# What do twin studies show about personality?

> Written with AI · [Psychology: theories of personality](https://lessoons.com/en/personality-theories) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/personality-theories/what-do-twin-studies-show-about-personality

Twin studies show that about 40 to 60 percent of the differences between people in personality traits go with differences in their genes. Identical twins, who share almost all their genes, are more alike in personality than fraternal twins, who share about half, even when raised apart. Growing up in the same family makes siblings only a little alike; most of the rest comes from each person's own experiences.

## The topic explained

### Why twins are a natural experiment

Identical twins (monozygotic, MZ) come from one fertilized egg and share about 100 percent of their genes. Fraternal twins (dizygotic, DZ) come from two eggs and, like ordinary siblings, share about 50 percent of the genes that vary between people, on average. Both kinds are usually raised in the same home at the same time. So if identical twins are more alike in a trait than fraternal twins, the extra likeness points to genes.

Twin studies of personality measure the trait, often with a Big Five questionnaire, in hundreds of pairs, and calculate how strongly twins' scores go together, a correlation from 0 (no likeness) to 1 (identical). Comparing the two correlations gives an estimate of heritability. Researchers also study twins who were separated early and raised by different families, and compare twins with adopted siblings, so that the effect of genes and of the home can be pulled apart in more than one way.

### Calculating heritability

Heritability is the share of the differences between people in a trait, within a particular population, that goes with differences in their genes. A simple estimate is Falconer's formula: twice the difference between the identical and the fraternal correlation. With illustrative numbers, if identical twins correlate 0.50 on extraversion and fraternal twins 0.25, the difference is 0.25 and the heritability about 0.50, or 50 percent.

Real studies give numbers close to this. Jang, Livesley and Vernon (1996) studied 123 identical and 127 fraternal pairs and estimated the heritability of the Big Five at 41 percent for neuroticism, 53 for extraversion, 61 for openness, 41 for agreeableness and 44 for conscientiousness. A meta-analysis by Polderman and colleagues (2015), combining fifty years of twin studies of many traits, found an average heritability of 49 percent.

### Raised apart, and the surprise about families

The strongest test is twins separated early and raised in different homes. In the Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart, Bouchard and colleagues (1990) found that identical twins raised apart were about as similar in personality as identical twins raised together. The more surprising finding is about the shared environment, everything siblings have in common, the same parents, home and neighborhood: it explains little of the differences in personality. The rest of the variance comes from the non-shared environment, experiences unique to each person, different friends, teachers, illnesses, chance events, and from measurement error. Robert Plomin and Denise Daniels (1987) put the question as why children in the same family are so different.

### What heritability does not mean

The common mistake is to read 50 percent heritability as "half of my personality comes from my genes." Heritability describes differences in a population, not a single person, and it can change when environments change. It also does not mean a trait is fixed: a highly heritable trait can still respond to experience. Twin studies have limits too. They assume that identical twins are not treated more alike than fraternal twins, the equal environments assumption, which critics doubt; twins may not represent everyone; and separated twins were often placed in similar homes. A good answer gives an estimate, explains what it means, and names a limit. Genes and environment also work together: a child who is naturally curious may seek out books and people that feed that curiosity, so a genetic tendency can shape the environment a person ends up in.

## Practice: twin studies and personality

For 12th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Fill in the share of genes each kind of twin has in common.** — Identical (MZ): about 100 percent. Fraternal (DZ): about 50 percent on average, like ordinary siblings.
2. **Why does comparing identical and fraternal twins tell us something about genes?** — Both kinds usually share a home, but identical twins share about twice as many of the genes that vary. If they are more alike, the extra likeness points to genes.
3. **Calculate the difference and the heritability using Falconer's formula. Show your work.** — Difference: 0.46 − 0.20 = 0.26. Heritability: 2 × 0.26 = 0.52, about 52 percent.
4. **What heritability did Jang, Livesley and Vernon (1996) find for openness? Which two traits had the lowest heritability?** — Openness: 61 percent, the highest of the five. The lowest were neuroticism and agreeableness, 41 percent each.
5. **A student says: "Extraversion is 53 percent heritable, so 53 percent of my extraversion comes from my genes." What is wrong with this?** — Heritability describes the differences between people in a population, not how much of one person's trait comes from genes. It can also change in different environments.
6. **What did twin studies find about the shared environment, and what explains the rest?** — The shared family environment explains surprisingly little of the differences in personality. Most of the rest comes from the non-shared environment, experiences unique to each child, plus measurement error.
7. **Evaluate twin studies as evidence about the origins of personality: one strength and two limits.** — A good answer gives a strength (a natural comparison of genetic likeness; consistent results across studies, Jang et al. 1996, Polderman et al. 2015; twins raised apart, Bouchard et al. 1990) and two limits (the equal environments assumption; heritability is a population statistic that can change; separated twins often in similar homes; twins may not represent everyone), and concludes.

## Common questions

### Are identical twins the same personality?

No. They are more alike than fraternal twins, but their personality scores correlate about 0.5, far from 1. Their different experiences, friends and choices make each of them a distinct person.

### What is the Minnesota twins study?

The Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart, led by Thomas Bouchard, studied twins separated early in life. Bouchard and colleagues (1990) found that identical twins raised apart were about as alike in personality as identical twins raised together.

### Does high heritability mean a trait cannot change?

No. Heritability describes differences in a population under current conditions. A trait can be strongly heritable and still change with experience, and a change in the environment can change the heritability itself.

### Why are children in the same family so different?

Twin and adoption studies suggest that the shared family environment has little effect on personality. Each child also has unique experiences, a different place in the family, different friends and events, which together make siblings differ.

### Are twin studies the only way to study genes and personality?

No. Adoption studies compare children with their biological and adoptive parents, and newer molecular studies look at many genes across the genome. Each has its own strengths and limits.
