision?** — That God accepts and even rejoices in it: the sages' authority to decide is part of the Torah God gave, not a rebellion against it.
7. **Write a paragraph: was the end of prophecy a loss or a new beginning? Use two sources.** — A good answer quotes Sanhedrin 11a or Bava Batra 12a and the oven of Achnai, explains what was lost (direct vision) and what was gained (a Torah decided by reasoning and argument), and reaches a reasoned view.

## Common questions

### When did prophecy end in Judaism?

According to Sanhedrin 11a, with the death of the last prophets, Haggai, Zechariah and Malachi, in the early Second Temple period. After them the sages speak of only a bat kol.

### What does a sage is greater than a prophet mean?

It is Ameimar's saying in Bava Batra 12a: wisdom gained through learning and reasoning is not lower than prophecy, and after prophecy ended it continued through the sages.

### What is a bat kol?

Literally the daughter of a voice: a heavenly voice that the sages say was still heard after prophecy ended, though it could not decide Jewish law.

### What is the oven of Achnai?

A story in Bava Metzia 59b in which Rabbi Eliezer's miracles and a heavenly voice fail to overturn the majority of sages, because the Torah is not in heaven.

### What does lo bashamayim hi mean?

It is not in heaven, Deuteronomy 30:12. The sages read it to mean that after the Torah was given at Sinai, its law is decided by people, not by voices from heaven.
