# Why do journalists protect their sources?

> Written with AI · [News and journalism](https://lessoons.com/en/news-and-journalism) · Grade 10 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/news-and-journalism/why-do-journalists-protect-their-sources

Journalists protect their sources because many important stories come from people who would lose their jobs, or worse, if they were named. If promises of confidentiality were broken, such people would stop talking and the public would learn less. In Israel this journalistic privilege rests on a 1987 Supreme Court ruling and the Press Council's ethics code, and a court may lift it only in exceptional cases.

## The topic explained

### Where news comes from

Most of what a journalist reports was not seen by the journalist. It comes from sources: people, documents and records. A primary source has direct knowledge, such as a witness, a participant or the original document. A secondary source passes on what others saw or said, such as a neighbor who heard about it or another outlet's report. A good reporter climbs from the secondary source to the primary one before publishing.

Before an interview, reporter and source agree on the ground rules. On the record: everything may be published with the source's name. On background: the facts may be used, but the source is only described, as in “a city engineer”. Off the record: nothing may be published; it helps the reporter understand. Newsrooms define these terms a little differently, so the rule is to agree on them before the source speaks, not after.

### Why the promise matters

Journalists protect their sources because the most important information is often held by people with the most to lose: an employee who sees a cover-up, a worker who knows a building is unsafe. If they are named they may be fired, sued or threatened. A reporter who promises confidentiality and keeps the promise makes it possible for them to speak; a reporter who breaks it warns every future source to stay silent. Lawyers call this fear a chilling effect.

The best-known case is Watergate. The Washington Post reporters Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein relied on a source they called Deep Throat. His identity was kept secret for about thirty years, until Mark Felt, who had been the FBI's second-ranking official, revealed it himself in May 2005.

### Journalistic privilege in Israel

No Israeli statute grants journalistic privilege, the right of a journalist to refuse to name a source in court. It was recognized by the Supreme Court in the Citrin case of 1987: two journalists who would not name their sources to the Bar Association's disciplinary tribunal had been fined, and the court weighed the needs of justice against the free flow of information to the press. The privilege is strong but not absolute: a court may order disclosure only in exceptional cases, after weighing both sides.

The ethics code of the Israel Press Council, founded in 1963, adds a professional duty: a journalist does not reveal a source who was promised confidentiality without that source's consent. The common mistake is to think privilege protects the journalist. It protects the source, and through the source, the public's access to information.

### The price of anonymity

Anonymous sources have a cost. Readers cannot judge who is speaking or why, and a source may use anonymity to attack a rival without answering for it. So careful newsrooms set limits: use an unnamed source only when the information is important, cannot be had on the record and comes from someone with direct knowledge; confirm it with a second, independent source; and tell readers as much as possible about the source, such as “a member of the committee who attended the meeting”.

A strong exam answer explains the reason for protection (sources at risk, the flow of information), names the limit (a court in exceptional cases, the risk of misuse) and gives an example.

## Practice: why journalists protect their sources

For 10th grade communications students. The story about a water leak and its sources are made up. Answer from what is printed here, then check yourself against the answers.

1. **Write primary or secondary for each made-up source in a story about a burst water main.** — Worker who saw the leak: primary. The city's inspection report: primary (the original document). Neighbor who heard of it: secondary. Story on another site: secondary.
2. **Fill in the missing row of the table: what may be published when a source speaks on background?** — On background: the facts may be published, but the source is only described (for example “a city engineer”), not named.
3. **A source tells a reporter: “This is off the record,” after she has already told him everything. What is the problem, and what should a reporter do next time?** — Ground rules should be agreed before the source speaks; a condition added afterwards may not bind the reporter, and the two may understand it differently. Next time the reporter agrees on the rules at the start and checks that both mean the same thing.
4. **Explain the chilling effect in one or two sentences.** — If journalists broke their promises of confidentiality, future sources would fear being exposed and would stay silent, so important information would stop reaching the public.
5. **Complete the empty side of the scale: what reasons stand against protecting a source in court?** — Revealing the source can serve the search for truth in a trial and the rights of an accused person; in Israel a court may order disclosure, but only in exceptional cases after weighing both sides.
6. **What did the Supreme Court decide in the Citrin case (1987), and why is it important when there is no law on the subject?** — It recognized journalistic privilege: journalists may refuse to name their sources, and the court weighs the needs of justice against the free flow of information, lifting the privilege only in exceptional cases. With no statute, this ruling is the main legal source of the privilege in Israel.
7. **Look at the chain in the diagram. A made-up site reveals the name of a source it promised to protect. Which link breaks, and what happens to the links after it?** — The promise of secrecy breaks. Future sources no longer trust reporters, so they stop taking the risk; fewer facts reach the public and others no longer dare to speak.
8. **Should a news site publish a claim from a single anonymous source? Write a short balanced answer and a conclusion.** — A good answer gives a reason for (the information may be important and impossible to get on the record, and the source may be at risk) and a reason against (readers cannot judge the source, and it may be misused to attack someone), then concludes with conditions: direct knowledge, confirmation by a second independent source and as much description of the source as possible.

## Common questions

### What is journalistic privilege?

The right of a journalist to refuse to reveal a source, including in court. In Israel it is not written in a law; it was recognized by the Supreme Court in 1987 and can be lifted only in exceptional cases, after the court weighs the need for the evidence against the free flow of information.

### What is the difference between off the record and on background?

Off the record means nothing the source says may be published. On background means the information may be used, but the source is not named, only described, such as “an official in the ministry”. Newsrooms define the terms differently, so they are agreed in advance.

### Can a journalist go to prison for protecting a source?

In some countries journalists have been jailed for contempt of court when they refused an order to name a source. In Israel the privilege is recognized by the courts, so such an order is rare, but it is possible in exceptional cases.

### Why do news sites use anonymous sources if readers distrust them?

Because some important facts are known only to people who would be harmed if named. Careful newsrooms limit anonymous sources to such cases, confirm what they say with a second source and describe them as fully as they can without naming them.

### Who was Deep Throat?

The secret source of the Washington Post's Watergate reporting in the 1970s. In May 2005 Mark Felt, who had been the FBI's second-ranking official, revealed that he was the source; the reporters had kept his identity secret for about thirty years.
