# What did the Hawthorne studies find?

> Written with AI · [Sociology: organizations and the world of work](https://lessoons.com/en/organizations-and-the-world-of-work) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/organizations-and-the-world-of-work/what-did-the-hawthorne-studies-find

The Hawthorne studies (1924–1932), at a Western Electric factory near Chicago, found that output depended on more than lighting or pay. Workers responded to attention and to their work group, and in the bank wiring room the men set their own unwritten limit on output. The studies made the informal organization famous, though later re-analyses found the effects much weaker than claimed.

## The topic explained

### Lights up, lights down

The Hawthorne studies took their name from Western Electric's Hawthorne Works near Chicago, which made telephone equipment. They began in 1924 with a simple question: does better lighting raise output? Engineers set up an experiment room, where the light was changed, and a control room, where it stayed the same. Output rose in both rooms, whether the light went up or down, and fell only when the room was almost as dark as moonlight. The light was not the cause. Something about being part of the experiment was. A careful reader notices what the control room was for: it should have stayed flat, and it did not.

Harvard researchers led by Elton Mayo joined in, and F. J. Roethlisberger of Harvard and W. J. Dickson of the company did most of the work on site until 1932. Their full account, Management and the Worker, appeared in 1939. The findings of the Hawthorne studies changed how sociologists look at a workplace.

### The relay assembly test room

From 1927 six women who assembled telephone relays worked in a separate room, watched by an observer who talked with them. Rest breaks, snacks and a shorter day were added one at a time. Output usually rose, and often went on rising even when the old conditions came back. Only one change, six five-minute breaks that kept interrupting the work, brought it down. The researchers concluded that the women worked harder because they had become a group, were treated as special and had a friendly supervisor.

The misreading to avoid: the studies did not show that rest breaks or snacks are what matter. They suggested that the social side of work, attention and the group, can matter more than the physical conditions.

### The bank wiring room: the informal organization

From November 1931 to May 1932 an observer sat with fourteen men wiring telephone switch equipment. The company paid by output, yet the men kept to about two units a day, which they saw as a fair day's work, for fear that faster work would lead the company to cut the rate. They had unwritten rules: a man who worked too much was a rate-buster, one who worked too little a chiseler, and one who told a supervisor something that harmed a coworker a squealer. Ridicule and exclusion kept everyone in line. The observer also saw two cliques inside the one room, with their own games, jokes and favors, which the company's chart did not show at all.

This is the informal organization: the norms and relationships that grow inside the formal organization of charts, rules and pay. Every workplace has both, and the informal one can support the formal goals or work against them.

### What changed, and what the critics found

The studies gave rise to the human relations approach to management, and to the Hawthorne effect: people change how they act when they know they are being studied. The critics have been sharp. Alex Carey (1967) argued that the evidence could not support the conclusions. Franke and Kaul (1978) re-analyzed the relay room data and found that stricter discipline, the economic slump and the quality of materials explained most of the output. In 2011 Steven Levitt and John List found the lost lighting data and saw only a slight effect. Harry Braverman added that the studies hid conflict over power and pay. A strong answer gives the findings and their limits.

The lasting lesson does not depend on the size of any one effect. Sociologists still study the informal organization of hospitals, armies, schools and offices, because every workplace runs partly on the unwritten rules its members make, and researchers still guard against changing what they study by watching it.

## Practice: the Hawthorne studies

For 12th grade students of sociology. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Write the name of the last phase of the Hawthorne studies.** — The bank wiring room (1931–1932), where an observer watched fourteen men at work.
2. **In the lighting experiment, what was the control room for, and why did the result surprise the engineers?** — The control room kept the light the same, so any change in the experiment room could be traced to the light. Output rose in both rooms, so the light could not be the cause.
3. **Complete the table: what happened to output when the old conditions came back?** — It often still rose, which led the researchers to look for a social cause rather than a physical one.
4. **Complete the table of the bank wiring room's unwritten rules.** — A worker who worked too much was a rate-buster; one who worked too little was a chiseler.
5. **Fill in the informal column of the grid.** — Who sets it: the work group; form: unwritten.
6. **Complete the table: what did Levitt and List find in 2011?** — Only a slight effect: the recovered lighting data gave much weaker evidence for a Hawthorne effect than the original story.
7. **In a call center the team agrees, without saying it aloud, that no one answers more than 60 calls a shift, and a new worker who answers 90 is mocked. Write a paragraph explaining the case with the bank wiring room, and say what management could learn.** — A good answer names an informal norm on output, enforced by ridicule like the rate-buster label, and notes the formal pay and targets beside it. It suggests management learn the group's reasons, such as fear of higher targets, rather than only adding incentives.

## Common questions

### What is the Hawthorne effect?

The change in people's behavior when they know they are being observed or studied. It is named after the Hawthorne studies, although later re-analyses found the effect in the original data much smaller than first reported.

### What is the difference between formal and informal organization?

Formal organization is the official structure: the chart, the written rules and the pay system set by management. Informal organization is the unwritten norms, friendships and cliques that workers create among themselves.

### Who carried out the Hawthorne studies?

Western Electric engineers began them in 1924. Harvard researchers led by Elton Mayo joined them; F. J. Roethlisberger of Harvard and W. J. Dickson of the company, who wrote Management and the Worker (1939), did most of the work.

### Why are the Hawthorne studies criticized?

Small groups, changes made several at a time, two workers replaced in the relay room and the Depression in the background make the results hard to read. Re-analyses found discipline and economic conditions explained much of the output.

### What is the human relations school?

An approach to management that grew from the Hawthorne studies. It holds that workers' feelings, attention from supervisors and the work group affect output, not only pay and physical conditions.
